New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Substrate for quartersawn veneer

Posts

Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#1

Substrate for quartersawn veneer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

I have some 1/8" quartersawn satinwood veneer to cover a writing desk. Veneer sheets will finish out to a bit over 6" wide, so will take three sheets to cover desktop, allowing for the surrounding solid satinwood border.

Question: What is the most desirable underlayment for the veneer. I am thinking solid wood, but marine ply is an option if that is better owing to stability.

If solid wood underlayment, would I be better off using plain sawn or quarter sawn as underlay? And if quartersawn, does species matter--for example, I wouldn't want to bury quartered satinwood as underlay--would quartered oak (for example) do as well? Also, if quartered, would you orient the grain of the veneer same as grain of underlay, or crosswise? I would think orient grain the same way, but am seriously uncertain.

We have a mild climate here; no extreme swings of temperature or humidity (indoors).

Thanks for your help!

Wiley

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#2

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

James Watriss

Hi Wiley,

Marine plywood has advantages, for sure. It's easy, is the big one. But I've seen plywood warp, too, so if you go that route, sticker the whole sheet and watch it for a day or two before you cut, in case you need to bring it back.

Way back when I made my chess table, I used solid wood. Strips were cut and laminated to provide a more or less quarter sawn surface. Choose for straight, clear grain.

On top of that, one layer, each side, of veneer running cross-grain to the wood. Glue up both sides at the same time. Glue shrinks when it cures, and the tension is enough to cup a full, flat panel. Doing both sides balances the stress. At the time, I figured gluing the second side would balance everything out. It didn't, it cupped the other way. Bah, phooey.

Pick a simple veneer that 's easy and cheap. I think I used mahogany, but it might have been maple. The veneer is there to keep any potential weird movement issues in the core from telegraphing to the final surface, so species isn't important. But make sure it's lighter than your surface, in case you need to stain it darker to match. (Sanding errors, etc.)

When you go to cut your surface veneer, cut way oversize. You can glue blocks to it that way to align to your panel, and keep it from sliding around when you bag/ press it.

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#3

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

William Duffield

What kind of glue are you using? If a water based glue, then I would not recommend an MDF core, unless you can find the waterproof MDF, whose brand name escapes me. MDF would work fine with contact cement or epoxy. An additional issue is its weight, if you think someone may be moving the desk often. That's usually a problem only with small tables, however.

Another choice is baltic birch plywood. Glue the satinwood with its grain running perpendicular to the top layer of birch. At the same time, glue another sheet of veneer to the bottom. For best results, its coefficient of expansion with changes in humidity should be similar to the satinwood.

Third choice is a substrate of a stable solid hardwood. My first choice would be quartersawn tulip poplar. Over that, top and bottom, apply a layer of crossbanded veneer. Again, my choice would be tulip poplar. Then apply the satinwood and utility bottom veneer over that, perpendicular to the underlaid veneer.

Fourth choice is lumber core plywood. I've used lauan, until I developed a sensitivity to it. I don't know if it is still available. I heard a rumor that they had clear cut all of it in the Philippines.

In any case, each layer you add should have the grain oriented perpendicular to the layer immediately below it.

Hope this helps, and isn't too many options.

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#4

an easy answer

Bill Tindall

unless you need to mold the edge do what factories do, lay it up on plywood, with Baltic birch being the best.

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#5

Ellis Walentine

My take

Ellis Walentine

Hi Wiley,

I've done numerous veneering jobs with thick veneers, and I've usually laid them up with PVA or Unibond 800 on veneer-core plywood or MDF. I use the latter where the panel needs to be dead flat and is not supported by a framework or some sort of bracing. In a writing table, I assume you will have aprons and interior stretchers that will keep the top flat, so you can probably get away with plywood.

I generally try to thickness the veneers down to about 1/10" to make them behave more like veneer than solid wood. I believe it helps the glue to resist cross-grain shrinkage over the immovable substrate. I also work glue into the edge joints between the veneers -- usually by opening the joint and rolling or brushing a thin layer of glue onto the adjacent edges -- to further resist the tendency for the joints to shrink open, which can be a problem with thick or sawn veneer.

Ellis

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#6

Re: MDF Question

William Duffield

Ellis,

I don't use MDF a lot, because every time I try to work it, I find more properties that I really dislike. These include the way it expands when I try to drive screws into it or if I get it wet. Why don't you get surface irregularities from water based glues that telegraph through the veneer?

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#7

Response and followup

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thank you all, and particularly James, William, Bill, and Ellis! Well, I learned something--didn't know one needed additional (interior) layers of crossbanded veneer over a solid wood core. It really amounts to making your own plywood. So I might as well use the 9-layer marine ply I have right now. James, I would never have thought of the use of blocks to butt up and align the sawn veneers! Bill, you mentioned molding: Yes, the plywood/veneeer section will be surrounded on four sides by solid quartered satinwood, probably 2" width + or -, and some type of edge treatment--ogee mold, or a simple band or inlay.

Ellis and William, I had been planning on using old brown glue because of its workability and cleanup friendliness. But perhaps I should go with Ellis' experience and use PVA. I am worried a lot about the exact lay-up sequence--apply sheet by sheet, or make up the whole top and apply at once (along with the balancing bottom veneer).

I want the top to be seamless in appearance, just like when you edge join solid boards. I had thought it would be best to keep all the meat I could in the veneer, to assist the initial edge join, plus there's something there to plane, to remove the resaw fuzz.

When you guys lay-up sawn veneer like this, do you go sheet by sheet, or make up the whole section, and lay it up in one big sheet? The veneer is approx. 1/8" thick.

