New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

Posts

Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#1

Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

david weaver

I know we've had various go-arounds about this, and I've had private conversations with several people about whether or not stropping does anything and whether or not leather has any abrasive value.

On new horsebutt with razors, it's clear that the leather is abrasive - too much, it actually is a lateral move with a razor treated with chromium oxide, or maybe even backwards.

But once the horsebutt is broken in and smooth, it just lightly wears the edge of the razor and makes a very tiny (but visible by light reflection) worn edge that is sharper than the edge was. And sharper from either side of the bevel, and even. A freshly sharpened unstropped tool will seem to shave hair from one side of the bevel much better than it does from the other, but proper stropping eliminates that.

I have not seen good pictures of this before, and I've seen pictures from Beach's page that refer to loaded strops degrading edges, and from a knife paper that described strops as doing little in terms of abrasives.

They are said to be at 2000x, far above the 250 or 400x level that I've seen elsewhere.

http://blog.modernmechanix.com/mags/PopularScience/10-1931/razor_blades/razor_blades_1.jpg

this doesn't do a lot for us as woodworkers, I guess, but it is a continuation of prior discussions we've had about stropping. I know I've seen warren say he's not sure exactly what's going on at the edge, but he knows it's improved.

I hope also that some of the things that come up about stropping with razors will let folks who are using loaded strops after finish stones know that the loaded strops, especially if used heavily, are likely not doing anything productive for them.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#2

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks David.

Incidentally, the strop I mentioned the other day is one I have had for some years. It is nicely broken in.

I am curious to know what you and others recommend to maintain a plain strop. Do you leave it dry, or add an oil to keep the leather conditioned?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#3

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

david weaver

I can only speak to a hanging strop. I think I have maybe added 10 drops of neatsfoot oil to my razor strop, and it probably would work about the same if I'd have added none. I've used it exclusively for what has to be almost a year, so it has had a razor cross the surface probably about 25000 times.

my paddle strops (which are in the shop), I have never treated at all, except one I oiled heavily out of curiosty. I usually get short with them when I accidentally get them dirty, once that's the case they're fine after a soft arkansas or something but not good for paring if you want the paring cut to be finished (like on a moulding plane). I would think they don't need treatment at all, but neatsfoot oil would be my favorite thing to put on them if I was going to rub something into them *sparingly*. If doing that, rub the oil (a couple of drops) on your hand first and then rub your hand on the strop. a drop that hits the strop will just soak in instantly and not be spread.

They (bare leather) are beneficial over nothing even if they are oiled heavily, but I think they are much more beneficial if they are very lightly oiled or not oiled at all, especially once broken in.

Just my opinion. Most of this is colored by my want to get the best edge on a razor, and i only use a strop in the shop regularly if I finish with oilstones with most things, and paring chisels maybe regardless of stone. The effort is blasted off of a plane iron in a hurry compared to a good shapton finish stone edge.

A lot of old barbering texts suggest tallow based shaving soap to be rubbed in and then wiped off. I haven't had such great experience with that on cowhide, but I'm sure it depends on the soap. In the shop, it would seem to do nothing other than make dirt stick to the strop.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#4

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

CStanford

A strop smoothes jagged edges, removes outright 'rag' and, importantly from a shaving perspective, is helps homogenize the edge across the length. What you don't want with a razor is a section very much 'better' than another. You need the edge to be equally 'dulled' by the strop or the razor will seem to catch and stutter across your face. After use, a strop when it is correctly wielded will straighten a razor's edge to some degree - takes some of the break off the cresting wave of a turning edge.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#5

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

david weaver

There's no sharpness test that I'm aware of where a freshly honed razor will be more keen before it's stropped than after. The edge definitely does need to be uniform, or it won't be uniform after. Catching hair is not a matter of keenness, it's a matter of parts that aren't sharp. A sharp edge, regardless of the orientation of the parts will sever hair without catching at all.

Be it hanging hair, or an arm shave, the result is the same.

If before stropping, the edge was sharper in places than after stropping, the hanging hair test would show it if a hair landed on a sharp spot. But that doesn't happen unless the strop is of exceptionally poor quality.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#6

Re: addendum

david weaver

some of the things I have seen people do to strop tools could definitely dull them - pulling a tool through leather with extreme pressure at a scraping angle rather than one close to the bevel.

I am curious to find out what the conclusion is about something being dull if it cuts through something more easily after it's been "uniformly dulled".

