New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

Posts

This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#1

This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Today, I put up the last piece of siding on our current remodel. This remodel has, as with most of our work on the house, involved the noise of many electrons working their little hearts out to cut/shape/etc. the wood and related parts. But, on our 115-120 year old house, there's always room for handwork. We wound up replacing all of the exterior wall framing except four corner posts (two exterior corners and two posts next to the adjacent rooms). And the city made us install shear plywood on the pony wall*. The new walls are straight and plumb; the old walls weren't.

The (existing) frieze board** on one wall wound up with a gap to the framing that ranged from 3/4" to 1/4" over five and a half feet. Plus, of course, it isn't level, while the new siding is installed level. Since the 5/8" thick siding has to run up behind the frieze board for proper water shedding, this made for a challenge, and an opportunity for some hand tool work.

Here's the problem (it's worse than it appears in this picture):


So it could run up behind the frieze board, the last piece of siding got a rabbet that ranged from nothing to 3/8" in depth, and 1-1/8" to 3/4" in width. I'm terrible at in-process shots, but my approach, in essence, was to clamp a batten - actually, an aluminum guide normally used to guide a circular saw or 'lectric router - for the width of the rabbet; make some marks on the board to designate starting point and terminal depth (I added a midpoint depth, to make me feel better); and go to town with the Stanley 78 for the main work and Lee Valley shoulder plane to clean it up.


You can see how dramatically the rabbet varies in width and depth:



After priming and carefully tapping it in place (I had no desire to break that 1/4" thick wood at the deep point of the rabbet), I have a resolution for that wall that meets the 30-30 test***.


I was wondering, while I was making it, how I'd have done this with power tools, and finally decided I'd have had to make a jig to hold the board on edge, angled in two dimensions, to run over the table saw; and another with the board flat, and angled in two dimensions. My head spins.

------------

*For those not familiar with framing terminology, this is the wall between the foundation and the floor level of the first (ground, for our English and English-colony members) floor.

**We could have pulled the frieze board and soffit and reworked them; but that would have led to reworking the rafter tails, which would have led who knows where...you have to pick a point at which to stop, or you might as well just tear the house down and start over.

***How does it look from 30 feet away if you drive past at 30 mph?

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#2

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

TomD

There are a lot of ways that could be done with power tools. but probably the most realistic would be a 4" grinder. One can gutter just about anything with that. Another would be an electric plane. Hand held circular saw. Fly cutter on a router. But I would certainly have done it with the kind of tools you chose since they are pretty fast, and the dust factor would have been a lot better.

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#3

They just don't "build them like that" anymore!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Aren't you glad?

Nice job of fixing, Bill! Adapt and overcome. Is the house pretty much buttoned up for the rainy season? And where are you able to get solid wood siding that wide?

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#4

Ellis Walentine

A couple thoughts on this

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for a nicely illustrated and informative post, Bill. Now, here's my question: Which was crooked, the frieze board or the wall framing? If the frieze was/is straight, it seems to me that you would want the rabbet straight and then shim the studs out as needed, so the siding ends up straight and parallel to the frieze. That way, you could have made a uniform rabbet to the thinnest dimension of the gap. Of course, you wouldn't have had the satisfaction of rising to the challenge.

Renovation projects are a topic for many conversations, I suppose, but to me the woodworking part boils down to straight, plumb and square, no matter how crooked, tilted or skewed the existing conditions are.

The job looks great, by the way.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#5

If you`re anything like me...

Bob Hackett

The slower you go the better you get.

For me taking the time to weigh all possibilities usually leads to being more inventive not to mention safe. In my younger days I would quickly decide what power tools to drag out and set up on the job site, what jigs to make and then end up abusing various pieces from the scrap pile as I ran thru the numerous trial runs that dialed in the "one shot" process.

Nowadays I tend to look towards the hand tools I carry in a single tote and even if half way thru my " WWing meditation" my mind comes up with a better solution I usually have enough material left to make the needed corrections to attain the new solution.

Funny after all these years I find that the "slow approach" is not only most fulfilling but usually the least time consuming course between the problem and the final solution, especially if you factor in cleaning up, reeling and folding up, and then dragging all those tailed beasts back inside and putting them away then making another trip outside and disposing of all the tempopary jigs and test pieces in the scrap pile mountain. :D

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#6

Re: A couple thoughts on this

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks.

