New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Repairing an infill plane...

Posts

Repairing an infill plane...

#1

Repairing an infill plane...

James Watriss

I was having an issue with a wiggling handle on an old Spiers.

Emailed Konrad Sauer, and he suggested I drill the pins, pull the infill, and fix it.

I whined and cried about it, and wondered why I couldn't just inject the whole thing with glue... but I pulled the infill out this morning.

It's amazing how rough some of the hidden surfaces were...

Turns out the tenon on the handle was tapered, which is why it wiggled in the groove in the bottom of the infill. Never would have guessed that one.

This is going to be an interesting project...

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#2

Pictures?  If not, didn't happen


Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#3

Trust

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I take James at his word. I think it offensive to suggest that his tale did not happen. I know that Bill is only being playful here. However, I have had it happen to me that someone used this technique in order to suggest that I was not truthful. In that situation it is pretty nasty.

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#4

Re: Trust

James Watriss

Thanks, Warren. I appreciate the vote of confidence. It means a lot.

Anyways, If he'd been reading my blog today he'd have seen the photos.

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#5

Missed those pics; I'll have to track them down


Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#6

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

Brian from Monument

If that happened with my plane handle, I might glassbed the handle to the plane bed.

It is not a purist approach but it would work.

This is an adaption of glassbedding a rifles receiver.

I am a gunsmith.

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#8

Jameswatriss.blogspot.com


Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#9

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

James Watriss

That's an interesting thought... My only real concern would be how the bedding would hold up over time as the wood moves. I may do something similar with hide glue and sawdust though.

I'm not a purist, for sure. But I do like the reversibility of hide glue if something goes awry.

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#10

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

Brian from Monument

The bedding material is a form of epoxy and is bonded very well to the wood.

Like a single item.

It fits on the planes metal nicely since the metal was part of the form.

The metal needs a release agent, I use a fine grease.

No harm to the metal, no harm to the bedding material.

There is no real concern about wood movement, for an item such as the handle/tote.

For larger areas, it is still a small concern as you can work only in those areas where there are attachments.

For a rifles action we think of it only having a movement problem around the guard screws.

Yet the holes where the guard screws penetrate the wood, the area is opened to permit motion.

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#11

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

James Watriss

Yeah, I understand most of that. I think that part of what's in my head right now is that I'm happy to have been able to take the plane apart and re-work it, despite the age of the plane. Preserving that ability in the future seems like a good idea. Epoxy seems pretty permanent in a way that hide glue is not.

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#12

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

Brian from Monument

The epoxy is only permanent more or less with the wood itself.

The way I would do it the wood would be separable from the metal.

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#13

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

barryvabeach

Jim, you didn't notice, but while you were scratching your head about why in the world the tenon had a taper, I snuck into your shop and took a photo of the tenon. I assume yours looked like this - this is from a Spiers infill I have - I never could figure out why it was tapered, and made the tenon on the replacement handle full size. You can barely make out a reglued crack in the handle about an inch up from the bottom. I see a reglued crack in that spot on most of the Spiers I see listed for sale on ebay - is yours cracked there as well? BTW, hope you enjoy your plane, I really like the way an old Spiers feels.

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#14

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi James

For what it's worth, I also used epoxy to bed the infill in a Spier smoother. There is a write up here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolRestorations/Renovating%20an%20Infill%20Smoother1.html

The use of epoxy - and for that matter the extreme design I ended with - did not phase me. I only had a steel shell and the lever cap to start with, so I had fun.

Every now-and-then I think of returning it to a more traditional form. Perhaps ...

Epoxy is easy to remove with a little heat.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#15

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

James Watriss

Best I can figure, the taper is there because the slot was done with something related to a dado stack, and they wanted to clear the radius. But it's overkill, as the handle clears it by a mile.

Re: handle cracks...

Yes, I had a crack in the handle. The reinforcing rod kept the wood separated, so simple glue and clamp wasn't an option. I turned the cracks into saw kerfs and filled with veneer instead. Handle's very solid now...

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#16

Re: Repairing an infill plane... *LINK*

barryvabeach

Jim, glad you got it solid. Here is one that they did not use bailing wire or duct tape, but about everything else it seems. Enlarge the 4th photo to see the screws, and nails. etc.


Repairs to Spiers Handle

Re: Repairing an infill plane...

#17

WOW... I mean, just... Wow.