If sharp means something cuts less easily, I don't get it. Just the same as I don't get people claiming a knife edge with tooth is more sharp. Butchers put that one to rest a long time ago in their preference for a good steeled edge over a medium stone.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#7

Re: addendum

cstanford

Remove outright rag, burnish and somewhat equalize hill and dale, make slightly duller but smoother, straighten cresting waves of steel (only if used correctly). This is what a strop does well.

Give in to alchemy. Give in to art. Give in to mystery.

Give in. Have fun. Enjoy.

Be well.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#8

Re: addendum

Marhk

Now, I know shiny doesn't equal sharp but I believe it does equal smooth. Consider the sensation of using an edge tool. If the edge is sharp then a great deal of the resistance to movement is how smooth the bevel and back are. So, easier to use. Feels sharper. Stropping surely does make the bevel smoother. It will polish a tool sharpened on a natural water stone, which normally would be dull appearing. I guess if done at a low angle it can polish all the way to the edge - making it smoother and feel sharper.

Interesting that a felt wheel does the same thing - better. (but with more risk!)

Note that in this line of argument I am assuming that stropping doesn't change the intersecting angles much - hence "sharp" vs. "feels sharp."

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#9

Re: The sharp shiny thing...

david weaver

There is only one part of a chisel or plane iron that will be dull on a chisel that is still very sharp, and that's the soft backing iron, mild steel, or wrought iron.

The hardened steel will be polished to a bright finish by the natural stones that are truly fine, and those that are truly fine will be hard enough that they can hold their grit in place.

In the many natural stones around where the edge isn't brought to a polish, and where slurry is released by the stones, the edge is not that sharp. People will tell themselves it is, but there is no stone sold as a razor finisher in japan that will not leave a bright polish on the hardened steel.

The same is true of oilstones. The particles must stay in place to get that superfine natural finish, and very very few people actually do that with tools, because it takes a lot of time.

There just isn't a natural stone that I'm aware of that really has superfine particles, even the japanese natural hard stones have particles in the 3-5 micron range, as far as I know, a bit finer than a novaculite stone.

The term used in the razor circles (where these things have been examined a lot more closely than with tools) for the dull finish on a steel due to loose particles is "slurry dulling".

Still the question remains, if a stropped edge really does cut everything much more easily than an edge that wasn't stropped, and it's considered "dulled", then what exactly then does sharpness mean? it is not an illusion. Lay a hair on a razor edge under its own weight and see how easily it's severed, before and after stropping. The same will be true on tools *as long* as clean bare leather is used, and no power felt wheels, etc, where the geometry of the edge is being noticeably altered.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#10

Re: The sharp shiny thing...

Marhk

This is the old sharp vs. shiny conundrum. In my experience high end Japanese natural stones will leave a dull finish on O-1 or A-2 steel. Is it sharp - yes! The definition I use for sharp is the final line at the edge - how fine is it? My Ohira suita stone will leave the sharpest edge I can get with my technique. The finish will be dull. It's all about light reflection. But if one then strops this you can make it shiny. My contention has always been that at the edge the finer Japanese natural stone will leave a cleaner edge line but the motion resistance from the dull surface leaves a less slick feel as the tool is used. Note the scanning EM's that people have posted. I think you need both sharp and shiny for a perfect edge. But, I can work OK with just the honed edge (dull). Too bad I'm not familiar with the razor sharpening literature. (I bought into the triple edge thing - haven't gone to 4 yet!) Carvers are fond of a slick-sharp feel. They strop a lot.

The felt wheel thing I mentioned came from a discussion I had several years ago with Marc Adams. He uses a wheel to sharpen & strop all his edge tools. Said that he gets back to work faster. I think I remember that he said that Tage Frid did that same thing. I have tried it a bit. I'm still a little bit afraid of dulling an edge but the concept is probably one I'll move to as my patience for sharpening becomes less and less. ( I tried a Tormek in the past. Just about went to sleep while I was using it - too slow! ) Note the Koch system at Woodcraft. Too expensive - but interesting.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#11

Re: The sharp shiny thing...

david weaver

Yep, saw all of the those power systems, they're all interesting. I still do just generally use a bench grinder, or in some cases, a belt grinder.

Using a felt buff is definitely a fast way to get back to work.

Come on over to the dark side sometime and shave with a straight edge razor. If you want to start, I'd be glad to send you one in shaving shape, sterilized and all. Gratis. Of course, all of the other duds that you'd need to buy (strop, brush, soap) aren't free.

