New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Starting resaw

Posts

Starting resaw

#1

Starting resaw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

New writing desk project involves veneering both sides of a Baltic birch ply top. 3/32" to 1/8" veneers top and bottom. My friend Konrad Sauer already resawed the show side satinwood on his bandsaw. Could not believe the yield he got out of that single board.

I need balancing veneer for the bottom side of the top. I have some sugar maple, so will use that for the balancing veneer and interior framing of the drawer box. I have a small bandsaw, but it won't handle the 9" wide maple board I need the veneers from. So I need to hand resaw two 1/8" maple veneers, 9" x 38". Have begun that job, and it's not a real tough job, just takes a while.

Here's the work getting started:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8220626129/in/set-72157632104394661/

Closer shot of saw and kerf:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8221704260/in/set-72157632104394661/

Saw is a Mitsukawa rip, 425mm (17"), 3-1/2ppi, with rake angle 0 to just a hair negative (aggressive; tilted in direction of cut). I started the kerf with a smaller saw, then switched to this saw after I had about an inch of kerf on both faces.

At first, I was a little disappointed when I received this saw in the mail, thinking the toothing was too coarse for dry hardwood. But it seems just right in use. I had left the toothing up to Mitsukawa--just told him I wanted to resaw hardwood. I made the order through Tomohito Iida, and he did a fine job as go-between. I've had nothing but good experience with Tomohito. Here he is:

http://japantool-iida.com/faq/2008/05/how-to-order-2.html

I can't get to my regular bench to do this work, because of the way life around the house is arranged (don't want to wake my wife). So made up a small bench I could stash on the porch. It's less than 4' long, but it's what this desk is gonna get made on. It's sturdy: LV's cast iron leg set, with 2-1/4" butcher block top from McMaster Carr (Rob Lee suggested them for this item!); wrapped the top on two sides with a 2" x 7" apron; hung an LV twin screw vise on one end.

Will post updates from time to time.

Wiley

Re: Starting resaw

#2

Looks like it's working really well Wiley.


Re: Starting resaw

#3

Midway resaw?

Bill Tindall

I have made a play on your words to introduce a question. I have often thought about resawing something with a hand powered saw but never did more than think about it before finding a means to band saw the veneer. The anticipation was that midway in the course of resawing the saw would be difficult to control and the resaw kerf would wander about. So, beyond the start, which even I could accomplish successfully, how did the rest of the resawing proceed? Like many things woodworking, if I see someone else successfully doing it I am motivated to try it.

Re: Starting resaw

#4

Re: Midway resaw? Update

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I'm about 80% through the first veneer. Haven't timed my heads-down work, but I would guess maybe 30-40 minutes of actual sawing. Time passes slowly when resawing sugar maple.

My approach has been to start both corners, saw a 'pyramid', then cut down the pyramid; then make a new pyramid. I also started both ends, to meet in the middle. Another way to look at the work in progress is, you're making a miter box, where the saw will become self-guiding on the right track. I look at all sawing as constructing a miter box. Anyway, when making the pyramids, I advance the kerf well ahead of where I actually am at the time (dunno if any of this is right--all critiques welcome).

Here's a (blurry, sorry) shot at about 75%. Here I'm working on my 'short' end, and plan to finish the resaw from the short end later this morning. In this picture, I'm sawing down a pyramid:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8227762988/in/set-72157632104394661/

You queried whether the kerf wanders. Not with a plate saw, but more on this below--I will discuss what goes wrong, to add some interest to the subject. It's hard to see in this picture, due to the blurring, but if you blow this up, you'll see a thin stick in the kerf just above the saw, to cut friction as much as possible.

