Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 2
Bill Tindall
I have 5 drawers to make, poplar sides and walnut fronts. The plan is to do half of each drawer with the LV chisel and half with the home made CPM 3V chisel and compare the results.
This 3 V chisel is not optimally hardened. At the time we went for maximum toughness which is at Rc 58-60. It has since been found that 3V edges are still tough enough to resist chipping at Rc60-62 and this greater hardness provides better resistance to edge deformation, the other mode of chisel wear. (Personally, I don't believe abrasive wear is a factor for a chisel used for dovetailing) Edge deformation is the only edge "wear" I have ever seen at Rc58, never chipping, nor metal disappearing by abrasion..
Step 1 was to equivalently grind and sharpen each chisel. Chisels were hollow ground at some angle slightly more obtuse than whatever was on the factory grind for the LV chisel, probably around 27 degrees, arbitrarily chosen as that is where the grinder rest happened to be.
It was clear that the LV chisel ground more easily that the more abrasion resistant 3V. The 3% vanadium in 3V makes it abrasion resistant for better or worse.
Next the edges were refined on a "Fine" fixed diamond plate. I could detect no difference in abrasion at this or the next step. Finally the edge was finished on a cast iron plate charged with 1 micron diamond powder.
One of my least favorite tasks is flattening backs. To my astonishment the LV back was already so flat that I could directly polish it on the 1 micron abrasive with no intervening abrasion. For this reason alone I would recommend this chisel!
Two drawers have been done. The chisel I made is light and nicely balanced for dovetail chopping, yet it is also good for the inevitable paring to clean up the dovetails. I am not going to hunt a second chisel for the paring. To my surprise the LV chisel seemed at home in my hand as well. It takes insignificant effort to aim and balance it in the scribe line. This is certainly not the case for many top heavy chisels.
After the equivalent of one drawer each I can see slight wear developing on the edge of each chisel with a 10 X lens. The wear is too little to say if either is more or less. It will take more chopping to see is there is any difference between the chisels.



