New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

Posts

Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#1

Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

Tony Wilkins

I've been trying to get my planes in wood whenever possible as they are lighter and easier on my fatigue. To that end I have a try, jack, and smoother all in wood. There are two I wonder if wood is the right way to go - plow and moving filister. I'd get the veritas in both if I didn't get woodies. So what are the pro's and cons in each side of this.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#2

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

Get the Small Veritas Plow. It is a light plane. I doubt very much that you will find a woodie that is significantly lighter. More importantly, the Small Plow has ergonomic advantages over unhandled wooden ploughs - it is balanced and comfortable to hold, and the adjustments are easy to make.


It may be possible to get away with the Small Plow as a pseudo-filletster as well as there are wide blades available. Of course it will still be a plough as it has a skate, but it is worth trying out for the cost of a blade.

If you can run to it, the Veritas Skew Rabbet Plane is worth adding to the tool chest. Alternately, see if you can find a Record #778. I have a ECE unhandled Filletster. It is an excellent plane, but I prefer the ease of setting up and adjusting the Veritas or Record.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/Raisingapanel.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#3

Re: The weight vs handling conundrum

Bruce McCrory

Good recommendations, Derek. I find spare, starved horse look--actually, the skeleton--of metal tools to be much easier to handle than the bulk of wood.

Weight is not the only consideration. I'd rather carry a brief case with exhibit folded, than a 36x48 art binder in the wind.

Even the LV-LAS (Veritas low angle smoother) I have now competes with the other heavy's in its class. It has multiple functions also. I consider it achingly light, but am warming to it. Brute force and weight work better only in the initial rough squaring.

I am extremely fond of my even lighter block planes. Keep them whisker-shaving sharp and they are a handy substitute for anything bigger.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#4

Near a store to test drive?

Bruce McCrory

You can quickly assess comfort and usefulness of tools, equipment, or hardware in a store, or even a shop that offers classes. And, best of all you can custom design what works best for you.

I remember my own frustration in finding computer equipment to better aide my growing arthritis. A salesman brought a few things to the office, had me test drive them. No. No help. Finally, I drove down to the store--a whole 3 miles--and shopped.

BTW, wait until after surgeries and repairs have stabilized to do your shopping. I have a $27k car that is not so comfortable, after a back surgery.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#5

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

TomD

There are only three planes were I like the metal versions better at some level. Jointer, rebate, and block. The metal jointer is always the way I left it. If I had a lot of work to do or it was cold, I would reach for the lighter wooden one. Same thing with the rebate, it is a little fragile in the wooden forms, and can go out of nick. The block plane is more a mater of jamming everything into the smaller space. I guess I also bought these tools at a certain point, or got them as gifts. I could use the wooden version only.

I prefer those tools in wooden form. Metal ones could be made, but I don't think the quality is there yet. I hate grub screws and rusty metals. I would rather wedges and premium wood. If these products were made to Bogdon reel quality I might be interested. And then decide I couldn't afford them. :) I just don't like the solutions so far.

Ergonomics is rarely a one feature thing. Like a better handle? Wait till your hands don't like those cold little sharp cornered thumb screws. Or tapping vs screws, much more controllable. Or the ability to turn a blade around in 20 seconds with movements from a major muscle group. I think the advice to wait until you get a stable physical base is sound, unless you don't mind repeating some purchases, which is a pleasure for many. No mater what one does, one is likely to find something later that seems like it would be an improvement.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#6

Re: The weight vs handling conundrum

TomD

In almost all cases I prefer a lighter plane to a heavier one. There are cases where it helps, or does not hurt much. Mostly weight seems to help with end grain, and short run up situations like some block plane or shooting applications. But in almost all cases lighter is better. Lighter, slippery, and good geometry.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#7

Re: The weight vs handling conundrum

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

High mass vs low mass ..

I have both. I much prefer the agility of a light plane when smoothing or trimming, but high mass is preferred when working hard woods or where momentum will be an aid, such as on a shooting board.

My recommendations were with Tony's needs in mind. He requested a plane of low mass. However low mass without comfort/ergonomics would be a mistake. For example, the Record #043 is tiny and light, but it would be awkward to hold.

I can compare the low mass Veritas Small Plow with my own high mass wooden plow. They are so different. the Veritas is like a scalpel as it slices through wood. My woodie is like a tank and nothing stands in its way. Both have there place for me. The woodie would be inappropriate for Tony.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#8

Re: The weight vs handling conundrum

Bruce McCrory

I think Derek and I are on the same passenger list, here.

Two pounds of metal vs two of maple becomes a comparative choice in ease of handling, tuning, adjusting--ergonomics--and storage. Is a drop to the floor an ergonomic complication, or better for one over the other; metal vs wood survival?

As I later commented, unless Mr. Wilkins can touch, feel, and experience the whole shop atmosphere, he's watering into the wind and mostly on himself. Costly miscalculations may be the norm, otherwise.

