New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

Posts

Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

#1

Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

Lars Parrington

Is there a big performance difference between O1 tool steel (at ~61HRC) and the steel used for the irons of Vintage Stanley planes, in terms of time between sharpenings? The Stanley planes I have all seem to date from 1930's to 1950's, so that's the vintage I'm interested in here.

I'd been thinking of making up a few replacement irons out of O1 since it seems like a fun and easy project. However, lately I've been wondering if there would actually be a noticable improvement. A2 might also be an option, if someone can convince me that I can effectively heat treat it in my backyard.

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

#2

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

TomD

I have some A2, but never got around to it. It can be home heat treated. It can be air hardened, or oil hardened, and for our kind of work, it can be tempered in the oven at temperatures that are doable. It is a 5% chromium steel, and I think that may be why I do not like it.

O1 I have heat treated a fair amount, and I really like everything about it. I can't compare it to later Stanley steels, at some point those companies started making really bad blades, by the 70s. My dad had a Stanley, probably from the 50s. It was no pleasure. Though the body is pretty nice.

Home heat treated O1 is a wonderful steel. Easy to work with at every stage. It is very similar to "cast" steel from the 19th century. I find it sharpens and uses so similarly that I can use all the same techniques with it. If you are dissatisfied with your Stanley blades, and not because they aren't a super steel. If they seem below the performance mean, rather than failing to be way above it, I would say O1 would be an improvement. It is at or above the performance mean. If my shop burned down, I would loose hundreds of high end Japanese tools, but I would not replace them. I would make replacements in O1. I would buy a few of Rob's new tools and try them out for those rare situations where I am planing or working something that seems to contain valve grinding compound. The Japanese tools are a large cut above, make no mistake, but I would not replace them.

Most commonly I work maple, cherry, beech, hickory, oak, walnut, softwoods, rosewood, ebony, real mahogany. I also work plywood with hand tools. O1 is fine for all of these.

I do use a lot of HSS in the shop.

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

#3

Re: Not as Hard

david weaver

I don't know exactly what alloy stanley used through different years, certainly the modern cutters are not the same thing as the cutters from the turn of the century.

There is some variation in my older stanley cutters, between the early laminated cutters, the cutters right after that, then the sweetheart cutters and finally the modern junk. Variation both between and within those groups. All of the irons I have from stanley are plenty fine to do any work.

But none is as hard as one of the new O1 steel irons that is brought up to high hardness. I'm sure that is a result of a planned hardness level at stanley, the irons were probably tempered to a hardness that would make them easy to sharpen with all kinds of natural and synthetic stones (O1 that is brought to 62+ hardness is not pleasant on some stones, especially if you don't have a grinder nearby).

I am also sure that it (the hardness) is not due to some urban myths, such as the steel was inferior or that only with modern technology can you harden steel to a high hardness and consistently. The razor makers were doing it back then, and before then (at least back into the late 1800s), with much better steel than O1 and with deadly consistent results, and much finer grinds than any plane iron.

I have yet to see any vintage american straight razor that was a dud, they have superb very high carbon steel in them.

Remember when you're looking at the vintage stanley irons that they were targeted at carpenters, cabinetmakers, etc, all at the same time, so they had to be serviceable for all of those folks, too.

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

#4

Re: Not as Hard

TomD

Yeah, and mahogany, real mahogany, was a very easy wood to work, even compared to cherry. So as you say, they were targeting their market.

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

#5

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

Lars Parrington

Ok, I did a bit more research on heat treating A2, and it seems like it may be doable. The main difficulty is that I would not be able to use the magnet test to gauge whether the steel has reached conversion temperature. I am also worried about creating overly large carbides during the process and thus not being able to acheive a keen edge. TomD, what is the disadvantage of the 5% chromium content?

With either steel, should I be shooting for a higher hardness, like 62 or 63? And maybe it would be worthwhile to re-harden the old stanley irons while I'm at it, assuming they are good steel, but just not optimally hardened. That would be the same process as for O1, correct?

