New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

Posts

Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#1

Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

Marhk

The collective woodworking sophistication of this group is amazing. I would like to draw on this knowledge while trying to categorize individual sharpening techniques in a way that illustrates the many ways to the same goal - a sharp long lasting edge that is simple to resharpen. I would like folks to point out the various recipes that they use.

To start: What method are you using and happy with? More interesting to me is what edge configuration are you trying to achieve? Which shape is the best in terms of ease of sharpening, sharpness, duration?

Method -

Coarse steel removal can be accomplished by "grinding" using a wheel grinder, flat disk grinder, belt grinder, sand paper on flat surface, very coarse stones (water stones or diamond) or loose diamonds on cast iron. Honing is then by stones (water, oil or diamond), hard felt wheels, fine sand paper and/or leather stropping. A honing guide may or may not be used.

Configuration - bevel

There seem to be 3 approaches to sharpening the bevel side - concave, flat and convex. All these with or without a micro-bevel. (Don’t know of anyone who uses a micro-bevel with a convex main bevel - I have done it, it will work however with an acute convex bevel. Also don’t know anyone who uses a concave main bevel without a micro-bevel - too brittle and unhonable except maybe on a hard felt wheel.) The micro-bevel can be achieved by using a gauge, by tipping up slightly or by registering a concave bevel’s proximal and distal edges on the stone.

Configuration - back

The flat side (I'll call this the "back") needs to be sharpened. Some say dead flat. Some want it slightly hollow (not just Japanese chisels). Some call for a micro-bevel (ruler trick). I have even heard of a knife-like secondary bevel on the back of, for example, a carving tool. Some call for a slight hollow with a micro-bevel. (Charlesworth)

As to the back micro-bevel this can be achieved alternatively with the ruler trick, by slightly lifting the back as it's being honed, by pressing especially hard on the edge when honing the back, by stropping the back so as to create a slightly rolled-edge micro-bevel or by using a hard felt wheel to briefly touch-up the back.

So, it's obvious that a new woodworker faces a mountain of conflicting information. Just trying to comprehend the overall forest, let alone the individual trees is a daunting task. I wonder if we can even define the "best" way. Some of the super-surfacer data that was recently published seemed to illustrate a technique to comparatively study these various edge techniques. Too bad this type of comparative work hasn't been more exhaustively done! A magazine with roots deep in woodworking and the scientific method is called for. Too bad that doesn't exist!

My own journey through this sharpening asylum is as a life-long hobby woodworker (starting with 4 years of high school shop classes back in the early 60's). Lately I've been playing with the Sellers' method of sharpening using a convex bevel - with good, quick, sharp results. The convex bevel doesn’t need a guide and is surprisingly easy if one remembers to always start at a coarse stone - that to me is the secret to this technique. (Prior to that I used Charlesworth’s technique for about 8 years or so and prior to that, for most of my life, I just honed the flat bevel and didn’t think about it. I guess, I thus used a convex bevel during those years.) I don't think the convex bevel sharpening lasts as long as some of the other techniques, however. But, it is quick to redo and no tool or guide is required. (But, remember one hand clapping is not statistically significant - this is the problem throughout all of these discussions. We need real comparative data!) Recently I was browsing the ECE (wooden planes) catalog. They point out that a convex bevel is bad because it creates heat and dulls quickly. Maybe they are right. Just to be complete, I use a belt sander to reshape an edge. I think that with the heat sensitivity of A-2 steel that makes more sense than using a wheel. I have a flat disk grinder that I use for rehabbing old chisels and blades. It works to flatten the back but I've never seen one of these devices get a blade dead flat. I still have to flatten further on water and/or diamond stones. Sometimes I strop to renew an edge.

We touched on what various people do to finish honing the back during the discussion about the Kato / Kawai study. So, how do folks here deal with the bevel of a western blade - concave with a micro-bevel or flat with/without a micro-bevel or convex? Do you use a gauge? Note that I really wonder if anyone can hone a flat western bevel perfectly flat by hand - they really end up slightly convex. (Sort of what Sellers has been doing all along.)

