New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Roubo Bench advice

Posts

Roubo Bench advice

#1

Roubo Bench advice

rononkokomo

If you wanted to build. Big honkin Roubo that you might have to move, would you run lag bolts throughout the tenons instead of draw boring?

Ron

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#2

Re: Roubo Bench advice

Jim Ritter

No, for starters I would not pin anything. Just let gravity do its job. After you move pin it if you need to.

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#3

Re: Roubo Bench advice

ebushee

It's a pain to move a big honkin' anything, including a workbench, and especially if there are going to be stairs involved. If you are thinking about moving in the near future, I would consider a few options. One, I would wait to build the big heavy workbench until settled, whether that would be your current place or a new one, and make do with your current bench until then. If your current bench is inadequate you might build a quick and dirty one that is stiff, but still lightweight, and could be used in the future for an assembly table or work table.

If you just can't wait and still want the big bench, I would definitely consider something that can be knocked down. That could be either bench bolts (Lee Valley or Benchcrafted) or tusk tenons. The side stretchers can be made more permanent, those and the legs can easily be picked up as a unit and carried away. And if your top is heavy enough, just put it on the legs and let gravity hold it for now. It can either sit in leg tenons, or I've heard of folks having the top rest in dowels set into an upper side stretcher.

And I suppose another option would be to just build the bench, drawbore everything, and pay some movers to take care of it. They are readily equipped to handle big, heavy things.

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#4

Re: Roubo Bench advice

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ron

Keep in mind that my top is only 76" long, not "big honkin" long. Anyway, I still had to consider the possibility of the bench moving one day, even though I do not have any such plans.

I reasoned that the difficulty in moving a bench is when you attempt the whole package - base, top and vises. So what I did was ensure that these could be separated.

I drawbored everything on the base because it needed to be as rigid as possible.

The top is attached via blind tenons. Gravity would do the job well-enough as it is 3 1/2" of Oak. For extra rigidity I pinned the top with dowels. These are easy to drill out. Drawbored pins would not be easy to remove.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#5

Re: Roubo Bench advice

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The bench illustrated in Roubo is designed to be taken apart. The top sits on tenons that are not pinned. The stretcher tenons are pinned. However the stretchers are somewhat narrower than the legs so that the pins are accessible from the back and can be knocked back out for disassembly. Don't use glue. I have knocked down my Roubo lathe about 70 times.


Re: Roubo Bench advice

#6

Bed Bolts

Bill Tindall

Beds are made with M&T joints and by nature designed with moving in mind. A bed bolted M&T is as rigid as a glued M&T. Seems that a movable bench would benefit from the same construction.

For example....Instead of the flimsy "loft beds" one can buy for dorm use to lift the sleeping surface high in the room so a desk can fit below, I made one from 16/4 poplar with bed bolted M&T for the rails. It had 5' tall legs, yet it was as rigid as if it was welded metal.

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#7

Wisdom

rononkokomo

You said "be patient" i am thinking that is going to br mt best option. My current bench does a lot of things well.

Ron

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#8

Thanks

rononkokomo

I think i may start on my base parts and just not assemble anything till i know where it will sit.

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#9

Re: Roubo Bench advice *LINK*

Lars Parrington

Ron,

I am ~75% of the way through building a roubo in my basement. I am also planning to move within a year or two. I thought a lot about building the bench to allow for disassembly, but in the end i decided not to. It will either add extra complexity to the design, or compromise the rigidity of the bench. I both glued and drawbored all the joints.

With the bench mostly built, I've found that it's much easier to move around than i was expecting. it slides around if i plane too aggressively. it can be lifted off the ground by one person standing at each end.

My basement has a set of hurricane doors that lead to the driveway. When it comes time to move, I think I will flip the bench upside down and drag it up the stairs on skids using a rope and a come-along (or maybe my truck). From there, two people will be able to put it in the back of the truck without much trouble, by lifting one end at a time.

Maybe it would be possible to drag the bench out of your basement in a similar way? Of course, you'd also have to think about the accessability of your future shop, and how difficult it would be to move the bench into its new home.

You can see my bench here:


http://lllars.com/the_workshop/roubo_workbench/index.php

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#10

Re: Roubo Bench advice

Patrick Gibbons

While my bench is not a Roubo, I have my top floating on the tenoned legs. It was easy to knock apart when I moved. I used Lee Valley bench bolts for the legs and they have stayed tight for over 10 years now. I have been planning to make a new bench for about three years. Originally I wanted to build a Roubo style but now I think I want to make a bench patterned after Paul Sellers' bench which can be seen on his website. He has a 12 part series on building it. I want to use solid pieces so there are no laminations. I laminated my present bench top and vowed never again. The Sellers style bench is easily taken apart for moving. I took classes from Paul when he was in Texas and can vouch for the bench being solid, easy to work on and stable.

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#11

Re: Roubo Bench advice

TomD

I know you mention big honkin, and roubo at the same time. One though though is to tend towards the non big honkin Roubo side of things. Big honkin knockdown instead.

1 - Not really sure there is any great advantage to Roubo, simple with various contraption for holding work maybe, but the actual roubo construction not sure there is any advantage to that. Well to be honest, I think it is a bad idea.

2 - Lag bolts into a tenon are a high load fitting that will wear too quickly. Of course if the lags are under no load, then it won't be a problem, but it wouldn't be necesarry either.

3 - Of the two classic style benches I have made, I never got around to attatching the tops to either. I have this never finish anything completely gene, but beyond that, it is hardly ever noticeable. I'm not recomending it, but I do see the

4 - Both of my benches are knock-down. The first uses a draw bolt system which I don't like at all. It does work, but it is easier not to take the base apart when moving, and that is what I have always done. My second uses big honking draw wedges, that method is even stiffer and really easy to take apart. That is how I would do any other base in the future. My second bench uses scantlings pretty much copied from Klausz, though it is not a Klausz bench or base.