Would one of the high speed steels be a better choice here?

I use Norton waterstones for sharpening, and have recently started hollow-grinding some tools. My heat treating gear is extremely minimal, basically consisting of a propane torch and a toaster oven. When I made a corner chisel, I couldn't get more than the 1" at the tip up to temperature. I'm hoping that adding a second torch and maybe containing some of the heat with a tin can, will be sufficient for plane irons. Oh, I also have weber grill, which possibly could be drafted into service as a some sort of charcoal forge with the assistence of the shop vac or air compressor.

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

#6

craigd

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

craigd

I have most of a full rack of pre-WWII Stanleys and have made two O-1 1/8" thick replacement blades, a #3 and #7. I don't notice any difference. The old blades (stanley and others), both laminated and solid, are good steel and well tempered but about as flat as corrugated roofing. I have LV #3 & block A2 blades (and 2" x 1/4" A2 blades) and they might be better but not enough that I prefer one over the other.

If you make an O-1 blade, don't temper much above R60, it will chip in use.

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

#7

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

david weaver

You don't have enough gear to do the stanley irons any better than they are done. Plus, you'll increase the grain size of the steel if you reharden them.

Also, you don't know with them whether they are oil hardening or water hardening steel, and may need to do some of them twice, and run the risk of them warping if they're water hardening steel.

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

#8

Re: Vintage stanley irons vs. O1 steel

TomD

"Ok, I did a bit more research on heat treating A2, and it seems like it may be doable. The main difficulty is that I would not be able to use the magnet test to gauge whether the steel has reached conversion temperature."

I did read some were using the mag test. Even with O1 it actually is supposed to be held higher than the mag level by 0 degrees for 10 minutes. I go non-mag, then hold it in there till I see a different colour. Not a mjor change, any recognizable change. This is obviously subjective, but seems to work. On ebay, they are selling laser thermos for like 15 bucks, mostly they just do the tempering ranges, but some are higher. Seems they would be useful for a number of things.

" I am also worried about creating overly large carbides during the process and thus not being able to acheive a keen edge."

I wouldn't sweat it. I wouldn't use A2 either. for better info scour knife forums.

" TomD, what is the disadvantage of the 5% chromium content?"

Not sure I have the right end of it, but chrome seems to run with knives that are hard to sharpen.

"With either steel, should I be shooting for a higher hardness, like 62 or 63?"

For cutting edges, it is hard to get it too hard, probably in part because the initial hardening may not be perfect.

"Would one of the high speed steels be a better choice here?"

Some of the better HSSs produce better results in terms of edge holding and sharpness, when dry ground or otherwise abused, as intended. But for an entirely hand routine, I prefer O1 to A2 or HSS. Some HSS are pretty good for hand sharpening, but most are more trouble. You have not actually said what you want. O1 is pretty darn good stuff, it is hard to take anything further than O1 without picking up some undesireable traits. So the more you go for, the more specialized your needs and definitions need to be. I guess the new LV steel is an attempt to get more performance without any downside. But most super steels have definite downsides.

"I use Norton waterstones for sharpening, and have recently started hollow-grinding some tools. My heat treating gear is extremely minimal, basically consisting of a propane torch and a toaster oven. When I made a corner chisel, I couldn't get more than the 1" at the tip up to temperature. I'm hoping that adding a second torch and maybe containing some of the heat with a tin can, will be sufficient for plane irons. Oh, I also have weber grill, which possibly could be drafted into service as a some sort of charcoal forge with the assistence of the shop vac or air compressor. "

First, there is nothing wrong with getting only 1" done. We aren't making crowbars. By the time you make stout enough tools to deal with vibe, you are pretty much dealing with strong enough tools. There are not that many US woodworkers who are working their way honestly through an inch of steel, particularly if one includes normal consumer or experimental factors.

I have heard it said guys making one brick forges have forged 12" bowies, but I find it hard to see. I have no trouble doing anything you would want as a woodworker, in a home made forge that runs off BBQ propane.