The new wall is straight and as plumb as we could make it while leaving the corner post in place. The frieze board was fitted to the old wall, which must have twisted 1/2" or more over five feet to achieve that particular state (I have commented before that the homeowner who did this work after World War II possessed more enthusiasm and determination than competence). On that stretch of wall, we accommodated the added 1/2" of wall thickness (for the plywood added to the pony wall) by continuing the thickness all the way up the wall, with plywood added to the studs. Thus the closeness of the frieze board to the framing at the corner.

It's possible that, had the city inspector seen this project at the demolished stage and told us he wanted to shear added to the pony wall, we could have come up with a better solution. But, by the time he told us, we had the walls framed.

This room was converted from the back porch, so the framing is...interesting. Above the top plates in the room is 3/4" beadboard, the original porch ceiling. Above that is the original top plate and a vertical 2x6 that, together, form the header between porch posts. The rafters then rest on this. The frieze board locates from this framing, which we did not touch, since it would have required adjusting the roof framing that we redid completely a couple of years ago (that a spinoff of the bathroom remodel, also built on part of the old back porch).

And, yes, in general, I agree: new work on a remodel always needs to be straight, plumb, level, and square. It's the transition points between the new work and the old that make for the interesting learning opportunities - as in this case.

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#7

Keep this up Bill...

Bob Hackett

and pretty soon you`ll be able to work on boats.

If you find plumb, level or square on an old boat then it`s most likely either an accident or an illusion. :D

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#8

Re: They just don't "build them like that" anymore

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"...where are you able to get solid wood siding that wide?"

15 years ago, we could get actual solid wood siding in that width (about 9-1/2") from one lumberyard at the north end of the county (half an hour away). No more. What we can get now is finger-jointed red cedar (well, and pine, but by "pine," they mean radiata pine, which dissolves into mush when the water and fungi have their way). I hate, just hate, to confess this, but it's actually easier to work with than the solid wood was. The reveal - 3/8" thick - on the siding is very delicate until it's put in place, and it was always terrifying driving home in my bumpy old truck with several hundred dollars worth of siding in the back, wondering whether the siding would be intact on arrival. The cedar does not propagate splits with the vigor that the solid redwood did.

I get it at the contractor's yard over in Santa Rosa, 15 minutes away, so there's fewer miles of bad road to test the wood.

Even though the wood's less prone to splitting, we drill the nail holes at the ends, and I've had to remove a couple of (thank goodness, short) boards that split in installation, even with the predrilled holes.

It also comes primed, meaning I just have to prime the end cuts and any factory priming holidays (for some reason, the factory painting step always leaves the priming incomplete inside the bottom shiplap).

This siding pattern is very common on the Victorian and Edwardian houses in this area, so the yards have enough customers to justify carrying it. There are, in fact, two versions of this pattern. Our house is sided in "V-channel rustic," on which the reveal is a constant thickness before returning to the full thickness with a 45 degree bevel. The other pattern is "cove channel rustic," on which the reveal starts at 3/8" at the top, but soon begins to curve out to the surface. The two patterns are very similar at a quick glance; in fact, this room we're working on now had a mix of the two, something I didn't realize for many years after we moved in. V-channel, when it breaks, invariably breaks right at the bevel, so the cove channel is significantly stronger; I kind of wish the original carpenter building the house had thought of that.

But that's rather more answer than question. I'll stop now.

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#9

Re: Keep this up Bill...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The same is true of old houses, although with old houses, at least you don't have to worry about them sinking.

But you're right about boats, from what I understand. What's the old saying? "A cabinetmaker works to the nearest 1/64"; a carpenter to the nearest 1/16"; a boatbuilder to the nearest boat."

Some of this comes from the original use of a space; since these rooms we've been working on were converted from porch, the floors all slant outward, since a proper porch floor is pitched to shed water outside. But I've noticed, in walking around this room, that the floor irregularities are more complex than that, no doubt because of settling.

Re: This week's accomplishment (long, pics)

#10

Correction

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

As I think about it, we did discuss relocating that frieze board; but it would have left a 1/2" gap at the corner between that one and the board around the corner. We'd have had to fill it, or replace the frieze boards all along the adjacent, long, wall. Since this is old stock, 7/8" thick, it would have been a big project.