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#2

Lazy and cheap approach

Bill Tindall

I hollow grind on a 7 " wheel. Then straighten edge on a fixed diamond plate. Then refine edge with 1 micron loose diamond on cast iron. Stroke back of blade a few times for good measure. All operations are free hand. It works for the tasks I do. It is cheap, and quick and doesn't require much skill or practice.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#3

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

TomD

One can always break down, and rather than re-inventing the wheel, just do what the maker did. Particularly when starting out. There seems to be an assumption on the net, probably true, that there is always a better way, other than how the designer, maker did it. Gets real scary with stuff like boat plans. But sometimes you can just repeat what the maker did. So say Hock blades that are hollow ground, or some of my own blades, might get the grinder. Japanese chisels get hand sharpened on Japanese stones, etc... Other stuff would work, and one can learn to break the rules, which is generally non-tragic, but not always.

Concave and micro bevel. A lot of knives, some drawknives, a lot of axes, maybe some mortising chisels. As you rightly point out, it can be complex...

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#4

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

CStanford

Flatten the back, hollow grind the bevel, hone on oilstones, maybe a secondary bevel on chisels that feel a mallet often.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#5

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

CStanford

I call it the one sentence approach.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#6

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

Marhk

So, what about my contention that anyone sharpening a bevel (without an intentional micro-bevel) by hand will end up with a convex shape?

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#7

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

Schtoo

Marhk asked;

"So, what about my contention that anyone sharpening a bevel (without an intentional micro-bevel) by hand will end up with a convex shape?"

You believe that if you want to. I'd have to say it's quite likely to occur for most folks, but not everyone will automatically make an initially flat bevel convex.

Other than that, good luck with your sharpening.

Stu.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#8

not one hollow ground...shortcoming of convexity

Bill Tindall

Which of course is why many shops hollow grind. It is not only fast it results in a surface that sucks down on a flat, smooth sharpening media resulting in "perfect" registration.

I never could free hand grind till I went to hollow grinding because of the covexity you are discussing. The problem with "convexity" is that it breeds more of itself. The more convex the bevel becomes the greater the tendency to enhance it to ensure the edge refining is getting to the edge.

The knife people advocate a convex edge for durability but I think it a flawed plan for chisels.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#9

Re: not one hollow ground...shortcoming of convexi

Howard Pollack

Same is true for me. I've never been able to figure out why a convex bevel is not as useful as a flat bevel...

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#10

Flat bevels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Some years ago fellow on this forum claimed his jointer irons were sharpened perfectly straight across. He was not happy when I asked how perfect they were. Bevels will be less than perfect whether they are jigged or hollow ground or freehand flat or "micro bevel". That does not mean that flatter bevels are not preferable. Intentionally rounded bevels, "micro bevels" and hollow ground bevels all affect the wedging action of a chisel.

I think that stropping is worth learning to do well for a fine edge. Stropping is much more clumsy if there is a micro bevel or an intentionally convex bevel.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#11

Re: Flat bevels

Marhk

"Stropping is much more clumsy if there is an intentionally convex bevel"

I wonder if you could please explain why this is so?

Always seemed to me that if the final angle of a bevel was say 25 deg at the edge, then it didn't matter that one side of the angle were convex. The effect is the same at the edge. But, the friction (and heat) would be more. So, edge life may be less. Sharpness would be the same. Control, at least according to Sellers, is better with a convex-edge chisel.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#12

Re: not one hollow ground...shortcoming of convexi

Marhk

"The problem with "convexity" is that it breeds more of itself."

