Re: Wooden versus Metal vise hardware
TomD
I am wondering for a tail vise (and in general) what are the pro's and con's of having a wooden screw compared to a metal screw?
Metal screws work a lot better, I have not used a bench screw, but I have a number of screw boxes, and know what wood screws are like. Wood screws have less power, because of the angle it needs to be strong. That said, there is something fun about a wooden screw. I would certainly use one, but it probably isn't the best completely soulless choice.
Obviously metal screws allow quick releases, etc... to come into play.
" I'm think specifically of the benchcrafted hardware that looks very well conceived and constructed. "
I have to confess to thinking the BC hardware, and their demo bench are very nice looking, and they call out to me. LV which is a local store to me, just started carrying them, and I looked at them longingly... That said, here is the rational position:
There are going to be differences of opinion on this part, but of all the vises, the leg vise is the least useful. So while this may be the best version, it is such a bad vise at such a high price, that would rule it out for me.
The hand wheel is an interesting version, and it can be spun which makes adjustment fast, and I would use one, but it has less leverage, is more in the way. So it is $370 for something that is still a compromise.
While I have no problem what people charge for their products, and there can be many reasons for prices that are well justified... These are incredibly expensive. MSC sell wheels, other people sell screws, that is a 70 dollar item in my mind. They are offering it in a very nice version, but it probably isn't 300 extra to me. I have certainly paid more for stuff I just wanted.
The tail vice does not look like a good idea. In order to get the compactness the wheel gets really small and looses out on the spin and leverage.
The whole thing is kinda weird, roubo primitive with machine age hand wheels.