New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

problem with tearout

Posts

problem with tearout

#1

problem with tearout

eliot d

I believe I really have some fine planes now -- including my recently built Japanese kanna. And when I plane some reasonably soft wood, I get a truly fine surface. But I tried it on some hard maple and got terrible tearout. It may have planned in the wrong direction at first, but I did it the other way also. The blade is sharp too. I was disappointed, as you can imagine. Any thoughts?

Re: problem with tearout

#2

Re: problem with tearout

James Watriss

Many thoughts...

-softwood and maple are very different. Pine and cedar can be much more forgiving. Even fir can be pretty agreeable. And some hardwoods, too, like Walnut. Sam Maloof said that unlike Walnut, maple is not a 'friendly,' wood. Attractive, yes, but not as forgiving as walnut.

-Even among maple, some maple responds better than others. And sometimes, the grain can be deceiving. I've planed a lot of maple that didn't work well in the direction that *looked* like the right way to go, but worked fine the other way.

-Tight mouths and chip breakers help. Thin shavings help. High bedding angle helps. Very sharp irons are a very good place to start. My best experiences have always been with laminated high carbon blades, bedded at least at 45. 48 is better. (infill plane. :-))

Maple CAN be rewarding to work with, but when you come to work with it, you have to come to it the right way. I'm sure this isn't the PC way to say it, but anyone who's ever been in the doghouse with his wife knows what I mean. Assuming you know how to do right by maple, it will be forgiving, and shine with a radiant inner glow, revealing subtleties of figure and grain that aren't otherwise apparent. But if you forget, for a minute, it will not be so pleasant.

But it does take time to figure out how to do right by maple.

Re: problem with tearout

#3

craigd

Re: problem with tearout

craigd

I'm guessing your planes are in the 40º-45º cutting angle range?

[Softwoods truly look great when cut at a low angle and Schtoo (http://toolsfromjapan.com/) has shown that Kannas do well on hardwoods.]

If so, I think James nailed it - you probably need to fine tune the chip breaker (plus his other suggestions). For me, 55º and above works fine on maple with no chip breaker and 50º is usually good. If my Stanleys have the chip breaker set per the recent discussions and the blade is sharp, I get good results, if not, ouch!

Here is some fiddle back? maple planed at 55º:


Re: problem with tearout

#4

Re: problem with tearout

Ethan Liou

Maple is my favorite. Its fine texture gives a silky shinning surface after planing. Here's some thoughts.

1. reduce the depth of cut to about 0.001", this usually solved the problem

2. put chip breaker really close to the blade edge, about a hair away.

I use these two method and had been having good results. I always keep my plane mouth wide open. (I hate clogs more than anything).

Hope this helps.

Re: problem with tearout

#5

Re: problem with tearout

TomD

It could be the piece of wood also. Frankly, while Malloff may have dissed maple (and in his own house had quite a few contrasting pieces using it), let's face it, you don't get paid more to use it, it costs more than rosewood in many cases, at wholesale, and is harder to work. But, it planes to a beautiful deep finish. Early in my career, I had a little scrap of maple with very simple grain, nothing spectacular, but it was so beautiful after it was planed that I kept it in my pocket for a good long while.

Also, the number I have for planing maple with a Japanese plane is 43°, soft maple 41°. A chipbreaker may make life easier, but is not required for good results. I would attempt a fine shaving, the prerequisites for which are a sharp blade with the correct camber (or flat), and a sole that is flat. Everything else is secondary.

Re: problem with tearout

#6

Re: problem with tearout

david weaver

If I were using your plane, and you were dead set on using it for that, I would put a tiny back bevel on it about 10-15 degrees. Like so tiny you could barely see it, so that when you don't want to use it again, you could just hone it off.

A cap iron would also work fine, but you have to be able to set it properly.

Maple can be deceptively difficult to plane sometimes with a single iron and a shallow pitch, and other times it cooperates wonderfully.