5 - If you want a base that goes together like a hardware drawn base, the best option is a hardware bonded base. It is stronger (not that that really maters, but just so you know); cheaper to do, or no more expensive; easier to install, less alignment issues; looks better, no slots or holes; works better, no fiddling to lign stuff up. I used this approach on my current breadboards, but I did not use it on the base as noted, though I have, and it is what I would use if I were making a hardware based base. You just pot, say, a 1/2" stud in a 3/4" hole. What you end up with is a huge stick of lumber with a seemingly organic threaded rod sticking out of it. This is how they do the load take offs on the butts of windmill blades. Those things are about the most dramatic cantilevered structures one can imagine. And many of the original high tech blades were made of wood back in the '80s.

6 - I made my big honkin bench top out of two pieces. I had a whole bunch of reasons for doing this that were just personal whimsy, but it has worked out great. I have two big beams, joined at the ends by hardware bonded breadboards. I do have the cranes and stuff required to move all this, but it comes apart into 4 pieces, so I can cart it around without the lifting gear, and I like it. It looks nice, and some clients have said they wanted their work to look like it, or like the odd stain I accidentally applied, :) Meaning people who want traditional woodwork think they are looking at it, while I think it is pretty modern for a wooden bench. My top has a gap about 3/4", that I quite like, but stuff does drop down occasionally. It holds chisels and other stuff nicely, but it would be more practical if the crack were only 1/8".

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#12

Won't work for me

rononkokomo

Anything coming out of my basement has to be taken up stairs then moved through a snug turn. Tusk tenons for the stretchers might work but could interfere with leg vises?

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#13

Re: Won't work for me

TomD

That hasn't been a problem on my bench as regards the other stuff they tend to interfere with. Someone has a plan where the tusks are on all but one of the legs in order not to foul the tail vise. That is a little too pragmatic for me.

Benches are more complex than they look, so if one diverges from careful plans in any way, my experience suggests it is well to make the top first and then the base. Certainly when I made my first base, I did not have much stuff to support the top with, so making the base first seemed a good idea. Then one gets into the top, and maybe gets hardware that is not identical to that specified, or figures one could get six inches more out of the top stock so why bother cutting it. Next thing one knows one makes a top that misses the mark with the base. So if possible build the base second. Or just be a lot smarter than me. Which is to say, you could probably work it out somehow. The tusks with wedges really are incredibly stiff. The bolt systems all just have to crush a little side grain, and have short more leverage to do it. Also, while I was a little apprehensive about making them they turn out to be about the same trouble as the captured nuts.

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#14

Re: Roubo Bench advice *LINK*

Jonas B

I am dealing with this same issue right now. I am planning on building a bench in my basement, but I may need to move this bench in the future. To be honest, for ease and lowered cost, I am thinking that I am going to build a Nicholson Bench, like the one in Chris Schwarz's 2nd workbench book.

But, I saw this post in the lostartpress blog about Will Myers' new Moravian workbench and thought it had some really cool ideas. I hope it's okay to link to the wkfinetools.com post that Will Myers did about his build:

This bench uses wedges in the mortise and tenons in a really interesting way. It seems like it would be a neat way to do the joinery in the legs and stretchers without using bolts. I'm not sure how well bolts work in a bench, they may work fantastically, but they I have had issues of bolts constantly loosening over time in other benches/furniture that had bolts.

Just a thought.

Thank you,

Jonas Baker


http://www.wkfinetools.com/tMaking/art/moravianBench/moravianBench-01.asp

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#15

Bolted M&T joints

Bill Tindall

I don't know what a bench bolt is but anyone that builds beds where the M&T joints are pulled together with bed bolts can attest that this joint is easily taken apart (my daughters loft bed has been re-purposed numerous times and moved more than a dozen times) and results in a joint as rigid as if it was glued. I have never had a bed bolt loosen and that is with 40+ years of using them. There are now 4 bed bolted beds in my house, all rigid, with no need to adjust after 20 years. Should they ever need tightening it would be a 10 second job to do so.

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#16

Re: Roubo Bench advice

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I once had a similar Pennsylvania Dutch bench that I could knock down and move. Mine was white oak and the legs straight up and down. One thing that would be helpful for Ron is that the frame at each end is roughly 24X 34 and doesn't need to come apart for moving. The end frames were pinned mortise and tenon. Just the long side stretchers were wedged. If you use this system, leave plenty of length on the tenons so they don't split out at the end when the wedge is seated. We also have an 18th century "barn frame" loom that is secured with wedges. A loom used by a production weaver gets as much stress on the frame as a work bench.

Jonas, the lower stretcher on the bench you linked to was dovetailed in rather than tenoned. I wonder if it wasn't added later. A dovetail socket like that could be cut in without taking the bench apart, but I think it would be better to have mortise and tenon top and bottom like the one I had.

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#17

Interesting

rononkokomo

BUT... I gotta have a Roubo.. With two leg vises.. One of which will serve as a tail vise. I have found Doug Fir 6 x 6 s for the legs. Still noodling about the top.

Re: Roubo Bench advice

#18

Re: Roubo Bench advice

Will M

I built a Roubo before I built the Moravian bench. I simply love the Roubo, I can think of only one major flaw...mobility. Even if you have one that is bolted together it would be pain to assemble/dissasemble/move. The Moravian bench has honestly suprised me, it is solid and stable as the Roubo but you can take it apart in about 60 seconds and load it up....by yourself. So far I have not found anything I would change about it.