New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

Posts

Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

#1

Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

Tony Wilkins

Decided to make this a separate question from the workbench queries I've had. I am wondering for a tail vise (and in general) what are the pro's and con's of having a wooden screw compared to a metal screw? I'm think specifically of the benchcrafted hardware that looks very well conceived and constructed.

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

#2

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

TomD

I am wondering for a tail vise (and in general) what are the pro's and con's of having a wooden screw compared to a metal screw?

Metal screws work a lot better, I have not used a bench screw, but I have a number of screw boxes, and know what wood screws are like. Wood screws have less power, because of the angle it needs to be strong. That said, there is something fun about a wooden screw. I would certainly use one, but it probably isn't the best completely soulless choice.

Obviously metal screws allow quick releases, etc... to come into play.

" I'm think specifically of the benchcrafted hardware that looks very well conceived and constructed. "

I have to confess to thinking the BC hardware, and their demo bench are very nice looking, and they call out to me. LV which is a local store to me, just started carrying them, and I looked at them longingly... That said, here is the rational position:

There are going to be differences of opinion on this part, but of all the vises, the leg vise is the least useful. So while this may be the best version, it is such a bad vise at such a high price, that would rule it out for me.

The hand wheel is an interesting version, and it can be spun which makes adjustment fast, and I would use one, but it has less leverage, is more in the way. So it is $370 for something that is still a compromise.

While I have no problem what people charge for their products, and there can be many reasons for prices that are well justified... These are incredibly expensive. MSC sell wheels, other people sell screws, that is a 70 dollar item in my mind. They are offering it in a very nice version, but it probably isn't 300 extra to me. I have certainly paid more for stuff I just wanted.

The tail vice does not look like a good idea. In order to get the compactness the wheel gets really small and looses out on the spin and leverage.

The whole thing is kinda weird, roubo primitive with machine age hand wheels.

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

#3

I saw the word soul

RonHarper

I really think that is what it is about. There are some of us who just love the older ways of doing things. I find a lot of pleasure in taking my d8 10 tpi crosscut and my d8 7 tpi rip and cutting a top to perfect size for the bedside table I am making. ( well... perfect is a stretch... the rip cuts will need one or two passes with my 605c. ) many of my woodworking friends think I have taken leave of any sanity that I may have

possesed. But, I love working that way and I am in the very fortunate position that that is what matters.

I absolutely love wooden screw vises. I currently have one. I am adding two to my shop very soon. They work absolutely as well as I need them to. Are there better options? What does better mean? I will have a hundred and fifty bucks in all three of them. AND they are so very cool.

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

#4

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

JMOHNIKE

Metal, in my opinon, is the only way to go. Have had both. The wood one, now long gone, was a problem from the start. Limited clamping pressure due to lack of torque. Solvents and glue were always a problem. For the first 2-3 years I had it I would have to take it apart, and "adjust" it due to the change in the weather. Metal one, 5 yrs now, clean and lite oil on my birthday, no fuss no muss.

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

#5

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Decided to make this a separate question from the workbench queries I've had. I am wondering for a tail vise (and in general) what are the pro's and con's of having a wooden screw compared to a metal screw? I'm think specifically of the benchcrafted hardware that looks very well conceived and constructed.

Hi Tony

Consider the differing requirements in a screw for a tail vise as opposed to a leg vise.

Firstly, the advantage of a wooden screw in a leg vise is that you get a large diameter with low tpi. Mine is 2" and 3 tpi, but some are 2 1/2" diameter and 2 tpi. Compare this with the Benchcrafted screw of 1 1/2" diameter and 4 tpi. Basically what you get from the low tpi is a screw that requires few turns to move in-and-out. The advantage here is neutralised by the BC screw, which turns slower but moves more smoothly.

I think that the screw for a tail vise should be compact, and that a wooden screw would be too bulky in this area. On the other hand it would be nice to see a steel tail vise screw with lower tpi. Where as the leg vise really does not have to move in-and-out very far (we tend to limit the thickness of the boards we work), the tail vise needs to deal with a wider range.

For the record, I have a wooden screw for the leg vise and a BC tail vise. I love using both and would do them again if I had to.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

#6

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

Lars Parrington

For my recent roubo build, I built my own vises. They are extremely similar to the benchcrafted designs. I find that they move in and out plenty fast enough, even the wagon vise which I sometimes have to move 8 inches (as that is the spacing of my bench dogs). I used 5 threads per inch screws for my vises, whereas BC uses 4 tpi, so my vises are even slower moving than theirs, and yet the mechanisms move so smoothly that it is not a hassle to make big adjustments.

Actually I would not recommend usign a vise screw 2 or 3 tpi. Even with 5 tpi, I do sometimes, although rarely, need to tighten the handwheels almost to the limit of my strength. I could probably use less clamping force if I cover the faces of the vise with leather, but I have not gotten around to that yet.

It was a lot of work machining the vise hardware, especially the wagon vise. If I was to do it again, I would use a different design for the wagon vise. Maybe a design similar to the maguire wagon vise.

You can see pictures of my workbench here. There is a good photo of the wagon vise, but I haven't got a picture of the leg vise up there yet.

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

#7

Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware

Jeff Heath

I completed my Roubo style workbench with both Benchcrafted vises and I can tell you that the hardware is outstanding. This is my 4th bench, and I finally feel like I've got a bench that does everything I need it to do. The vise hardware operates so smoothly that I doubt you'll ever be concerned about moving it in and out. With the Glide leg vise, I can just give it a spin, and it spins in by itself until snug on whatever I am clamping.

The wagon vise is my 2nd on a bench. On my last bench, which I built 15 years ago, I included a wagon vise with a screw that that traversed in and out of the end of the bench. With the vise block all the way to the right (open) the screw would protrude a good 12" to 15" out from the right end of the bench, and I cannot tell you how many times I smacked my hip into that as I worked around the end. The benchcrafted handle stays nice and tight to the bench, and the block traverses on the acme screw.

With a little leather on your chops, you will have all the holding power you need without having to "gronk" down on the vise handles. I did this to an old wooden screw vise and broke some threads.

Jeff