But I am so glad to not be fighting those clogging razor heads.

You're right, you can get a pretty good sharp edge while the hard steel is still a little bit matte. You can also get a mediocre edge with an aggressive uniform stone that's mid range (shapton 5k is an "OK" edge straight off the stone, but not like the 15k edge), and have a very bright polish.

Japanese razor stones (which are a small % from the mines that are extremely uniform, hard and that have the smallest particles in the miners opinions) are rated by their ability to shine the bevel up to a full polish. This is, of course, after they are not letting any abrasive go.

To get an idea of what's sharper in a plane, I don't know if anything works better than the shaving thickness test, though with a bench plane, it's pretty easy to get down to about 3 ten thousandths with any good sharp edge. (of course, it's a waste of time, too).

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#12

Re: The sharp shiny thing...

Marhk

Thanks for the offer but I'll have to pass. I have vivid memories of my Grandfather shaving with a straight razor. He had all the stuff. He was a connoisseur of styptic pencils! As he got older he developed a tremor. Now, that was exciting to watch! I still have one of his razors somewhere. I would however never think of using it - too many important things just under the skin in that area. Slicing and dicing jugulars is not my thing! Even the thought of it is too much.

I still think that a blade with a matt finish from a high end water stone is just as sharp (or more so) as one from a ceramic polishing stone. Its all about the final angle. But the feeling of using it is perhaps slightly different. In terms of a plane: Is "sharp" how easy it is to pull a 1 thou shaving ( and the sound it makes), or is "sharp" defined as the smoothness and character of the board itself? Both? Hard to express. I think that "sharp" is how uniform and thin the line at the very end on the blade is, as seen under EM. The thinness of this line can of course continue to infinity. Under an EM, looking further back at the bevel, the irregularity there is where stropping plays more of a role - smoothing it out. It seems to me that most stropping media can only damage the infinite end line of the blade - strops are too soft and irregular. As infinity is approached with the thinness of this end line the strop can and will change the final angle ( thus "sharpen" the edge - if you're good or lucky ) but can easily blunt the edge. So, as someone else said in a prior discussion stropping has to be very carefully done, if at all. Perhaps we should strop then pass the edge over our finest stone to finish it - in that order.

I like the idea of a standardized test for "sharp." Splitting hairs is not something I've tried. But if it could be standardized …

I usually test by paring end grain pine.

This sharp thing is too much like philosophy, angels on pins, etc.. I'm building another workbench and have to get to it.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#13

Re: The sharp shiny thing...

R Payne

As someone who shaves with a straight razor, I can attest that you won't get as good a shave from just a stone as you will if you strop. I have paste on the back of the strop (I find it is good for maintenance) but the final work is done on a bare strop. That is the best edge possible.

ron

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#14

Re: The sharp shiny thing...

david weaver

Well, the truth is at the edge. There are cases where the polished bevel on a ceramic waterstone belies trouble at the edge. When you get to that level of sharpness, funny things happen.

there is a debate in the razor forums about whether or not a shapton 16k will damage some hard razors after more than 20 laps. I have seen the microscopic pictures, and tiny chips in the edge actually do develop from it.

But in an edge where there is no damage, an edge highly polished by a natural stone will always be sharper than an edge that is matte. The polish on the bevel will telegraph it, but the real key will be the smoothness of the edge, which will be better with the high polish.

By the way, keep that straight razor, you will want to use it sometime, I promise you the movement back to wetshaving is not going away, and it is really hard to cut yourself bad with a straight razor. You'd literally have to trip and fall on it. Even if you nick yourself your natural reaction is to move the razor away very quickly and stop. I have never had a bad cut and in probably the last 250 shaves, none at all. I expect no more also unless someone bumps me while I'm shaving. As a beginner I did get some minor nicks, but they were just that, very minor. I got nicks as bad or worse with a bic disposable when I first started shaving. It's a lot easier than you think.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#15

Re: The sharp shiny thing...

Marhk

Same old problem - what is "Sharp?"

We need an objective means of deciding.

I am not going to succumb to the sharp is shiny theory.

I need some data. My experience, albeit limited to my life-long hobby experience seems to tell me shiny contributes to a cutting experience but is not where "sharp" really is.

Your experience may differ. Shaving depends on feel. Maybe the edge polish significantly contributes there?

Sharp is cutting, smooth is feeling. All too qualitative. We need a method of quantifying.

I wonder if the 4 blade razor is actually any better???