Some unsolicited advice:

One extremely important consideration [warning] is never to make decisions or spend money while on prescription pain medicine. Anyone who has, understands my advice in this regard. That stuff is pure wacko juice, but you don't realize it. If there is no choice, be sure to have competent help to advise.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#9

Re: The weight vs handling conundrum

Tony Wilkins

Derek, thanks as always for the sage advice.

Mr. McCrory, what exactly do you mean by:

As I later commented, unless Mr. Wilkins can touch, feel, and experience the whole shop atmosphere, he's watering into the wind and mostly on himself. Costly miscalculations may be the norm, otherwise.

I have gathered up mostly wooden planes because in the cases of those I have they are lighter than there metal counterparts. Due to a lack of strength due to nerve damage in my arms, mass is not the best option. Derek answered thoughtfully knowing that limitation. The wooden plow and filester I didn't believe would follow that same logic. Though beautiful to look at, neither is lighter nor as ergonomic as it's metal kin. I wasn't totally sure of that fact so I asked the question.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#10

Another consideration

Patrick Gibbons

Both a plow and fillester need to be guided to make a rabbet or groove that is square. The floor of the groove or rabbet must be parallel to the board with their walls at 90 degrees. I had a Record 778 which I recently sold. I find the Veritas is easier to keep square. I also realized I exerted a lot of force and effort with the Record to try and maintain this correct orientation. Part of the problem is that I am left-handed and the Record is a right-handed tool. I had a similar experience with a Stanley combo vs a Veritas plow. I seem to remember reading somewhere that wooden plows and rabbet planes are easier to maintain correct orientation. I do not have any personal experience with this issue. Another factor is that a sharp blade taking a thin shaving works much better.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#11

Re: Another consideration

Tony Wilkins

I've heard (and it seems to be the case with me) that the height of the wooden bodied bench planes help orient to square more easily. Don't think that would be the case with wooden plows or filisters where you keep the off hand on the fence to keep it tight against the wood. Might be the case with wooden rebate planes with them being taller but don't know since the metal varieties are about the same shape - I'd definitely have to defer to experience on that one.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#12

Example

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tony,

Shown below is a wooden plough I was using today to define the size and cut the wrap-around tongue on a slab of Baltic birch ply. This will be the core of a veneered desk. This core will be wrapped in a satinwood frame; the frame will be grooved to take the tongue. Plane is a Union Hardware No. 245 (all boxwood) screw-arm model; irons are John Moseley & Sons, London (more on irons below).

To your questions..... It's all personal preference, but there are some common attributes and some objective differences among woodie ploughs, and between woodie and metal ploughs. I am speaking of vintage woodies here, although Old Street (formerly Clark & Williams) make a wonderful plough:

1. Woodies are different from each other. The pictured woodie is screw-arm. These are heavier and bulkier than wedge-arm or the old 'Yankee' type. This plough has no handle--they also made them handled. There is a difference in use: I prefer the handleless, because I want my hands right over the cutting action. Better control, and easier to keep the plane plumb (in my experience). If plough is handled, then you're controlling at a distance, and indirectly (thru an engineering 'couple'). To me, weight doesn't matter--the plane is supported by the work--but bulk does. I prefer the lighter wedge-arm or Yankee in practice (the C&W is my favorite), but went for bulk and weight here because of cutting through the cross-plies and glue and crap you find in ply. Bulk just feels clumsier. On the other hand, I have found that screw-arms tend to be dead-sound in terms of no arm-slippage--150-year old plane will work like new, with no surgical intervention by you. With one exception, and that is the iron/wedge situation....

2. Irons and wedges. The plane shown was not shipped with the irons I'm using; who knows where the original irons are, they're almost never found with the plane. And the taper of the irons has to match the taper of the wedge--or the irons will rattle loose in the plane. So you can't just buy a vintage woodie and be in business--you need a set of irons that will match the wedge in the plane; or be ready to do some surgery on the wedge; or just be lucky. I was lucky here--the Moseley irons just needed a light scraping of the original wedge to fit. Also, a mixed, or 'harlequin' set of irons will not generally work--each iron would need its own wedge.

3. Irons and sizes. Vintage irons are numbered 1 thru 8, and nominally they are 1/8", 3/16", 1/4", 5/16", 3/8", 7/16", 1/2", and 5/8". But. These are nominal. The actual size range is usually + or - 1/32" from the nominal. In the plane shown, the No. 3 iron I'm using is pretty close to 1/4", but that's just happenstance. Similarly, you generally find the No. 1 iron larger than 1/8"; but this Moseley set's No. 1 iron is slightly smaller than 1/8". So if you're persnickety about metric vs. Imperial and into mic'ing irons and chisels, fuggedaboudit. Also the vintage irons as-found will generally be a mess at the business end--plan on machine-grinding them to a hollow grind. I've done a bunch of sets and never found a soft iron though--they've all been good steel as soon as I could unblunt and unconvex them.

