New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

Posts

Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#1

Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

Bill Tindall

I have 5 drawers to make, poplar sides and walnut fronts. The plan is to do half of each drawer with the LV chisel and half with the home made CPM 3V chisel and compare the results.

This 3 V chisel is not optimally hardened. At the time we went for maximum toughness which is at Rc 58-60. It has since been found that 3V edges are still tough enough to resist chipping at Rc60-62 and this greater hardness provides better resistance to edge deformation, the other mode of chisel wear. (Personally, I don't believe abrasive wear is a factor for a chisel used for dovetailing) Edge deformation is the only edge "wear" I have ever seen at Rc58, never chipping, nor metal disappearing by abrasion..

Step 1 was to equivalently grind and sharpen each chisel. Chisels were hollow ground at some angle slightly more obtuse than whatever was on the factory grind for the LV chisel, probably around 27 degrees, arbitrarily chosen as that is where the grinder rest happened to be.

It was clear that the LV chisel ground more easily that the more abrasion resistant 3V. The 3% vanadium in 3V makes it abrasion resistant for better or worse.

Next the edges were refined on a "Fine" fixed diamond plate. I could detect no difference in abrasion at this or the next step. Finally the edge was finished on a cast iron plate charged with 1 micron diamond powder.

One of my least favorite tasks is flattening backs. To my astonishment the LV back was already so flat that I could directly polish it on the 1 micron abrasive with no intervening abrasion. For this reason alone I would recommend this chisel!

Two drawers have been done. The chisel I made is light and nicely balanced for dovetail chopping, yet it is also good for the inevitable paring to clean up the dovetails. I am not going to hunt a second chisel for the paring. To my surprise the LV chisel seemed at home in my hand as well. It takes insignificant effort to aim and balance it in the scribe line. This is certainly not the case for many top heavy chisels.

After the equivalent of one drawer each I can see slight wear developing on the edge of each chisel with a 10 X lens. The wear is too little to say if either is more or less. It will take more chopping to see is there is any difference between the chisels.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#2

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am wondering what you mean when you say it is not a "top heavy chisel". Are you holding the chisel like a pencil instead of with the handle? I would have thought the Lee Valley chisel was a heavy chisel. You mentioned earlier that your 1/2 inch LV chisel was 113 grams. My 1/2 inch chisel is 10 inches long and weighs 73 grams.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#3

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Nice write up so far.

With my researcher hat on I would add an O1 chisel to the mix. The difficulty that most will have with the outcome of your results is that they compare a non-production 3V chisel (the qualities of which are only known to you) with a PM-V11 blade (which few have experience of). An O1 blade would not only be a recognisable reference for most, but a baseline point against which the other two may be compared. I would suggest an modern, easily purchased O1 chisel ... perhaps another Veritas? Or a LN.

The bevel angle is relevant. You should sharpen bevels at the angle the manufacturer recommends. Otherwise you may not do justice to the blade. I recall some years ago a controversial chisel review in FWW magazine. All the chisels were ground and honed at 25 degrees. Since they were used for chopping, this placed the A2 bladed chisels at a disadvantage with regard edge holding.

Looking forward to more.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#4

Re: Bevel Angles

david weaver

Bevel angles should probably be done both ways. One at a consistent angle across all chisels, and another with whatever is recommended.

If a chisel holds up great at 32 degrees or whatever is optimum for A2, but it won't hold up well at 25, then I would want to know that as a user. 25 is about the sweet spot for medium hardwoods and softwoods up here, and 30+ is a bit blunt.

The conclusion of the second FWW article a couple of years ago was that LN chisels were great because they were really tough at 30 degrees. That wasn't too instructive for most people who will eventually go lower than 30 degrees - they would instead have a chisel that holds up less well than a lot of more expensive chisels, but sharpens slower and is more picky about what stones are used.

If I could only see one of the two, I would rather see all chisels at 25 degrees, and if the results were bad, maybe a chisel maker could be encouraged to make a chisel that held up well there.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#5

chisel grip and other ergonomics

Bill Tindall

When I am chiseling along a scribe line, such as the case when chopping out dovetail waste, the heel of my hand is on the work surface and the chisel is grasped between thumb and forefinger just above the bevel. This configuration allows for rapid and precise location of the chisel in the scribe line. A top heavy chisel puts strain on the thumb and finger. I rarely have occasion to strike a chisel while grasping the handle. Several professionals working in furniture shops seem to have settled on short chisels for making drawers so I am not too far off base on my preferences.

The typically short Japanese chisels are ideal for this task, if you like the rest of this format. I don't. I am going to own one set of multitasking chisels, so they must pare acceptably as well as chisel to scribe lines. The short Japanese chisels with a ring on top are uncomfortable for paring and they are too thick for ideal dovetail chopping. The chisels I made, the Lee Valley chisel, and butt chisels suite me for multi-taskers.

