Excerpt from an Article on Stropping (1931)
david weaver
I know we've had various go-arounds about this, and I've had private conversations with several people about whether or not stropping does anything and whether or not leather has any abrasive value.
On new horsebutt with razors, it's clear that the leather is abrasive - too much, it actually is a lateral move with a razor treated with chromium oxide, or maybe even backwards.
But once the horsebutt is broken in and smooth, it just lightly wears the edge of the razor and makes a very tiny (but visible by light reflection) worn edge that is sharper than the edge was. And sharper from either side of the bevel, and even. A freshly sharpened unstropped tool will seem to shave hair from one side of the bevel much better than it does from the other, but proper stropping eliminates that.
I have not seen good pictures of this before, and I've seen pictures from Beach's page that refer to loaded strops degrading edges, and from a knife paper that described strops as doing little in terms of abrasives.
They are said to be at 2000x, far above the 250 or 400x level that I've seen elsewhere.
http://blog.modernmechanix.com/mags/PopularScience/10-1931/razor_blades/razor_blades_1.jpg
this doesn't do a lot for us as woodworkers, I guess, but it is a continuation of prior discussions we've had about stropping. I know I've seen warren say he's not sure exactly what's going on at the edge, but he knows it's improved.
I hope also that some of the things that come up about stropping with razors will let folks who are using loaded strops after finish stones know that the loaded strops, especially if used heavily, are likely not doing anything productive for them.



