New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Drying question

Posts

Drying question

#1

Drying question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

If I have doubts about how well a piece of wood was kiln dried, will a long period of acclimitizing in my shop, say a year or two, take care of any potential case-hardening problems?

Re: Drying question

#2

Re: Drying question

William Duffield

My understanding is that the damage done by case hardening is permanent.

For all the info you need to know about wood drying defects, reference Chapter 12 of FPL-GTR-113. (Really, "FPL-GTR-113" is all you need to know to ask Google to find it for you.) While you are at it, download the whole manual, in PDF (and read it).

This is the USDA Forest Product Lab's wood handbook, or General Technical Reference, Wood as an Engineering Material.

Re: Drying question

#3

not so

Bill Tindall

All KD lumber is more or less "case hardened" after initial drying. A quality run operation then steams the lumber back up to the target 7%. Steaming will relax this stress. Honey comb on the other hand is forever.

Re: Drying question

#4

Re: not so

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm not convinced that my local kiln is such a quality operation. I've asked the guy about conditioning his wood and he looked at me like I was speaking Swahili. He just sticks the wood in, dries it to a specific surface moisture content and calls it good. The price is right, so I keep buying there. However, my question is whether additional acclimitization in my shop, up to a year or more, will offset any casehardening the wood has encountered. If that is so, I'll just lay in a stock and let it sit for a while, much to the consternation of my wife who doesn't see a pile of wood as a treasure trove.

Re: Drying question

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: not so

Dale Lenz

As I'm sure you know stream is usually used to condition the lumber, to relief CH of lumber. The stream relaxes the lumber's shell and allow the core to come out of compression, the squeeze if you will. I would think laying the lumber around for awhile, would gradually relieve the internal stress in the board(s). Start looking for someone local with a solar kiln, the stress in the lumber is relieved every night, unless the kiln operator adds additional heat during the night.

Good luck and lets us know how it works out.

Re: Drying question

#6

Dealing with case hardening

Steve Elliott

In the thirty-plus years I've spent working in commercial cabinet shops I've come to expect case hardening in almost all the solid stock I use. I doubt letting the wood sit around for a year will make much difference.

Now that I know how to use the case hardened condition to help straighten a crooked or bowed plank I'm always a little disappointed if it turns out that a less-than-straight piece of stock doesn't show some case hardening.

The trick is to remove wood first from the convex side near the middle of the board or wherever the biggest hump is. As this outside layer is removed the balance of tension and compression is disturbed and the board bends toward a straighter shape. Once the first (formerly convex) side is straight, removing the wood at the ends of the other side to achieve uniform thickness has little effect on the straightness of the board. The result is a straight board at the maximum thickness it would be possible to get from the original rough plank.

Re: Drying question

#7

Re: Dealing with case hardening

Patrick Gibbons

I've had pine boards (both SYP and WYP) in my garage for well over a year or more that exhibited extreme case hardening. I've had the same problem with eastern red cedar which was not kiln dried.

Re: Drying question

#8

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Drying question

Stephen Shepherd

Bruce,

Once the wood is heated above 185 degrees [F] fatty acids in the lignin are melting and the resulting wood is harder because of the loss of these chemicals in the lattice of lignin.

Stephen

Re: Drying question

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: Dealing with case hardening

Dale Lenz

With all due respect, I'd be interested in how you determine the air dried ERC, was CH. 99.9% of all my lumber is AD and I've ripped a few boards of well AD walnut and one in several hundred boards I get one side of the board pulling away from the kerf, normally on the non fence side. I have always chalked it up as some "hidden" stress in the lumber. I don't purchase limb wood as boards, if the tree/log was a leaner, IDK. But lumber from the same tree that one or two boards that showed "interal stress" sanded and looked fine to me.

Re: Drying question

#10

Dale Lenz

According to Gene Wengart... *LINK*

Dale Lenz

case hardening does not go away with time, but can be managed by planing equally on both side. I assume ripping is out. I don't always believe everything Gene says, but in this case, I bow to his experience. See link below.


