New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Follow up question massive bench tops

Posts

Follow up question massive bench tops

#1

Follow up question massive bench tops

rononkokomo

I have noticed that the Schwarz , and others, have built bench tops out of 6 x 6 fir or pine. What does one need to do to get holdfasts to work in such a bench top?

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#2

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

david weaver

Nothing. Just make it thick enough that they have a broad surface to grip inside the dog hole. 6 inches might be a bit too thick, I'd bore the bottom side of the bench so the effective length of the dog hole was no more than 4 inches.

I've been using a sawbench made out of 2x12s for about 2 years now maybe, it's got dog holes in it, and it's probably white pine (definitely not DF). I put it together as a temporary sawbench knowing that it would get mangled, but I was looking for something I could make in an hour.

I still haven't replaced it, the holes do get dinged up a little bit from the holdfasts since the board is only 1 1/2 inches thick, but they work fine still.

I'd be more worried about the hardness of the bench surface than I would the functionality of the dog holes.

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#3

Why?

Bob Hackett

The real questions for me are; how rigid and flat does your work surface need to be, how big, what type of work do you need to hold on it and in what manner or presentation?

Once I answer those questions then I can better evaluate my real world needs now and in the foreseeable future. Defining those needs allows me to get a better handle on what materials are most appropriate and in what dimensions.

I tend to not pay too much attention to what the big names are doing. I find I am always a whole happier if I keep my eye on what I personally need and intend to do. I build to meet my own needs and let others climb into whatever box they see fit at the time.

I`d need a really good reason to use 6" thick material on a bench top. Keep in mind I can get rough sawn local hardwoods like oak and maple for a dollar a board foot in that thickness up here.

PS- if I was planning extensive use of hold downs a 6" thick bench top would not be high on my list. If I needed that much strength and rigidity in conjunction with hold downs I`d be using a metalworker`s platten with some 1/4" plywood thrown between the metal and the wood it to protect the work. Seems like someone would have to take the exit onto Overkill Blvd if they began shopping around for a bench top that thick.

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#4

Re: Why?

david weaver

Presumably they're using 6" thick stuff because it's an easy lumber source?

I don't even know what the big names are, but the tip to not confuse bloggers with experts is still relevant, I think. Nobody checks your credentials to start a blog.

There's lot of folks around here who have spent their woodworking careers working with hand tools. Warren comes to mind, so does George Wilson (though George is at SMC).

I know who I'd ask.

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#5

Re: Why?

TomD

"Presumably they're using 6" thick stuff because it's an easy lumber source?"

I think that in Chris' case he had a very long wait to find the wood he wanted for his real Roubo bench. Not sure that was 6 inches, but maybe he is onto something else.

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#6

Re: Why?

TomD

"I tend to not pay too much attention to what the big names are doing. I find I am always a whole happier if I keep my eye on what I personally need and intend to do."

Chris in particular has made a career making benches I would not want to own. Most of the experts are writing for beginners, or the not very committed anyway. That said, a 6" top would appeal to me. Most of my benches use vises, and often stepping out of the box on bench top thickness will cause problems with vise installation if one is using commercial parts. But for Roubo like, or japanese like benches deeper is fine. I have one that has a top near 8 inches. That one I hewed and so bigger was easier to sort out of the log anyway.

I have never had a bench that was too heavy or too rigid. And for viseless benches, I like being able to plane the top to perfect flatness whenever it is required.

I blacksmithed a hold down once, and the key to getting good hold was the angle of the pad to the shank. A thicker top will change the angle, but it is adjustable. There are a lot of other variables one can play with like hole size, shank size, and stuff like barbed shanks. I could see making a hold down for certain thicknesses would be a problem, but six inch is so close to 4 that I can't see a problem.

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#7

Need heavy, rigid and flat?

Bob Hackett

Wood is not the most appropriate or sensible material to meet those requirements IME.

Steel (or even stone for that matter) is far heavier for comparable mass, will stay flatter longer (no warping or seasonal changes) and is WAY more rigid with far less bracing.

I also have far less trouble getting hold downs to grab in metal than I do in wood.

As far as vise mounting goes; why make the entire top uber thick when simple blocking in that area will do the job just as well?

Still haven`t heard a sensible or logical reason to make an entire cabinet maker`s benchtop out of 6" thick material. I might go along with that thickness for a smaller specialty bench but an entire regular sized cabinet maker`s bench? I still don`t see it as anything other than wasting good wood that could be put to better use elsewhere.

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#8

Re: Need heavy, rigid and flat?

TomD

"Wood is not the most appropriate or sensible material to meet those requirements IME."

Well that isn't really the point is it. Most woodworkers want a wooden bench. Such a bench is heavier more rigid, and has reserve material for flattening operations, the thicker it is.

"Steel (or even stone for that matter) is far heavier for comparable mass, will stay flatter longer (no warping or seasonal changes) and is WAY more rigid with far less bracing."

I have a four inch thick iron bench I use for metal fabrication, but it rusts quickly unless covered with oil. I also have measurement stone benches, and I have thought of making a bench out of several, but there are so many problems also. It is also a myth that these materials are stable. Wood is stable once it settles in, and it can be far more easily regulated with just a simple hand plane

"I also have far less trouble getting hold downs to grab in metal than I do in wood."

Yeah well, T-slots are a convenient thing, I have to agree. Though wood is not slippery. and go bars are easy to use, with less geometry limitations.

"As far as vise mounting goes; why make the entire top uber thick when simple blocking in that area will do the job just as well?"

My point was actually the reverse, that overly thick benches will created problems for conventional vise mounting. These are soluble issues, but it is something to keep in mind. I'm lucky in my work to do a lot of lamination, but to also be able to get big sticks. To Paraphrase Mr Benson (?). "You, Mr lamination, are no solid stick of lumber. Mr blocking does not even bear consideration."

"Still haven`t heard a sensible or logical reason to make an entire cabinet maker`s benchtop out of 6" thick material. I might go along with that thickness for a smaller specialty bench but an entire regular sized cabinet maker`s bench? I still don`t see it as anything other than wasting good wood that could be put to better use elsewhere."

Your not being convinced need not worry the rest of us. Speaking of logic, I think we all bristle when someone raises the bar, and if it catches on we all feel left behind unless we buy the Chaptons, or whatever. Personally 6 inches is more than I have contemplated, but my current bench is heavier than my first one, being 3 feet longer, and fairly thick. No regrets. As far as wasting wood is concerned, that is a trivial concern. Probably a large stick like this comes from a tree that is otherwise going to get burned for firewood. In my neighbourhood, which is fairly old, I have seen countless trees come down this past year that were large, and would make a thick bench just as easily as the firewood they were cut into. Three neighbours have taken down maples this last year. One took down 4. And a street called Old Orchard got logged out for intensification, I got wood that would easily have made such a bench, but at best was 3-4 feet long.

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#9

You have convinced me

rononkokomo

I will go Doug fir base and maple top

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#10

Re: You have convinced me

david weaver

Smart move.

Re: Follow up question massive bench tops

#11

I have one of those a month