Meantime, at 75%, the board is kerfed in all around. Here is what the kerf looks like on one long side--pretty even:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8226692565/in/set-72157632104394661/

What goes wrong....there's a couple ways to attack hand resaw, use a big frame saw, with say a 1-1/2" wide saw in it. This is the classic way, as I understand it. The other way is to use a coarse plate saw, as I am doing. You're picking your poison: I can see how a frame saw could wander in unaccustomed hands. But with a plate saw, once you've connected up the kerfs on your first pyramid, and start sawing down the apex of the pyramid, the saw really has to place to go, except straight down within the kerfs you've established.

But. When making those pyramids--especially the first one--the kerfs you've started from either corner need to lie in the same plane. As you pointed out, it's not much of a trick to start the corners. However, the marks have to be accurately gauged, and the fidelity of the saw to the marks has to be very close, particularly in a wide board. In a narrow board, like when I was resawing 4x4's not so long ago down to 2x4's, it wasn't so critical to be accurate. When I started this board, I thought I was right on the money. But you don't have to be off by much--in the low thousandths I think for 9" maple--to create friction. Or maybe there was some reaction in the wood, it's hard to tell. Anyway, that's why I'm using the stick of wood to keep the kerf above the saw as wide as possible.

I hope to finish the board this morning, and will show what it looks like when you open it up.

Wiley

Re: Starting resaw

#5

The moment of truth

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

and it ain't that pretty. I have to take back most of what I said in the above post about the plate saw won't wander. It did! One piece of data is worth a thousand theories. And "low thousandths" is LOL; add that to the list of embarrassing stuff I has said.

Here's the two pieces apart, the veneer on the left, the stock on the right. You can see some diagonal discontinuities where the kerf is disjoint:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8226920571/in/set-72157632104394661/

It's impossible to see in the above picture, but the veneer has a belly in it, about half way down, and the stock has a matching hollow. I'm sawing between 1/8" and 5/32" thick, the belly gets to about 1/4" thick, by eye. Oddly, the belly is totally hidden in the interior of the resaw; the kerfs follow their line all around the periphery on 4 sides.

Here's a look at the ends of the boards, the veneer piece nearest us, and the stock just beyond it. Note that the veneer piece is cupped about 1/8". Starting out, the board had just the slightest cup, so there was some reaction from the wood going on:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8226920801/in/set-72157632104394661/

Some analysis....

Point 1: Cup in the board. I left a very small amount of cup in the board before starting sawing. I figured, so what? Now looking back, that means that the gauge mark I was sawing to on the end of the board had that same curvature. Well, I can't saw a curve with that saw, but it would mean that my starting points from the two sides of the board were a little bit out of plane with each other. I would have done better to start out sawing straight across the end of the board!

Point 2: Reaction in the wood. I didn't pay attention to whether I took my first veneer from the outside of the tree or the inside. As it happens, I started from the inside of the tree. I think it would have been more sensible to start cutting from the outside of the tree, to relieve tension in the wood--does this make sense, or not?

I should have the other veneer sawn in a few days. Will show you that one as well, and we'll see if I've learned anything.

All commentary/critique is welcome!

Wiley

Re: Starting resaw

#6

Well.......

Bill Tindall

I don't have any fewer problems band sawing...its just quicker to discover them.

As a practical matter, I dull the teeth of the band saw after sawing several flitches of something hard like maple. How is the hand saw holding up? It doesn't seem like many teeth doing a lot of work. Can you resharpen it? (sorry totally ignorant about Japanese saws).

BTW, Will Neptune saws tenons just like your resaw project. Saw from each side and then saw out the middle.

Re: Starting resaw

#7

Re: The moment of truth

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When I first started resawing I cut the corners first, but found that it is better to put the board vertical in the vise and saw straight across (horizontally). Both Diderot and Roubo illustrate this method from the 18th century.

Most bellying is caused by twisting the saw. The saw gets off line so you twist it to get back. This causes the saw to bend the opposite way inside the cut which makes it want to wander worse and you twist harder, a vicious cycle. I recommend being extremely gentle in correcting the cut.

Re: Starting resaw

#8

Re: The moment of truth

Tony Wilkins

Is resawing something that is done much in Japanese carpentry? I know most sawing was traditionally done on a board across two low saw benches.

