New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Thinking ahead to a workbench

Posts

Thinking ahead to a workbench

#1

Thinking ahead to a workbench

Texchappy

Right now I'm locked out of woodworking because I can't get to the basement to my tools and makeshift bench. I'm spending my time thinking about when we leave the Army and build our house and I get my shop. I'm leaning towards doing a Nicholson type bench since it seems to rely so much less on heavy lumber to get to the end result.

So, am I thinking correctly - would a Nicholson bench be better for someone with physical limitations to build (as opposed to a roubo)?

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#2

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Depends on the physical limitations, I suppose. If you need to tuck your legs under the bench when working, a Nicholson bench would be awkward. But the individual pieces of lumber would certainly be less of a lift.

Somehow, the Roubo bench has gotten this huge prominence. There are lots of bench designs. Besides the Nicholson bench, there are the several variations of the European cabinetmaker's bench (Tage Frid's and Frank Klausz's, for instance).

And new bench designs like the Noden Adjust-a-Bench (linky below) that could be good for someone with a bad back (although I'd look at ways to raise it other than by hand if I had physical limitations).

Every bench has tradeoffs. If you can afford it, you might get (or see if you can get from your library or on interlibrary loan) Chris Schwarz' two books on benches, and the older "The Workbench Book" from Taunton Press.

Note that I'm no kinda expert. My bench is a solid core door resting on a plywood cubby-hole box and a 2x4 ledger lag-bolted to the studs, and screwed to both. It's rigid but ugly. It's a temporary bench - I've only had it since my 40-year-old was an early teenager.


http://www.adjustabench.com/index.asp

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#3

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

Patrick Gibbons

The bench I use now is based on the one Mike Dunbar built and uses. There is a plan in the first tools and shop issue of Fine Woodworking. It's a good solid bench that is easy to put together. It uses a thick slab for the first 10" or 12" of the top with thinner stock behind. I didn't duplicate this part of the bench and wish I had. It should be easier to make and handle while making it plus it gives you a good bench. If I had it to do over, I would make the top as Dunbar shows and I would add rails at the top to make it more solid in certain operations such as sawing and filing. Also take a look at Paul Sellers' site and his bench build. It's a very good bench which I've used at his school when he was in Texas. He has a series on YouTube and on his blog on building it and you can evaluate if it would be doable for you. On the Toolemera site there is a reproduction of the book Building Woodworking Tools (I think it's called), and it has a good simple plan for building an English-style bench. I hope these help.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#4

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

Brian from Monument

Bill, Sorry to say , but your bench does not sound "temporary".

Sounds more like permanently sad.

Are you planning on building a non-door bench?

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#5

Hey, it's worked

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Yes, I'd like to build another bench some time. But, it's a tool, like the others; I'd rather spend some time first, following up on some designs; but first I have to bring our house refurbishment projects under control.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#6

Re: Hey, it's worked

Texchappy

Thanks for the input so far. I narrowed it down to Nicholson and Roubo based on the Swarz book I have (have one of the two).

I might have a better question based on something I noticed. I was looking at the weight of the LN #7 and 8 and realizing that they're to heavy for me (I have trouble lifting a full gallon of milk). So maybe a better question is what options/soluctions do I have to help with work lifting around the shop?

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#7

Tough problem *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Even a No. 6, an under-respected plane and a possible jointer, is 7-3/4 pounds, around the gallon-of-milk size.

I've been told that the rule of thumb is that you can joint a piece of stock twice the length of the plane. If you limited yourself to 24" - 28" long pieces - granted, this makes for relatively small work - you might be able to get by with a jack plane (about 4-1/2 pounds)*. With practice, you can actually get a lot of straight lines out of a jack plane.

You could also aim to design pieces that don't require much, if any, jointing, but this severely limits you as far as tabletops and so on, which will often require jointing several pieces of wood to make up the width. But, even there, if you did designs with slatted tops, you could avoid jointing to a glue line, and a jack would get you by.

Wooden jointers might be lighter; they're bulkier, which could be an issue if your hand dexterity is limited, too.

Larger work would require muscling around larger pieces of wood, too; so maybe you need to think about small-scale pieces, at least until your strength is better or you have more practice exercising the strength you have.

There's an Australian forum, linked below, that is focused on woodworking for people with disabilities; you might drop in there and see what you can learn. Googling "woodworking with disabilities" got me 1800,000 plus hits.

*When I was starting out, all the how-to books recommended a jack plane, 14" long, as the first plane. Jointers came much, much later in the shopping list.


http://www.woodworkforums.com/f142/

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#8

Re: Tough problem

Texchappy

I've been focusing on wooden planes to reduce the weight. I have an Old Street smoother and jack. I had talked with them about a specially set up jointer but my wife put the veto on it when Don called back to make it. Guess I'll have to find another option now that they're not taking any new plane orders. Been going back to thinking about Japanese kanna (naga dai?)

I'll go an do some digging on that site you linked and see what ideas I can find.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#9

Weight and force required

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Only you can know the answers, but as a suggestion you might consider one more variable--blade width. Testing your strength is the weight of a tool, and then there is the force required to work it. The force in turn is going to be a function of the plane's bedding angle and blade width (and blade sharpness). It's surprising to me how much more force is required to take a 2-1/4" shaving, for example, than a 2" one. You might consider a No. 5-1/4, with a 1-3/4" iron, and weighing 4-1/2 lb (1 lb less than a No. 5).

Remember also that you can pull a Bailey or Bedrock style plane, if that is the best thing for you.

