Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel
TomD
"Ok, I did a bit more research on heat treating A2, and it seems like it may be doable. The main difficulty is that I would not be able to use the magnet test to gauge whether the steel has reached conversion temperature."
I did read some were using the mag test. Even with O1 it actually is supposed to be held higher than the mag level by 0 degrees for 10 minutes. I go non-mag, then hold it in there till I see a different colour. Not a mjor change, any recognizable change. This is obviously subjective, but seems to work. On ebay, they are selling laser thermos for like 15 bucks, mostly they just do the tempering ranges, but some are higher. Seems they would be useful for a number of things.
" I am also worried about creating overly large carbides during the process and thus not being able to acheive a keen edge."
I wouldn't sweat it. I wouldn't use A2 either. for better info scour knife forums.
" TomD, what is the disadvantage of the 5% chromium content?"
Not sure I have the right end of it, but chrome seems to run with knives that are hard to sharpen.
"With either steel, should I be shooting for a higher hardness, like 62 or 63?"
For cutting edges, it is hard to get it too hard, probably in part because the initial hardening may not be perfect.
"Would one of the high speed steels be a better choice here?"
Some of the better HSSs produce better results in terms of edge holding and sharpness, when dry ground or otherwise abused, as intended. But for an entirely hand routine, I prefer O1 to A2 or HSS. Some HSS are pretty good for hand sharpening, but most are more trouble. You have not actually said what you want. O1 is pretty darn good stuff, it is hard to take anything further than O1 without picking up some undesireable traits. So the more you go for, the more specialized your needs and definitions need to be. I guess the new LV steel is an attempt to get more performance without any downside. But most super steels have definite downsides.
"I use Norton waterstones for sharpening, and have recently started hollow-grinding some tools. My heat treating gear is extremely minimal, basically consisting of a propane torch and a toaster oven. When I made a corner chisel, I couldn't get more than the 1" at the tip up to temperature. I'm hoping that adding a second torch and maybe containing some of the heat with a tin can, will be sufficient for plane irons. Oh, I also have weber grill, which possibly could be drafted into service as a some sort of charcoal forge with the assistence of the shop vac or air compressor. "
First, there is nothing wrong with getting only 1" done. We aren't making crowbars. By the time you make stout enough tools to deal with vibe, you are pretty much dealing with strong enough tools. There are not that many US woodworkers who are working their way honestly through an inch of steel, particularly if one includes normal consumer or experimental factors.
I have heard it said guys making one brick forges have forged 12" bowies, but I find it hard to see. I have no trouble doing anything you would want as a woodworker, in a home made forge that runs off BBQ propane.