New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

How to make stain-answer to question below

Posts

How to make stain-answer to question below

#1

How to make stain-answer to question below

Bill Tindall

I prefer a mineral pigment stain. Iron oxide, for example, will remain the same color for light years and more. Synthetic dyes and pigments won't. The reason I use a stain is to keep wood roughly the same color over time, especially walnut which will bleach blond over time. To that end I stain all walnut, mahogany and cherry and some oak.

There was a time when all stains were mineral pigments. Now they are more often synthetic pigments and dyes and companies seem bent on reformulating every few years which drives one nuts trying to maintain a finishing schedule. So I concluded "screw it" and started making my own stains and fillers.

There are two routes to a pigment stain. One case uses "Neutral" General Finishes stain/conditioner(as recommended by the General Finishes chief formulator). The other case uses linseed oil as the liquid portion.

I have used various sources of mineral pigment but what I have found best is Moser's Japan Color available from Woodworkers Supply. It can simply be stirred into the General Finishes product. It must be worked into linseed oil. A lot of stirring will accomplish the task or a lesser amount of grinding it together with mortar and pestle or equivalent. About 10% pigment by weight in the liquid is a good starting place for formulation.

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

#2

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

TomD

"The reason I use a stain is to keep wood roughly the same color over time, especially walnut which will bleach blond over time. To that end I stain all walnut, mahogany and cherry and some oak."

I have never seen walnut go light in a human time frame, most woods go black in several hundred years. I can't think of any good reason to stain wood. It creates an unrealistic photo negative contrast, and the colour however sturdy is superficial.

I do like to use vinegaroon but purely due to the whacktastic results one gets. Black is a special case.

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

#3

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

TomD

Here is an old walnut gun:

http://museumvictoria.com.au/collections/itemimages/204/121/204121_Large.jpg

Not exactly the colour of ash.

One thing though is I don't really care if the wood changes, it is as it is supposed to be. I think there is a tendency to want something to look old immediately, or stay one colour for ever. But the old stuff got that way over time, and would still be changing if left alone.

Clear case of everyone having an opinion, though.

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

#4

Stone Age

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There was a time when all stains were mineral pigments.

I can't imagine what you are thinking here. Are talking about the Stone Age? Something in your memory?

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

#5

Bleached walnut

Bill Tindall

I'll post some pictures of bleached walnut when I can get to it and othes can decide for themselves. I was at a conference table some time ago that was so bleached out I did not recognize it to be walnut at first. It was the color of old ash.

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

#6

Stone Age pigments

Bill Tindall

The historical pigment stains were finely ground minerals, oxides of iron and manganese, for example, milled into oil. So yes, it could be said that these were/are stone age pigments.

There can be a huge difference in the effect of pigment stains. Stains like burnt umber are translucent and when very finely ground the result is more attractive than in the case where coarsely ground opaque pigments are used, which can look like paint if applied heavily.

The pigment stains are selectively trapped in pores to enhance them, if such is desirable.

For those that eschew sanding pigment stains can stain too dark in the open pores of a hand planed surface, so I can see that they could be undesirable for some. On the other hand, on a well prepared surface they are trivial to apply compared to soluble stains and vastly safer than chemical stains. Only someone ignorant to the perils of chromate would use it now days.

An example of a pigment stain is shown on this cherry spool bed. If you don't like the look then don't consider pigment stains.

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

#7

Re:  Stone Age pigments

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Of course I know that pigments were used in the Stone Age. What I am asking is for you to explain the statement:

There was a time when all stains were mineral pigments.

Just what time are you referring to? When was it that all stains were mineral pigments?

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

#8

another old gun

Bill Tindall


Finished in 1959. It is the color it is because it is oiled. Who knows what has been done in your example.


In the second picture we see fresh walnut vs simply lacquered walnut which is about 30 years old. It is beginniing to look like old ash that is darkened with age.

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

#9

PS- bleached walnut example

Bill Tindall

The gun stock is laying on a speaker cabinet that is simply lacquered walnut, about 30 years old bleached from indirect sun exposure . The speaker cabinet is what I am taking about when I say "bleached walnut".

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

#10

Re: How to make stain-answer to question below

John in NM

"I have never seen walnut go light in a human time frame"

I sure have, delivering furniture from a custom shop in Tucson. Seen two or three pieces that were no older than 1950's (a guess, but clearly not antiques - true antiques are pretty rare out here). Any that sat in sunny rooms were clearly faded, more or less the color of fresh luan or even finished ash.

Unfinished walnut in direct sunlight here at 7000 feet in NM will be noticeably lighter in a week, un-recognizable by color in a month, and grey in 3 months.

I suspect that gunstocks keep their color because they actually spend most of their time in a safe or closet. I'd love to think its due to the oil, but I've never seen any science to back it up. I still use oil on the ones I make though, just in case :D