New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

Posts

Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#1

Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

Alex Y

I plan to make a Moxon vise with wooden screws. When I built my bench, I used the only store-bought hardwood dowels I could find in the proper size. While they weren't perfectly straight, they have worked well. This time I would like to turn the dowels. Is some species of wood more highly recommended than others for the wood screws? I might like the appearance of walnut screws, and have blanks of the right size. Would that work well? What other woods?

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#2

Ellis Walentine

I've heard...

Ellis Walentine

...that yellow birch is the best.

Ellis

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#3

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

david weaver

Birch, Beech (if it's actually straight down the grain), ash or hard maple would be my choice. Walnut would probably work, but it's soft.

Maple bat and table leg blanks are all around, and should be very straight.

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#4

Riven?

Bill Tindall

While I have no experience with the topic I would think that a riven pieces would be best for the application. Of the common woods I would choose maple. It seems that something tough and split resistant would be best.

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#5

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

Lars Parrington

I've had good results with walnut, although the screws haven't seen hard use. I tried maple (probably soft) as well and there had some difficulty with the peaks of the threads chipping off while making them. I used a metal lathe to make the screws.

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#6

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

TomD

Lake erie toolworks makes them out of maple. The guy who made the Roubo, that was depicted in Scott's book 25 years ago, and presumably started all this, was maple. Norm Vandal mentions that yellow birch was easier to cut so he used it. In the workbench book, the Shaker bench they profile is the only traditional one that I could find mention of the material used. They say it was fruitwood, which makes sense as woods like apple are a lot more compact, more like metal. That might suggest something like boxwood, or LV would be the ideal, if one could only find it.

Riving is a simple and fast way to get baulks that follow the grain of the wood, ideally. But for any given piece of wood sawing is just as good, if one can actually safely saw it, and often gives better yield.

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#7

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

TomD

Lars how did you make the threads on your lathe? I know how to single point thread on a metal lathe, but I could not make a .66 threads per in thread on it. Most lathes are limited to about a 3 per inch. I gather there are ways to gear it down...

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#8

Re: I've heard...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Well, it's stronger than maple, and can have quite interlocked grain, which wouldn't hurt.

But why stop there? Hop hornbeam has the same qualities, but magnified, and is highly wear resistant to boot. I realize it is harder to find in large enough sizes, but it's certainly possible to find suitable stock...

Any reason not to use that species? I'm curious...

DC

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#9

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

Schtoo

Stable, close grained and strong? In that order if you ask me.

I've got a few large screws made from beech, and they fit the close grained and strong bill, but stability is not so hot. They tend to bind up occasionally when the weather changes, although they're still quite new so with use they may stabilize, or at least become less affected by the weather.

While I'd have liked to use rived material, I'm not convinced the extra trouble (for me) would be worthwhile. Riven wood doesn't tend to be more stable, and as the thread is cut across the grain, there's no added strength to be offered by riven wood. May be straighter and stay that way, but as you've had no trouble with wiggly screws, I'd guess straightness isn't as important.

Stu.

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#10

Re: I've heard...

TomD

Tensile strength wise Maple is similar to YB, and exceeds it in most regards where splitting denting, etc.. are concerned (thread wear). Sometimes by quite a bit. Also maple is a lot more dimensionally stable.

http://www.matweb.com/search/DataSheet.aspx?MatGUID=e30c1ad86e814c359e61b4c3449009bb

http://www.matweb.com/search/DataSheet.aspx?MatGUID=f842feea2ae14f5d9897dbedc72608e8&ckck=1

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#11

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

TomD

I think I got my numerators and denominators swapped, call it 1.5/inch

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#12

Re: I've heard...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Based on the links you posted, YB has more volumetric shrinkage than hard maple, but the T/R ratio is a lot better ( 1.28 vs. 1.94).

YB is known to dent more easily, for a screw I don't think it matters much, but then I might be wrong...

DC

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#13

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

Jack Guzman from Maine

I got my wooden vise screws from a gent named Howard Card who has since retired. I believe he made his screws from beech.---Jack

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#14

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

Lars Parrington

The screws I made were only 3/4" diameter and 8 tpi, so the gearing wasn't an issue. 0.66 tpi would be a challenge.

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#15

Stephen Shepherd

Any wood will do if...

Stephen Shepherd

it is the proper size and your screw box cutter is very sharp. I like hickory and white oak for screws that will see heavy service, although beech, maple, and birch work just fine. Made them from boxwood, ebony, rosewood, ligum vitae on the hard end and poplar and even PINE.

With a properly sharpened screw box and tap you can thread any wood, haven't tried basswood or aspen.

Stephen

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#16

"Made them from...PINE"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Did you paint it afterwards to look like some other wood? :D

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#17

Re: I've heard...

TomD

I'm sure you are right. Given they are two know woods that make the grade. Shear would be important to me to minimize chip-out.

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#18

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

greg forster

In one of Kenneth Roberts' 2 volumes on American Planes, there is a description/pricelist from a mid 19thc

plane manufacturer that lists bench screws and these were Walnut.

Don't have the books now, but I'm sure someone could find the page

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#19

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

Patrick Gibbons

Dogwood becomes slicker with use, self-lubricating in a sense. It's dense, very stable, once dry, turns well and is both hard and tough. Roy Underhill made a smaller screw out of it for a project once, though I can't remember which one. Other than that, I have no knowledge of its use historically for this application.

Re: Advice, please--wood species for wood screw

#20

Thanks, all, for the recommendations

Alex Y

Sounds like yellow birch or hard maple will be the way to go if I ever need to replace the main screws on my bench. However, there were many posts with a "use whatever you've got" flavor, and realizing that my Moxon will not get cranked down like other vises, I will just search my woodpile for a couple of hardwood pieces of appropriate size rather than buy lumber for this purpose. Easy to make another if I turn out to be wrong.

Thanks again.