Among the wooden planes, the ECE's are very good value, relatively narrow (a good thing in this case), and very solid and handy performers.

A Japanese plane introduces a fairly steep learning curve IMO. Starting with the fact that you have to fit the blade to the dai. And a bunch of other stuff to follow. This learning curve translates finally into a lot of physical activity dedicated to making the plane work. So you'll be fettling instead of bringing into being the object you're working on. Just sayin.

Wiley

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#10

Re: Weight and force required

Alex Y

Only you can know the answers, but as a suggestion you might consider one more variable--blade width. Testing your strength is the weight of a tool, and then there is the force required to work it. The force in turn is going to be a function of the plane's bedding angle and blade width (and blade sharpness). It's surprising to me how much more force is required to take a 2-1/4" shaving, for example, than a 2" one. You might consider a No. 5-1/4, with a 1-3/4" iron, and weighing 4-1/2 lb (1 lb less than a No. 5).
Wiley raises excellent points there. I'll add that two other factors affecting force required are depth of cut and slickness of the plane sole. With a little paraffin on the sole and a .001" depth of cut, the plane will practically glide effortlessly. However, you will take many more strokes to do the same job, which may be good or may just induce fatigue--you be the judge. Also, using the trick of tipping the plane slightly and dragging it back on the return stroke is much easier than lifting.

And if I can offer a little blasphemy here, hand-tool work can be hard physical labor. Maybe you would be better off killing a few electrons to get the heavy work done, and enjoy using hand-tools for the lighter fine-tuning work that determines the final fit and finish of your work.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#11

Depends

Ron Harper

I think the Nicholson type makes a lot of sense for someone with limited strength. A moravianbench would be another strong possibility

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#12

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

Tony Wilkins

Our new house should be ready be ready just before Christmas so if I'm physically able I should have a bit of garage to use for woodworking (God willin' and the body don't fail).

I'm about 80% sure that I want a Nicholson style. I have the benchcrafted plans for the split top Roubo and that accounts for the other 20%. After watching the series that Bob Rozaieski's bench building podcasts I think that I like the form.

I also am leaning heavily to having a crochet instead of a face vise. I'm also leaning towards a wagon vise on the tail using benchcrafted hardware.

It seems that a row of square dog holes in the front coupled with round ones in the back for holdfasts would be a very good choice for workholding. However, I'm wondering if having all 3/4" round holes would be more versatile (especially with all the need little do-dads that Rob offers).

So what'dya think? On the right track?

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#13

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

TomD

"I'm about 80% sure that I want a Nicholson style. I have the benchcrafted plans for the split top Roubo and that accounts for the other 20%. After watching the series that Bob Rozaieski's bench building podcasts I think that I like the form."

Style is so much less important than having one. I really can't argue style too much, that is what makes it style.

Are you going to have access to both side the bench, or only one? That makes a huge difference in design.

"I also am leaning heavily to having a crochet instead of a face vise. I'm also leaning towards a wagon vise on the tail using benchcrafted hardware."

Technically there isn't anything you can do with a crotchet that you can't do with a vise. My vise basically sits on the bench like a crotchet, or you could hold a crotchet to the bench with a vise. I spend 90% of my time in the vise...

"It seems that a row of square dog holes in the front coupled with round ones in the back for holdfasts would be a very good choice for workholding. However, I'm wondering if having all 3/4" round holes would be more versatile (especially with all the need little do-dads that Rob offers).

So what'dya think? On the right track? "

The round holes are probably better, I just can't do them, they are so ugly. You have one up on me on this one.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#14

Oh boy

RonHarper

Tony you ask some good questions. Tom, as usual, gives some great responses.

I agree with Tom style is way below function on the priority list. Remember. THIS IS A TOOL. It is not furniture. I strongly agree with The Schwarz that your bench is a work holding tool that must allow you to work easily on the face, edge, and end of stock. How you make that happen can vary a good bit depending on personality, skill, resources, and maybe most importantly the kind of work you will do on it. You gotta decide. What will you ask your bench to do? A great many of the choices are personal options. Not quite, but almost like do you like chicken grilled or fried.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#15

Re: Oh boy

Tony Wilkins

What will the bench be asked to do? What kind of woodworking will I do?

Hmm, here's the list of things I'd like to do plus the honey do's:

Desk organizer for the MRS

a couple of the 'skinny legs and all' tables from Tom Fidgen's book

Trestle table for the kitchen

Bookshelf for son

Desks for my sons

Desk for me

and I my try to tackle some built in's for our retirement house

And the precusor to all this is the projects out of Jim Tolpin's book.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#16

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

Curt Putnam

I've considered the Nicholson and while I appreciate the reduced material costs it so not me that it is out of the question. My only remaining "real" question is whether to use a split top or not and I'm leaning towards splitting it because I have a bum foot that limits the load I can put on it.

What feels good to you? Any of the popular styles of bench will serve nicely to build furniture but maybe not so much for building kayaks.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#17

Ok

RonHarper

Based on your list, it really is a matter of personal preference.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#18

How much was everybody's wood costs

Tony Wilkins

Just wondering how much to budget for the wood.

Re: Thinking ahead to a workbench

#19

Re: How much was everybody's wood costs

Lars Parrington

Tony, I spent $100 on the wood for my roubo. A bit less than $1/bdft from a guy I found on craigslist. A mix of red and white oak, mostly 4"x6" with some splitting. I had to joint them down to 3.5" x 5.5" to get them straight.