What appears to be the excessive thickness of the LV chisel remains a puzzle. It is quite likely that I will grind the tip more thin at some time. If it then breaks off I will have discovered why it was made so thick. However, this chisel scored highest in Lee Valley's testing for toughness, so I would not expect failure from a thinner chisel. The ones I made are only 0.140" thick and they are ideal.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#6

Why this will not be

Bill Tindall

First, I do not own a O-1 chisel. Second, I found a huge difference between Sorby, Blue handles, and Two Cherries (best by far) when I tested chisels some years ago. I expect one could get any result one wanted by selecting the best or worst carbon steel chisel for comparison. Third, at the time we chose 3V for making chisels it was the best steel for chisel making, combining the attributes of high toughness at high hardness. If the LV chisel comes close to the performance of the home made 3V chisel I will be convinced that LV tested chisel performance suitably and chose a superior metal for fabrication. This comparison is the only objective of this evaluation. I will leave it to someone else to compare LV carbon steel chisels to their PMV11 chisels. I have drawers to make.

As far as bevel angle, any chisel that needed to be ground at 30 degrees would be unsuitable for my needs. Anyone making an A2 chisel made a poor choice in steel in my opinion, probably because they didn't understand what steel attributes were important for chisels. I want easy penetration of the tip and I am not going to employ a protractor to sharpen when I need to. The chisel needs to perform within a range of bevel angles around 25 degrees.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#7

more on bevel angles and testing

Bill Tindall

If chisel A is poorer at 25 degrees than chisel B, chisel A has inferior steel and/or heat treating. Period. Changing A to 30 degrees for a retest is like running a race and putting the slower runners ahead of the start line.

I can not think of any reason one would not want a bevel angle as acute as possible for better penetration, "possible" being loosely defined as the most acute angle where the edge still resists chipping and deformation. Any chisel at any angle will eventually fail by chipping or deformation, deformation being preferred. Which is why toughness is essential in a chisel steel.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#8

Putting O-1 in the mix

Steve Elliott

When Lee Valley starts offering their PM-V11 blades for Bailey-style planes I will be doing a comparison test of alloys used for plane blades and will include at least one O-1 blade along with A2, M2 and CPM-3V.

The cutting geometry is different for planing so of course the optimum combination of steel attributes will be different from chiseling, but for those interested in these things there will be more to come.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#9

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

Bruce McCrory

A bit confused here ... Is the home-built cpm-3v the same steel as the Lee Valley PMV11? I do like the background info Lee put out for it.

Regarding steels and bevel angles, I would think that purpose and design should influence those factors. If everybody chops at 25-degrees, then 30 might be moot--i.e., a steel that needs the greater bluntness to compete for edge durability.

I got the FWW article and bought the cheap chisels, because I don't want to second guess a 300lb hammer blow vs. 500lb. I will cry over a broken $10 chisel, but not as long as for one costing more than the whole kit I got.

The real question is: should I invest in walking the tracks and coking railroad coal, then planning for the oven on my wife's next 'girls' night out? Hiring out tempering is beyond my budget.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#10

Clarifying the confusion

Bill Tindall

To dispel one notion, the last stuff we had heat treated cost $50 for 25 pounds. Find a knife maker and they might do it for a few dollars per tool. Bos used to do single items for just a few dollars each. Don't know if they still do.

CPM 3V is a particle steel developed for dies but widely used for high performance custom made knives. We don't know what PMV11 is as this is just a name Lee Valley used for this steel. It is probably a high chromium particle tool steel.

There are three main steel attributes relevant to wood working- abrasion resistance, toughness, hardness. Chisels don't get pushed through hundreds of feet of wood before sharpening so abrasion resistance is unimportant (it will affect sharpening ease unless diamond is used). Rather the chisel edge dulls by deforming, which hardness resists, or micro fractures, which toughness resists. Unfortunately as one heat treats steel ever harder it gets less tough. So a heat treating a chisel is some compromise between hardness and toughness. The best steel will be one that stays tough at high hardness and from what is reported the PMV11 excels in this regard.

The best steel in an inexpensive chisel that we evaluated is the Hirsch/Two Cherries.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#11

Re: Clarifying the confusion

Bruce McCrory

Thanks, Bill. I probably should have looked for your first review post; I remember perusing it. I do hope replying to my crazy questions does not interfere with the fun of experimentation.

I was unaware of these side costs (tempering) being so reasonable. And, I already killed the previous oven drying bent wood. Non-edibles in the kitchen oven--and stove--are strictly monitored.

I do enjoy, and learn, from your contributions.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#12

simialrly banned from kitchen

Bill Tindall

I was drying a poplar test piece to check moisture and set the microwave on fire. A mineral pocket inside the piece concentrated the energy, it caught fire and filled the kitchen with smoke. I'm now banned from the kitchen.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#13

Reasonable depends on how much you're doing

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I checked into a commercial heat treater in Mpls to HT a Bowie knife I ground from 5160. They wouldn't do anything other than stainless, but if it were of the right steel it would have cost me $30 for a single blade. Batches were cheaper.

I eventually found a journeyman ABS bladesmith who differentially HT and tempered my blade (alas, no discernible hamon), and it cost me $45.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#15

Re: more on bevel angles and testing

CStanford

Agree wholeheartedy. Very wholeheartedly.

Folks buying bench chisels and being told they need or *must* be ground/honed at 30* or higher are simply buying a bill of goods.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2

#16

Thrift store/ garage sales are your friends

Bob Hackett

Got a really nice toaster oven to use in the shop for metalworking for $5 at our local thrift store. For WWing experiments I usually tote it outside onto the patio or driveway in case there are smoke issues.