Thank you,

Wiley

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#8

Re: Response and followup

William Duffield

I have always glued and taped* the joints, and then laid it up in one big sheet. If you do it individually, you have the problem with needing to clean up glue squeeze out, with the potential to damage the edge of the sheet you have already laid down.

Adding banding, stringing or purfling is a horse of a different feather. In that case, you are cutting away and redefining the boundary, usually referencing the edge of the top, not the veneer sheet. There's much less chance of damaging the stringing when scraping out excess glue, since you are working with the grain, and if you do damage it, it's easy to repair, invisibly.

*Tape goes on top, on the show surface! I have a story about a hard lesson learned about that, which is why I probably mention it too often.

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#10

That is how I was taught


Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#11

Re: Response and followup

James Watriss

I've used PVA. I've come to appreciate the ability to re-work hide glue.

I lay down whole surfaces, already glued together: Hold the seam together. Use masking tape on the glue side to hold the whole seam together. Hinge the seam open, add glue. Close up and veneer tape the show side. When the glue dries, pull the masking tape. I did this (in many stages) with the chess board, the surrounding field of mitered book matched corners, and a field surrounding that)

The alignment blocks on the final surface were key.

Subsequent inlays, put fling, etc, were inlaid into the glued down surface.

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#12

Ellis Walentine

Re: MDF Question

Ellis Walentine

My suspicion, William, is that when you roll on an even coating of glue, it affects the surface of the MDF equally, so any swelling is uniform across the surface. Of course, with sawn veneers, you don't need to worry about anything telegraphing through.

As for things not to like about MDF, I only choose it for flatness and warp-resistance. I don't like the weight, or the clouds of sawdust, or the porous edges, or the hydroscopic nature of it, and it definitely requires some special approaches to fasteners and joinery.

Ellis

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#13

Ellis Walentine

Re: Response and followup

Ellis Walentine

By all means, lay up entire faces, both sides. For regular thin veneers (1/42" to 1/28") I use paper veneer tape in an old pharmacist's label dispenser that moistens the tape as you pull it off the roll. I begin with tape across the ends of each sheet to keep it from cracking open under caul pressure. then I put 3" long sections of tape across the joint every inch or two. If the veneer is very flat, you can tape it at wider intervals and follow up with long pieces of tape over the joint parallel to the grain.

For thick veneers like your satinwood, I would use fresh masking tape, which has a springy clamping effect that you don't get so much with paper tape. Masking tape isn't as good a choice for thin and softer veneers, because it has greater thickness than paper tape, and the clamping pressure tends to drive it right into the veneer. It's also a bear to get off, whereas paper tape comes off easily if you daub it with a wet sponge and wait a couple minutes.

I usually cut the taped face to about 1/4" wider and longer than the substrate, which is cut to the exact size of the finished panel. I use pieces of masking tape at the center of all four sides of the panel, wrapped from front around the edge of the substrate to the backer. If it needs to be more accurately registered than that, I make the sheet and backer bigger than necessary and trim the whole magilla after glue-up.

Ellis

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#14

Re: Response and followup

Tony - Memphis

I recently had a similar dilemma. I was veneering a round top with a sunburst pattern with banding and inlay. It seems about half of the suggestions said to lay the field then add everything else and half said make it one piece and glue it all down at once. I did the one piece approach. My reasoning was that it would be easier to make corrections before everything was glued and I wouldn't have to try and cut out for the inlay. It worked fine. One concern was the different thicknesses of the various parts. I used a flexible pond liner material under the caul to help with that. Stil had a few bubbles. I'll try gum rubber or canvas as suggested by soem other folks next time. Good luck with your project. Satinwood is beautiful stuff. I used it for my cross banding. This batch didn't quite have the glow that the last stuff I bought did, but it is still pretty. The previous batch was very gold and practically glows in the dark! Oh, I use MDF for all of my veneering. I sometimes use liquid hide glue, the new pva's for veneering, and Unibond.

Tony


Funny, I spent lots of time getting "perfect" joints between the pieces, then decided I liked the look of the black inlay in between them! Oh well.


Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#15

Re: Response and followup

Paul M.

I did the same thing that Ellis is suggesting here on a large desktop surface for my wife's art projects. I bought thick 1/10" mahogany veneer for the desktop surfaces (writing desk plus two cabinet tops). I wanted thick veneer so I would have some extra thickness to work with this as wood and not as paper. Using dyes on veneer sometimes is hit and miss due to the glue penetration, and I wanted to make sure that was not an issue here.

I jointed all edges and fastened them together dry using blue masking tape to tape one side together tightly. The tape goes across the joint, and you fix one side securely and pull the other side pretty strongly until the tape stretches before tacking it down to the other leaf. I do this dry on one side, turn the assembly over, and tent the joint so that I can get glue on the edges. Then flatten it back out to tighten the glue into the joint and then stretch tape across the joint on this side too. This is the method I use for bookmatching guitar tops and backs, and I just used it on a much grander scale.

Then into the vacuum bag with thinned yellow glue to glue the veneer down to the baltic birch substrate.

I even used three strips of the same veneer as a thick banding around the edges so that I had enough wood to put a small bevel around the edges. It came out looking great. It took the dye in without any glue interference, and my wife is happy with her new art desk.

Re: Substrate for quartersawn veneer

#16

Tony, that is stunning!!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I like the black accenting too.

How in the world did you do the satinwood border? Did you cut the satinwood pieces to a paper pattern, and figure out a way to butt them up? Or are the joints mitered so that each segment is over- and under-lapping its mates? It looks absolutely seamless.

Wonderful job!

Wiley