Re: Starting resaw

#9

Re: The moment of truth

Patrick Gibbons

Resawing is frustrating. I always saw thick to give me enough wood left to correct with the plane. I always saw from both ends even if the saw doesn't seem to be wandering. Any cup or other variation in the wood is magnified in the cutting. I think you did great. Nothing at all to be ashamed of. I wish I could achieve those results every time.

Re: Starting resaw

#10

Re: The moment of truth

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tony,

Historically, there had to be a way to reduce whole trees to boards for tansu. What I have read is that the Chinese frame saw was introduced in Japan about 1400, and then it was superceded by the mae-biki oga beginning ca. 1600. These saws were to produce whole boards.

That said, I don't know whether there is any tradition of veneering in Japan. I kinda doubt it, because they traditionally have had a different aesthetic there, in which artifice plays little or no role. However, I don't know--perhaps Tom can add something. Also, it's hard to generalize about Japanese woodworking methods, in that there were at least three separate trades: the temple carpenters at the top of the profession; the tansu (furniture) makers; and the shokunin, who traveled to peoples' homes to install and repair shoji screens, doors, and other household elements. Those mae-biki guys were a sub trade, making boards for the builders and craftsmen. Toshio Odate was a shokunin. The temple carpentry exams--which include sawing difficulty joints against the clock--are legendarily difficult even for an advanced western woodworker (Chris Hall has described them).

So discussing 'how they work' has to depend on which profession we're talking about. In The Workbench Book, Makoto Imai shows a pretty substantial bench--big beams laid on trestles, standing maybe 30" off the ground (from memory)--without vises as I recall. In the six videos posted here recently, originally by Wilbur Pan, the craftsman (in video 2), was working close to the floor, and did his cutoffs on the fly and by eye, while sitting, hanging the board over another low board or floor-dwelling bench, and using a ryoba. If you blinked, he was done.

Wiley

Re: Starting resaw

#12

Made changes;  sawing second veneer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Started sawing the second veneer slab today, and am very stoked! Sugar maple; 1/8" veneer. It's going well. And particularly want to thank Warren, who made some suggestions, which I am following. The thrust of Warren's suggestions was--said in a gentle way--that I was going about things the wrong way. Which is true, and I particularly want to retract some of the method I put forward initially in this thread.

Item 1. Triangles vs. straight down. On the first veneer, I sawed in a series of fairly steep pyramids, like 45 degree angles, working in from the corners. I ended up with mismatching kerfs and a belly in the veneer. Warren said he goes straight down now. So I started by kerfing across the top, then working down the sides about an inch, then catching the middle up. And so forth. Am leading the cut by kerfing down the side, but no more than an inch or two at the time, and then catching the middle up, so that the effect is pretty much straight down. With the pull saw, you can make an over-the-top-and-down sort of circular stroke, so that even when you're extending the kerf down the side, you can still come over the top, and keep the total cut in the same plane--which is the key, keeping the whole cut in the same plane by not letting the edges get ahead of the middle.

Item 2. Inside of tree or outside of tree. This veneer is from the outside of the tree; the first was from the inside. There is some tension in this board, even though I've had it for better than 5 years in the dry. Cutting from the outside of the tree is releasing tension--the veneer initially cups outward away from the stock (you'll see this below), before returning to a straight condition. In future, I will always start the resaw with the idea of releasing tension in the wood (this is with plain-sawn lumber, of course).

Here is the side view, I'm about half way done:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8230935100/in/set-72157632104394661/

Here is an edge view, the saw is running free in the kerf, and no bellying; the veneer is cupping slightly away from the kerf, then straightening up, I believe indicating a release of tension:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8230935244/in/set-72157632104394661/

Will show the finished work when I open it up tomorrow or the next day. So far, it's like night and day compared to the first veneer, and much appreciation for the suggestions, especially Warren's.

Wiley