New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

material for kanna pin

Posts

material for kanna pin

#1

material for kanna pin

eliot d

I'm ready to put the pin in my Japanese plane. What is the best material for it?

Re: material for kanna pin

#2

Re: material for kanna pin

david weaver

Anything is fine. You could get a mild steel rod at home depot and shellac it to prevent rust.

The pins used in kanna are sold by some japanese places. I think hida might have them. I have never put one in a dai of any type, though. Could be an adventure getting one in straight enough to be useful with the second iron for anything other than holding it in place.

I could be overestimating how difficult it is to get a decent job done with it, though.

Re: material for kanna pin

#3

Re: material for kanna pin

eliot d

Thanks. But don't you want the advantage of the second iron("chip breaker")?

Re: material for kanna pin

#4

Re: material for kanna pin

TomD

I have some of the pins that are sold by stores. I can measure one for you tonight. I think they are 4mm and plated. They are a little difference maybe than the ones that actually come in planes.

On the breaker thing, it is all very mysterious:

1) recent stuff on planes, but this applies mostly to one shaving bracket that may not be that important to Japanese plane use;

2) for years we have been told the Japanese planes have better quality breakers, so we should use them, right? But if it is true they only added them as an afterthought under the influence of Western planes, that may explain why they are made the way they are and the reasons may be less complimentary to the overall design;

3) So maybe if they are neither useful or traditional, we should not include them.

Personally I add them, but I don't use them. The breakers come with the planes, installing them does not adversely affect the planes.

Re: material for kanna pin

#5

Re: material for kanna pin

eliot d

"Personally I add them but I don't use them."

I don't follow.( Sorry.) If it's in there, aren't you using it?

Re: material for kanna pin

#7

Re: material for kanna pin

david weaver

If you can get the pin in good and straight and get a good fit and good predictable adjustment with the second iron, i would put it in.

The only downside to having the pin is if you are working at speed and you don't have the cap iron in the plane, the shavings get tied up around that pin.

As long as you can locate the cap iron and jam it into the plane, that's not an issue, though.

A 8/10 bu plane (~40 degrees) is a lot more forgiving on western wood with the cap iron set close.

Re: material for kanna pin

#8

Re: material for kanna pin

TomD

I do the instillation, probably try it out, then if I don't want it, I pull the pin, and I use it without the breaker. I can always put it in if I need it. If I don't do that, the likelyhood of my ever going back to try the SB is pretty near zero for me.

I did a test that I reported here, to general non-interest, about how long it took me to go from blade in, to out for sharpening to back in and cutting again. It was something like 15 seconds. And about twice that to hit a particular shaving thickness. Takes quite a bit longer with a sub blade. Of course this does not include the actual sharpening.

Re: material for kanna pin

#9

Re: material for kanna pin

TomD

I checked the pin, 200 thou. It also turns out I do leave the pins installed. I guess they aren't doing me much harm since I couldn't even remember.