4. Metal planes are predictable. If you buy an LV plough, it will work out of the box; the irons will be the size they say they are to a tight tolerance; don't have to go find irons and wonder how you're gonna get them to work with the plane.

Even a vintage Stanley 45 or equal will have irons that fit the plane--usually they're the correct nominal size, although sometimes you find a previous user has reground the exact iron you want to use, for some purpose or other.

But then, some people prefer wood. I do.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8214771970/

Wiley

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#13

Thanks Wiley

Tony Wilkins

I've decided when it's time I'm going to go with the LV for both the plough and moving filester. Old Street isn't going to be taking new orders for a bit according to their website. I searched around and Philly Planes is working to start selling a bridal plough (or is that bridle plow) using refurbished irons at a price that was quoted to be at 500 pounds.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#14

Re: Another consideration

TomD

I think the idea higher is better falls into the filling out the word count category. Sure one can argue it, or that lower planes, wood or metal, are more stable. This like arguing over BIC pens VS Parker pens for people learning to write. I have pen preferences, but I can sign a check with either. Something other than how easy something is to learn to use will end up being your concern, after the initial few hours of use are passed. I do agree that there are difference though, in this category, like the fact I prefer the wooden surface, does not carry ofver when the planing surface is a metal skate.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#15

Re: Example

TomD

When you say metal planes are predictable, this is a factor of the current market (not to be discounted). For the last 25 years, metal has been a disaster, with hours wasted in low tech alterations to get something usable. One of my early preferences for wood was dictated by the fact that as a woodworker, I could do in minutes what took hours or days with a metal tool. But now we finally have something that comes perfect out of the box, form LV, or OS, or Mung...

Big factor for average users will be the cost. Wood could be offered cheaper than metal, but as woodworkers prefer metal to wood, the large efficient producers are making metal tools, and wood is pricey. Since one can make a wooden plane in 45 minutes, that is also an option, but one that many people do not seemingly prefer, and may even seem less appealing with the complexity of planes in this category.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#16

Good points Thom!  And some Clarifications.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

In comparing wood vs. metal ploughs, I was comparing the most likely current offerings that Tony might find in the right price range--old, vintage, as-you-find-it wood vs. brand new LV metal.

There are absolutely superior wooden products. The one I know best is Old Street, formerly Clark & Williams, where Larry and Don make stunningly precise and usable planes of all types, bench, molding, ploughs, filletsters..everything. Philly also makes sound planes. Matt Bickford has been mentioned often on these pages as a top plane maker, and D. L. Barrett and Sons appear to me to be superlative, though I don't have first-hand experience of them. In fact, my apologies to all those who I don't know of, or am having a senior moment about.

I have paid dearly and happily for these newer wooden planes, placing C&W in the same quality category as high-end Japanese saws and Konrad Sauer's infills. We haven't talked much recently about Konrad on these pages, but he is exceptional in every professional and human regard.

Wiley

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#17

Got Spoiled

Tony Wilkins

After reading about Clark and Wiliams, I called them up and Don spent a lot of time talking to me and helping me figure out what might be the best options for dealing with my limitations. I got a couple of their planes as a result of all he did to help me out. I've founding comparing their jack to a well refurbished stanley #5 that I much preferred the ergonomics (grip and weight) of the wooden version.

I love the aesthetics of the wooden plough and wooden moving filister. However, they don't seem to hold the same advantage. The grip on the right hand seems better on the LV to my imagination and the weight advantage seems to swing back to the metal versions.

I won't need either for a couple of projects so I have time to decide (though I pretty much have).

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#18

Re: Got Spoiled

Tony Wilkins

Just to add. I do think the wooden plough is a magnificent old beast and it has become one of my aspirations in woodworking to make one some day.

Re: Wood or Metal Plow and Filister

#19

All that is needed ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Since one can make a wooden plane in 45 minutes..... :D

Heh .. Tom .. I just could not go passed that one without exclaiming! :)

That's all it took ... http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/BridlePloughBuild.html

On a more intellectual level, there is a difference between using wooden and metal planes, all sorts of trades offs, not simply pros and cons.

I have built, and continue to use, quite a number of woodies. I switch between wooden and metal planes frequently, usually depending my mood and the project. Take a jointer, for example. Because wood is lighter than metal, and because you can, a wooden jointer tends to be longer than its metal cousin. The extra length is helpful when jointing long boards. My go to woodie is 28" with a 2 1/4" wide tapered blade. The blade is the same width as a LV BU Jointer, which is 22" long. While the woodie glides smoothly over a wooden surface, the LV feels tauter, more direct in what it does. It is slimmer in construction, with a lower centre of gravity. This is an influence in my building razee woodies. A dab of wax on the LV sole sends it shooting across a wooden surface just as well. I've not compared the two planes in actual mass, but the LV feels heavier, possibly because the weight is contained in a smaller package.


Which is "better"? Wrong question. They are just a different experience for the same task.

Regards from Perth

Derek