New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Shell Cordovan - Finally Understand

Posts

Shell Cordovan - Finally Understand

#1

Shell Cordovan - Finally Understand

david weaver

I used to be confused by the leather talk on here, mostly because I am not that old (35), and the leather industry has pretty much sucked in the US compared to what it must've been 100 years ago.

When i was buying shoes about 6 months ago, I was trying to figure out how to buy shoes from someone who intended to make good shoes that can be fixed, and who didn't intend to make them in china.

While looking, I noticed that shell cordovan versions of some of the shoes were available for HUGE amounts of money (like $600+ per pair). They were, of course, off my list, that wouldn't go with my flea market shirts very well.

But there was a discussion here not that long ago about someone discontinuing the leather we love so much for strops, the bullet points of my (i'm sure inaccurate) recollection were:

* they're going to stop making the horse leather we like (some guy either quit or become deceased)

* the leather we like is cordovan (pretty sure that's not the case)

* the leather we like is horse butt (for some of us that's the case)

I was completely confused by that discussion, because cordovan was a slight that one high school teacher used toward another one ("you color your hair with cordovan shoe polish"). Since so few people actually appreciate the efforts of a fine leathermaker these days, I didn't have any clue, thought that cordovan was the color of leather and not the leather itself, nor the process to tan it (which is intensive).

But it is abundantly clear to me now.

* we like horse butt strips. They're from further forward on the horse than cordovan shells

* cordovan shells is generally the best leather you can find, lack of availability has nothing to do with woodworkers

And after just talking to horween, there is no lack of availability of shell cordovan, even to someone who just wants to buy one shell. The price is very high, though, it's not for woodworking.

So the conclusion of this general rambling is that it's nice to finally have a clue what we were talking about, and between the various internet sellers and importers of horse stuff, there is no shortage of horse butt or shell cordovan.

Shell cordovan, is, however about $90 a square foot. Reserved only for leather strops, shoes, wallets, belts and watch bands, and even at that, only the very best of those that are intended to be used for a very long time.

Horse butt is cheap, available over the internet from just about everywhere except US origin.

No need for cowhide, but it is even cheaper for someone who is just going to load a strop with abrasive, anyway.

Re: Shell Cordovan - Finally Understand

#2

I seem to recall...

John in NM

That Cordovan is also horse, just a different part. An internet store called Brettuns Village Leather used to sell horse butt that they called "north of Cordova", as some kind of pun that makes sense to those who know what part is what.

Re: Shell Cordovan - Finally Understand

#3

Re: I seem to recall...

david weaver

The genuine shell cordovan is from the rump of the horses on the sides, in oval cuts, the layer below the hide. The part in front of those ovals is the horse butt strips, which I guess are hide.

I don't know what gets done with the leather on the front of the horse, but those two, the shell and the strips, are a godsend for anyone who puts an edge to their skin.