New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

New set of chisels

Posts

New set of chisels

#1

Robert Tutsky

New set of chisels

Robert Tutsky

I am starting this woodworking thing all over again after loosing just about everything I had previously. I am on a shoestring budget presently and that's okay, I have become more resourceful and enjoy that challenge in itself. At the height of it all in the past I owned a full set of two cherries and a smattering of 750s, Witherbys, a few chisels shop made that worked well and some oddball chisels I don't remember the names but favored most of them.

Because I need quite a variety of tools and supplies to get going I took a chance on a cheap set of chisels in hopes that they would have even a marginal performance to accomplish what a chisel needs to do. So after searching around I found the Neiko chisels. Hey, for $49 they were definetely within my budget. I would love a set of LN or LV chisels but I have the need of coin left in the till to even buy some wood to use a chisel on.


First of all this post is not a sales pitch, I have no affiliation to the product at all, just my experience with using them. Most folks here I suppose have chisels that would put these to shame.

I realize they don't compare to high end chisels but for me at this stage of the game they worked better than I thought they would. They came somewhat sharp and the backs were easily smoothed out flat. I spent about an hour and a half honing them all to bring them up to par. The first use was a 3" through

mortise in maple for a mallet head and it certainly was a workout considering I didn't have a drill press to bore some of the waste out before chiseling... I didn't trust my ability in accurately drilling by a hand drill.

After finishing the mortise, the 1/2" chisel seemed as sharp as when I started. At approximately $5 per chisel I was pleased with the purchase. The finished mallet:


Now it's on to adding more stuff as I go...

Re: New set of chisels

#2

Re: New set of chisels

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You use what you can afford. Folks can, at times, get paralyzed by all the shiny toys and spend lots of time wondering what's best. A Mercedes is nice, but a Ford Focus will get you across town too.

Glad to hear these seem to be working out well.

Re: New set of chisels

#3

Re: New set of chisels

Edward in Vancouver

In my "other life" I am a Chef, have been for almost 30 years now. Guys get very worked up about their knives and some of them can cost an obscene amount of money. I have always maintained and given advice to cooks buying knives to start off with inexpensive knives, in particular, "Brand X", a well established inexpensive stamped steel brand sold the world over. They get the work done, easy to sharpen, easy to maintain, and when they get lost or stolen, it isn't so hard to swallow.

Hey, at least you have a matched set of chisels, mine look like "the usual suspects" in a police line up....................

Re: New set of chisels

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Nice case

Jack Guzman from Maine

That display case is impressive. Sounds like you would be fine if you never got another set of chisels than those. I got a set of the LNs when they first came out and I have some two cherries, but some of my favorite chisels are oddballs.It's all about the wood,not the tools we use to shape it.---Jack

Re: New set of chisels

#5

Re: New set of chisels

Patrick Gibbons

Forget the chisels. Look what you did with them. That's a great looking mallet. You do good work. Keep 'em coming.

Re: New set of chisels

#6

Re: New set of chisels

david weaver

Many of the chinese chrome vanadium chisels I've seen have been fine. Even a set of 5 that I got for the wife for when she does restoration stuff in the house were fine after a little bit was ground off. They were $12 for all 5 of them. The major difference between them and my expensive chisels is minor details with the steel and major differences with weight and balance (they have thin blades, are long and are handle heavy).

Those, however, look like copies of a marples type chisel, and are probably decent if the steel is reasonably hard and they're close to flat. Anything else, you can grind the sides finer if you want in the future.

It only takes one look on alibaba to see how many different sellers are offering marples knock-offs, etc. Some of them have to be decent.

Re: New set of chisels

#7

Robert Tutsky

Re: New set of chisels

Robert Tutsky

Hi David,

Yes, I have to agree with you that these are very close to the Marples that I had in the past. If the handles were blue you'd mistake them for the Marples. I looked into purchasing the Marples and they are available but read that Irwin bought out the Marples brand and they weren't up to the performance that the original Marples had.