Case Hardening

Re: Drying question

#11

Re: According to Gene Wengart...

Bill Tindall

Once the moisture leaves the wood the fiber bundles bond to one another and the wood is "set". The fibers can not move unless these bonds are weakened ( plasticized, or lubed if you will) by something. Water and heat do the job and there are other chemicals that will work to enable the fibers to slide past one another and the wood to take on a different shape- bend, relax, etc.

I have accomplished the task on small pieces with a steam iron and a wet towel.

Turns out mahogany bleeds red color which becomes one with the bottom of the household manager's steam iron. Not good! It seems that many of my employments of household equipment does not end well. I do now have my own shop hair drier, but that is another story

Re: Drying question

#12

Dale Lenz

So...

Dale Lenz

If I rip a board and it pulls away from the saw, would your above method straighten in out or at least make it better? Usually, like you I have plenty of lumber and I doubt I'd take the time to mess with that particular board. As I said, one in a hundred boards act like that.

As far as getting an iron in the shop, I took my time once fixing the male plug to the wife's iron and she purchased a new on, Bingo! Have hair dryer out in the shop, but would take me awhile to find it, used to use it somewhat, for what, don't have a clue. Have not had a need for it in years now.

Re: Drying question

#13

Rummage sales can be your friend

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

because they often have, cheap, useful shop accessory tools like wood steaming tools disguised as steam irons, hide glue cookers disguised as crockpots, and so on.

Re: Drying question

#14

On the utility of hair driers

Bill Tindall

1. Good for drying after dent steaming.

2. Drying after grain raising.

3. Hastening the cure of 5 min epoxy

4. Others I can't remember.

Re: Drying question

#15

Re: Drying question

TomD

Since you are willing to store the wood for a while, why not ask him if you can have it before he puts it in the kiln. It should be cheaper, and it should not take terribly long to dry, my experience with drying my own wood has largely been positive. I can't see any reason to search out KD wood, there isn't any advantage to putting it in furniture.

Re: Drying question

#16

Dale Lenz

Re: On the utility of hair driers

Dale Lenz

How long after using the hair dryer can you sand the epoxy? I usually use a bench light to speed it up, but it still takes at least an hour or more before I can file, scrape, sand smooth.

Re: Drying question

#17

Dale Lenz

Re: Drying question

Dale Lenz

I agree with Tom, you need to learn how to control bugs, not a big deal. Forget the one inch per year on drying that's hogwash! Been AD wood since the 80's.

Re: Drying question

#18

Re: Dale, I hear you

Patrick Gibbons

I had ERC close up on the saw blade while trying to rip it once. Couldn't get the blade to move. Just like pine does sometimes. The ERC was air dried. What I understand is that red cedar dries fast.

Re: Drying question

#19

Dale Lenz

Hair driers

Dale Lenz

Just prior to my current career job as a forester, that will be 29 years in two days. I was making an ERC cover box for some Kleenex tissues, which I still have. My goal was to completly finish the project in one day, used paste wax as a finish. Was mixing some glue and sawdust for putty for minor defects, around knots etc. Was using a hair dryer to speed the putty drying process, heard a pop, took a second look and the ERC had cracked from the dry heat, this was store purchased ERC back then. I love ERC, but it's a fincky wood. You just look at it wrong and it will chip, tear, crack or dent.

Hope everyone that is not retired is enjoying their day off if their employer allows. There's a Mom & Pop offering free lunch if your a Vet. think it's great, but think the righteous thing to do is to make a donation to the business with my meal, but my pocket book says no, so maybe I'll eat a sandwich before going to town.

Re: Drying question

#20

I have not tried that method, Steve, but

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I will the next time it rears its ugly head. That well explains the frustration I've had, because I've always tried to straighten the concave side but that has merely replicated the problem.