New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

When not to skew a plane

Posts

When not to skew a plane

#1

When not to skew a plane

North of the Border

Most teachers or woodworkers include "skewing the handplane" as a recommended planing habit. I did come across an old woodworker who was against skewing the plane but didn't get a chance to ask him why. An old post covered skewing the plane to some length:

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3104/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/18247v6eCfn5562kObkM1351995733/spage/1/sanc/28321/sbid/3104/md/read/id/28321/sbj/skewing-a-plane/

But it seems that it has not been covered as to whether there are occasions or woods where skewing the plane is not a good idea. Wonder if anyone has such experience or has come across discussions on that aspect.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#2

Re: When not to skew a plane

Warren in Lancaster, PA

An interesting question. I usually don't teach beginners to skew the plane, but find that they start doing it naturally, sometimes within 10 minutes of picking up the plane. I think even those who are instructed to skew go on to find a comfortable angle intuitively. This is just a natural thing. My recollection of my own start is that I did not know about skewing and probably first did it without realizing it. There was no U-Tube or Woodwright's Shop back then.

You want to tone down the skewing when edge jointing so the entire length of the plane is in contact. The plane cuts a little more accurately and is much more stable and controlled on the edge.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#3

Re: When not to skew a plane

James Watriss

I think, in general, it's more of a issue with a dull iron, particularly in woods that are figured, splintery, or otherwise prone to tear out. In my experience, it's a useful strategy when the iron is sharp, because the skew cut helps, despite the fact that it (sort of) lowers the effective pitch.

I say 'sort of,' because, in strictly geometrical terms, in the direction of the force vector, a cross section of the geometry will make it look that way. Realistically, I think what's actually happening is that the cut is normal, but at an angle to the grain, so individual fibers are being pushed sideways, and supported by neighboring fibers, instead of simply lifting out in line with their own direction.

At the end of the day though, that's all theory, and you have to experiment, and go by what your hands are telling you.

I skew my planes all the time. Works for me.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#4

The missing diagram from 2004

Steve Elliott

Warren has it right when he says it's an intuitive thing. Getting a feel for the angle of skew that works best is the real issue and it's pretty easy to do.

Just to make the discussion easier, here's the diagram from the discussion in 2004:


As for when not to skew, the only reason I can think of is that it reduces the effective length of the sole. This can be useful when trying to smooth a small problem area but results in a surface that is less flat or straight.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#5

Re: The missing diagram from 2004

James Watriss

Actually, corner to corner, it increases the effective length...

Re: When not to skew a plane

#6

Re: The missing diagram from 2004

Sgian Dubh

... and a skewed plane effectively reduces the angle of attack at the cutting edge, which can be useful, or it may be a hindrance. Slainte.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#7

Re: When not to skew a plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

But it seems that it has not been covered as to whether there are occasions or woods where skewing the plane is not a good idea. Wonder if anyone has such experience or has come across discussions on that aspect.

Skewing is not a good idea if you are trying to maintain the highest cutting angle, such as on interlocked grain.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: When not to skew a plane

#8

I found this to be true too

Bill Tindall

Skewing seems to be helpful when straight planing is making problems. The following is speculation as I am not a student of planing research, but I think problems are forecast by a perceptible increase in planing resistance which we soon learn is lessened by skewing, which in turn lessens some kinds of planing problems. Bottom line, it all come natural. This is not to say that there might be advanced skewing techniques that could be learned or taught. But for routine tasks when the going gets rough, the natural and subconsciousness skewing of the plane often helps. It may be best NOT to think about it.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#9

Re: When not to skew a plane

david weaver

Other than edge jointing, the wood will tell you when skewing is not a good idea. If skewing causes an iron to face right against the grain, then it will make results worse. It'll be pretty easy to tell.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#10

Re: When not to skew a plane

Mark Hennebury

Supersurfacers work on the same cutting principles as hand planes and employ a variable skew system from 0° - 60° the highest skew for softest wood and less skew as the woods get harder.


Higher Skew reduces the effective cutting angle of the blade and a lower skew increases it.

Considerations in cutting with a handplane are on an "adjust to suit" basis based on the particular piece of wood and the grain orientation, rather than a specific rule.

I also believe that there is an additional effect from a high skew angle: i believe that a high skew angle forces the wood fibers to slide along the blade exposing them to more of the blade edge producing a slicing effect requiring much less cutting force and therefore less stress damage to the fibers, and a nice clean cut.


Re: When not to skew a plane

#11

Is that some sort of mechanical "shooting board"?.

Bill Tindall

or a dowel trimmer, or what?

Re: When not to skew a plane

#12

Re: When not to skew a plane

cstanford

If the wood in need of hand planing is very close to finish thickness then plane up an offcut to see how the wood is behaving before you apply the plane to what will be a finished workpiece. If skewing is doing more harm than good then *obviously* don't skew the plane on the real workpieces.

There is no hard and fast rule. It does lower the cutting angle and this seems counterintuitive when planing figured wood but, still, it can work even in that situation.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#14

Re: Thanks for the views from different perspectiv

cstanford

I just sure hope you don't think that any written or verbal advice trumps what you actually see with your own eyes on the stock being worked with your own hands.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#15

Re: Thanks for the views from different perspectiv

North of the Border

I posed the question because of what an old woodworker said sometime ago about skewing the plane. I wondered why skewing a plane would be a bad thing and the views expressed so far are useful to such understanding and to some extent, confirmed that what the old woodworker said was correct in certain situations.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#16

Re: Thanks for the views from different perspectiv

cstanford

A lot of times the plane will cut fine either way - straight ahead OR skewed. Skewing can seem natural when taking off little lumps, bumps, and assorted high spots when doing the aeronautical equivalent to 'touch and goes' seems a natural movement. I also, for some reason, tend to skew the plane when taking a pass on the face of a board, in the section right near an edge.

Re: When not to skew a plane

#17

Re: When not to skew a plane

Guillaume Dery

to add to what Derek said, if I remember Leonard Lee's sharpening book correctly, skewing the plane lowers the effective cutting angle, hence Derek's comment on maintaining the highest possible cutting angle.