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#16

Re: The sharp shiny thing...

david weaver

Shiny isn't necessarily sharp, that's what I'm getting at, at least in relative terms. There can be a shiny bevel and a damaged edge.

But sharpest is shiny, no way around it. There is no fine razor finisher that doesn't impart a polished edge. Coticules, eschers, japanese razor stones, properly used HTA arkansas. Poorer finishers among those (escher being the exception, they are consistent) will impart a little bit of haze, but the truly fine ones leave a brightly polished edge with no haze and no stray marks.

The definition of sharp would be based on how easily a razor pulls staight down a face full of 2 day hair. It's easy to find out what is sharper, and a slightly hazy finish can be used to shave, but it will never move as easily through the hair.

Don't buy into any semi-religious talk about mysteries of dull edges somehow magically sneaking past a properly sharpened brightly polished edge. They sneak past only shiny bevels with edge damage. It is a known and already proven issue.

It just persists in the woodworking world because of blog entries and lack of experience, as well as the fact that a dull finished hard steel will still be sharp enough to do work. Sharp enough isn't the same as definitively as sharp or sharper.

When you get into the rarified air of superfine japanese woodworking stones (that few here tread in), they are also boasted as polishing the hard metal to a bright finish. The workman's stones, like a mid fineness suita will leave a hazy finish and a nice edge to work with, but it will not be as sharp as a brightly finished maruka stamped nakayama edge.

You have to resist the temptation to buy into things that don't make sense.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#17

Re: The sharp shiny thing...

Marhk

Well David, you had me going there. Well argued, wrong, but well argued!

I had to think about this. I even emailed Alex Gilmore about it. (check out the micrographs of natural vs.ceramic results of sharpening on his site www.japanblade.com)

The light reflection is the key. The natural stone creates an irregular scratch pattern - random axis short scratches of different particle size, because they are loosely bound and break into multiple sizes. (Natural stones are also made of many different kinds of particles - some hard, some soft.) That vs. the ceramic stone regular particle size and type, tightly bound so the scratches are in a linear movement direction. This creates a regular pattern that reflects. The surface from the natural stone is very irregular and reflects poorly.

Now as to sharp: it is all about the edge - how infinite and regular it is. (nothing magic there)

As to smooth: In a razor this smooth appearing shiny bevel may be more comfortable. I personally can't know that. Interesting to me my contention that shiny bevels plane differently may or may not be correct. I agree that stropped edges seem smoother. Is it sharper? Jury is out on that pending a quantitative test for sharpness.

Now, is shiny the same as smooth - that is probably false.

Regards,

Mark

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#18

Stropping

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is a point where theorizing has to take a back seat to empirical observations. And a trivial test for sharpness is not as helpful as the performance of the tool in actual use. Stropping is an art. It is ridiculous to sit in a chair and compare stropping to a felt wheel or some stone without a great body of experience with strops.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#19

Re: Stropping

Marhk

Would you further describe the "art" of stropping?

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#20

Not so much what is "sharp"...

Bob Hackett

but more importantly, what is appropriate.

comparing the level of sharpness needed for a straight razor to the level needed for a wood plane is like looking at the edge of a jackhammer bit, a splitting wedge, or a froe and saying " this will never work properly until it`s a sharp as my razor".

Appropriate sharpness takes into account far more than just focusing on what the edge looks like, especially the edge under a microscope.

Re: Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)

#21

Re: Not so much what is "sharp"...

Marhk

Ok, I agree about the microscope picture not equaling sharpness (it is a feature of it, though). But, without any quantitative way to access what we are talking about is like blind men describing an elephant. Everyone has an opinion. For example the recent cap iron study - this had real data that represented something beyond just one person's idea. This was a worth while study that actually changed how people do things. More difficult to refute hard data! So much of craft work is practice based on 2 sorts of evidence. First: Is everyone doing it - therefore it must be the correct way. Second: Who has the loudest voice, or the most status at the time - he (or she) must be right.

The first part of the scientific method is to ask a question. In this case: "What is sharp?" and "Does stropping make edges sharper or just feel smoother to use?" It seems to me that the only way to get at this sort of thing is to talk about it and ask the questions, maybe find a study that has already been done (as with the cap iron), or design and do a study.

So, sure I'm not planing with a razor blade. I haven't even asked the question "Does a sharper blade plane better or last longer?" I've said that I'm not a professional - but, a hobby is something you can get further into in a way, because you have the time and don't depend on the money.

Who knows, the earth may not be flat after all. Someone has to ask.