That said, after learning to use the cap iron on a simple cheap common pitch metal bench plane at warren's urging, I haven't had any tearout on anything except one piece dead quartered cocobolo (that tears out with any plane I use of any type, and crushes in the early wood with a scraper).

If I were in your shoes and I thought I was going to plane maple fairly often, I would get a plane where the cap iron can be set very quickly easily (which for me is a cheap bench plane).

Re: problem with tearout

#7

Re: problem with tearout

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Eliot and all,

Congratulations on finishing the kanna! More on it below.....

But first, you indicated you have more than one plane. I suggest you get the blades on all of them sharpened to your best, then test them all, taking fine shavings from that same piece of maple. Do they all yield the same results? Which works best? Which gives the most trouble? Details are important here. This is an initial trouble-shooting step, to pin down where the problem is, and where it isn't.

Specific to the kanna. Is it a double-iron plane, or does it have only the main blade (the Japanese make them both ways, though you see more with double irons). What is the bedding angle? How is the sole prepared--where is it touching the work?

Check: is the blade cutting symmetrically across its width: put a narrow stick in a vise (or just hold it in your hand), set for a fine shaving (1 thou or less), and test the shaving thickness across the width of the blade. Don't need to measure--you just want to know is the cut symmetrical across the blade width. This will tell you whether the blade is installed somewhat askew--if it is, you'll likely get tearout no matter what else is happening. If it turns out the blade is askew, and there is not enough lateral room to adjust, you'll need to provide slightly more lateral room, using either a side float or a 1/8" chisel, taking care not to alter the top or floor of the blade channel.

You can also test whether the kanna has full bedding support down near the cutting edge. And again, is this a single blade or double-iron plane? Pencil the blade bottom and insert it to depth, and look where the pencil marks are on the bed--do you have contact at the lower end? If this is a difficult test to run, or to see the results of, take a Post-It note (they are about 3.5 thousandths thick) and stick loosely to the bedding of the plane, and particularly at lower end. Re-insert blade to find out: will the blade still extend to cutting depth using the same hammer-tap force as before? If it does, recheck the blade for skew and see how it cuts now. If you have to tap harder, restrict the post-it to lower end only (last 1/2" of bedding contact, say) and recheck. If it's still taking a heavier hammer-tap to get to cutting depth, then you know you're about right without the paper shim.

Finally, on the kanna, regardless of tearout, are you able to consistently get a full width shaving off a flat board? Or is it erratic--cutting, then not cutting, sometimes digging into the board, or cutting one-side only? If so, this is an indication of a high spot on the sole, typically just to the rear of the blade, though it could also be in front of blade. Let us know if there is a problem in this regard, and we can take the next step.

Main thing to check first, though, is to test additional planes on the same pieceof maple

Wiley

Re: problem with tearout

#8

Re: problem with tearout

eliot d

All the replies are useful, but yours seems most thorough. I will try all that you suggest. Thanks.

Re: problem with tearout

#9

Also, I meant to say

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

that if you do need to pare back the sidewalls for lateral adjustment, do this only along the upper two-thirds of the iron's contact. Leave the lower end as is--you want the blade to pivot slightly with the lower end of the blade fixed as is. Usually won't need to remove more than 1/64" each side, so take it easy.

Hope this helps,

Wiley

Re: problem with tearout

#10

Re: Also, I meant to say

TomD

If you get intermittent results it can be a lot of things: the board, the bench surface, or the technique. Even in perfect situations, you will throw English into the plane that will cause it to vary shaving thickness. When taking transparent shavings, if you can plane those out, it is good technique. Thicker shavings may seem even, only because unless you measure them, you may not note the issues.

For fine shaving and getting your mojo going, using a jig, and working a straight across edge will get you there faster. You can add other techniques, and details later.

I have to disagree on one point, if we are talking about Japanese planes, the mortise should be tight all around the top, and the lateral adjust is in the bottom of the slot. LV has those little screws low down, so who knows what might work, but the master who taught me said the top is tight. One does have to be careful should the dai shrink, it can split the plane due to the tolerances with the blade.