Drawer fitting
Bill Tindall
In a post below Ellis asked about drawer fitting, specifically how much smaller to make it. A better place to ask than I would be a shop that has been making chest of drawers for a few generations and shipping them about the land. When I am in an antique store I take what ever opportunity offered to check drawer fits to see what looks good and what has worked.
Drawer front length: The drawer front size determines the size of the reveal around the closed drawer and it determines the initial width of the drawer assembly, which in turn determines how well the drawer works. A well fit drawer can be closed by pushing with one finger on any corner of the drawer front. Too much slop and the drawer will rack and fail this test. Hence, there is an engineering as well as an aesthetic component to sizing the drawer front.
Drawer fronts do not change length much but the case can move. In fact I had that happen on a recent chest and what was a well fit drawer began to bind when the case side cupped in a trifle. However the drawer sides could be planed a bit to correct this problem without altering the size of the drawer front. So the most important fit criteria is how well the reveal looks. After examining lots of antiques I like the looks of about 3/64" total.
I only make drawers to fit something 2-3 times a year, so I can't "stay in practice". I need to rely on an approach that is reliable at the expense of possibly slow. At this stage of chest construction my objective is to get the drawer fronts to just easily fit the the opening. I often have to adjust the angle on the drawer ends from 90 degrees (or what ever the saw cut it) to match some slight variation in the squareness of the opening, or saw cut. And at this stage about 1/32 gap at the top is targeted.
After the drawer is assembled I will plane the sides as needed to get a good fit and reveal. If possible I will store the drawer in some humid location before final fitting. Because the drawer front was sized and shaped to fit the opening before assembly it is typical that only a small and uniform amount of material will need to be removed from the sides.
Drawer height: The drawer may change substantially in height with changes in humidity. Grain orientation and species as well as humidity range and overall height of the drawer affect the amount the height will change. I use quartered poplar drawer sides to minimize height variation. On an average drawer built in average humidity I shoot for about 3/64 top clearance. That said I have had to refit tall drawer heights in the summer when the drawers were fit in the drier winter. So it could be said that I haven't figured out drawer height optimums yet.




