New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

plane nomenclature

Posts

plane nomenclature

#1

plane nomenclature

Eric in Los Gatos

OK, up until a minute ago I had never really thought about what distinguishes a rabbet plane from a shoulder plane aside from their intended jobs. Gun to my head I'd say that, typically, shoulder planes have narrower irons. This morning on Jim Bode's daily blurb he listed a shoulder plane with a 1-1/8" iron and a rabbet plane with a 3/8" iron. The basic forms of both planes are mighty similar. I would have thought it the other way around.

Sorry, don't how to elegantly show a link so here's the url: http://www.jimbodetools.com/cart.php?m=product_list&pageNumber=&catID=&c=67&v=&r=&id=&sortBy=pID&search=&shopByPrice=&viewAll=&customListIds=

So can any clear this up for me? Is it Jim Bode muddying the waters or is it me?

Thanks,

Eric

Re: plane nomenclature

#2

Re: plane nomenclature

James Watriss

I always figured a rabbet plane would have a higher pitch, since it's for face grain, and a shoulder plane was low-angle block geometry for paring end grain...

But I never confirmed that half- baked assumption.

Re: plane nomenclature

#3

My thoughts, and no expert

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"Rabbet plane" describes a plane on which the cutting iron extends out to/past the side of the plane's body.

"Shoulder plane" is a subset of that general type, designed/optimized to cut the end grain on tenon shoulders and the like. This optimization included low-angle bedding of the iron. Many traditional (infill) wedged shoulder planes provided very little chip escapement, because the assumption appears to have been that the "chips" would be end grain curlies/dust, not needing much room to get out.

The little Preston 3/8" rabbet wasn't sold as a shoulder plane but as a general purpose little trimming plane, which is why it gets called a rabbet plane, even though it shares a lot of the same characteristics like low bedding angle.

And it's further confusing because the metal shoulder planes, like the Preston shown in the link you included, tend to have pretty decent chip escapements compared to the infill versions, and can be used as multi-purpose rabbet planes (indeed, I own four shoulder planes, and have used them for end-grain shoulder cutting about 1% of the times I've used them - the rest of the time, they've trimmed rabbets or work on which I was working up against an obstruction of some kind).

I think the width of the iron is a poor indicator. The shoulder planes I own are all wider than the Stanley 192 rabbet plane that I also own (the 192 is NOT a shoulder plane, its iron being set at 45 degrees, bevel down), and not much narrower than my Stanley 78.

Your confusion is understandable. I think, to a degree, the "shoulder" plane designation is like those jokes about country directions, in which the local giving directions says, "Go down the road a piece to where the old Hawkins place was, before it burned down, and turn left until you come to the Smith farm [which farm has been owned by people named Jones for three generations, but is still named after the family that homesteaded it]." The historical function is attached to certain configurations of plane, but not to others, and you have to know the history to make sense of the distinctions. This is not to say that shoulder planes are no good for shoulders - they are, after all, low angle planes, optimal for end grain cutting - just that they're not limited to that function, as the wedged infill planes somewhat were due to the limited chip escapement.

Bill, who has committed the venial sin of using a Stanley 78 rabbet plane as a bench plane, even though that's not in the catalog description for its uses.

Re: plane nomenclature

#4

Re: plane nomenclature

TomD

Yeah, the low angle thing for shoulders, and the blade flush. Rebate is a specific width with some side projection, higher angle (though it really isn't all that important), and possibly knickers. Traditionally there are a range of planes that make similar cuts like moving fillister, dovetail, etc...

Re: plane nomenclature

#5

Re: My thoughts, and no expert

Patrick Gibbons

I would just add that rabbet planes are for making a joint and will remove more wood than a shoulder plane which is for adjusting a previously made joint and so removes far less wood. I would argue that a rabbet plane is more necessary than a shoulder plane though a power tool user would not agree with that statement at all.