New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

not a shokunin

Posts

not a shokunin

#1

not a shokunin

Bruce Mack

I deluded myself into thinking that I had acquired hand muscle memory in sharpening and honing plane irons. With good lighting and even finger pressure I turned a slight tactile burr using 3 steel plates with diamond paste and then removed the burr with a final pass on the back of the iron. The edge was not the samurai sword finish I had fantasied but it cut well enough I thought.

I just pulled out my MK II honing guide and did the same thing on the plates (wiping the roller after each coarser grit). The edge is now greasy sharp to the finger tip and the end grain peels off with little effort. The difference is apparent.

It's interesting how my wish for self sufficiency affected my assessment of the results.

Re: not a shokunin

#2

I don't see how you could fail by hand

Bill Tindall

The problem with hand sharpening isn't that the blade doesn't get sharp but rather the bevel rounds over with time. If you can think of some reason why the hand sharpening failed you can likely fix it.

Re: not a shokunin

#3

Re: I don't see how you could fail by hand

Bruce Mack

Thanks Bill. I don't have a grinder to achieve the primary bevel. Consequently there's slight reflective rounding at the very edge which I cannot eliminate with side sharpening. Perhaps I'm elevating the iron on that last plate and augmenting the rounding in an attempt to feel the burr.

Should I get a tactile burr at 1 micron?

Re: not a shokunin

#4

Re: I don't see how you could fail by hand

Bill Tindall

depends on the toughness of the steel. Likely not.

Skewing the blade at some angle to the direction of motion gets more of the bevel registered on the flat surface of the sharpening media. I get better control only pulling across the "stone" but this direction is not theoretically best. Works for me.

A quality 10X lens is invaluable for sharpening. It is good enough to see burrs, defects, chips, etc. and hence an excellent diagnostic aid.

Re: not a shokunin

#5

Re: I don't see how you could fail by hand

TomD

Sharpening a blade on a stone is really difficult. It takes a while to learn. The great thing about jigs is you can get back to zero. Use your hand technique to learn something, when you note you are loosing the edge, go back to the jig. The best results come from using both techniques, because knowing how to freehand is a massive transferable skill, and since we spend a lot of time sharpening in a career, it is a great time to learn something. Part of what we learn is that jigs are indispensable also.

I do the roughing on my blades at a substantial skew, or even entirely along the bevel. There are a million techniques for gaming sharpening. I once got a hour long lecture from a Japanese guy on all kinds of tricks, none of which I have ever seen in the mags, so using the brain is another option. The Japanese guys who do the planing comps use jigs.

Re: not a shokunin

#6

Worm in the water...

James Watriss

I'll bite.

What were some of those tricks, Tom?

Re: not a shokunin

#7

Re: I don't see how you could fail by hand

Bruce Mack

Good suggestions - thank you. I found the Bausch and Lomb 10x magnifier I had used in trying to smooth fountain pen nibs. The chisel edge was rough at the very tip. After a couple of passes over my hardboard/chromium strop it looked and cut much better. I like the idea of using the jig to establish the edge and then hand sharpening to that goal if possible. Smart people in this forum....