You know, I agree with this. At least I did until I realized the trick of starting with a coarse diamond stone to sharpen the convex bevel. It works. Several swipes on the coarse stone then I move to a 1000 grit water stone - and up from there.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#13

Re: Flat bevels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Stropping is an operation that requires feel and touch, practice and consistency. It is important just how one holds the tool, how much pressure is applied etc. Without the bevel to help feel the action, one is sort of swimming in the dark.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#14

Re: Approaching flat by hand, with no guides..

david weaver

... and no grinder.

If you want to avoid making a convex bevel, especially on thinner irons, side sharpen them to do your grinding, and do it each time you hone.

Your convexity will be in a much broader direction of the item being sharpened, and at that, you might even end up with the perfect amount for a smoother iron.

convex bevels or none on chisels, whatever you want to do. There seem to be some instructors wrapped up in convincing people that their method is the only way, which to me is grandstanding to get business.

On plane irons, the wear in use actually occurs to round the bevel until the relief is gone. I have no clue why someone would want to be less precise with their primary angle and actually hone such a shape into the edge of a tool. Sure, you can work like that, but it takes more time to do it and creates an edge that will not have the all-important relief as long.

If you are just working to work, and not to sharpen, I can't see why anyone would hand grind, especially if they have full-thickness hardened steel modern irons. A grinder and two stones (medium stone and finish stone - might not even need the finish stone), and a decent piece of clean leather should make sharpening everything fast. Substitute a belt sander if you want. Sharpening something like a chisel should take about 30 seconds, maybe two minutes for a smoother plane iron, and without compromising relief geometry.

But do what you want, though, there are a lot of people really overthinking the whole process because some folks are implying that their way is so good you can't get along without it.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#15

Tried em all

rononkokomo

If you subtract my 9 year hiatus, I have been doing this for more than 25 years. They all work. Scary sharp, water stones, oil stones, diamond stones. All have pluses and minuses. I just read an article this morning over on tools for working wood about diamond paste on maple or mdf. Intriguing because you can easily get a 5 inch by 12 inch "stone" if you want one. I know that he is a little controversial here, but Sellers honing method makes a huge amount of sense to me. A couple of my oil stones are a little narrow for this technique. I talked to a guy today who adds a surgical black Arkansas into the mix just before stropping . That too makes a little sense to me. My surgical black translucent is like marble.

I will be very interested in this thread

Ron

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#16

I forgot

rononkokomo

I know that there are some engineering types out here that are searching for perfection in an edge. That is fine. It is their time. I think it is fairly obvious that most of the older "gurus" hone the way that they were taught to hone. Remember that all of tese methods will, with practice, produce killer sharp edges. So, you quickly get to a place where improvement is a distinction that really does not make a difference,except for those on a quest for the perfect edge. Also, the human ego being what it is, a guy who has honed a certain way for 50 years is going to feel that it is the best way to do it.

It is one of them pins and tails things. Some incredibly gorgeous drawers done each way. I really do love the discussion

Remember Tage Frid honed with belt sander and felt wheel. His chisels and plane irons worked great.

Understand.. I do get value from the guys seeking the "perfect" whatever. I can read and listen, experiment and decide. I got all excited about Schwarz's tool chest and for two weeks I wanted to build one. Then, I realized that my tools never leave my shop. I do not need a chest. So what might be the very best for me might not be what you ought to do.

Ron

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#17

Re: Approaching flat by hand, with no guides..

Marhk

My personal approach is sharpen - slam, bam and back to work. I admit I can't hold a bevel flat. I get a convex edge if I don't use a gauge - and usually I don't want to take the time. But, I think a convex edge is OK. It can be quite sharp. My concern as noted is the duration of that edge. I used to use the Charlesworth method. It works well! I got beautiful sharp, long lasting edges. Using a gauge they were fairly easy to resharpen. But, the process to get there … !

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#18

Re: Flat bevels

Tom Colligan

Warren, when I think of stropping it is dragging rearward the iron or chisel along a fixed piece of leather charged with a compound.

Do you not also dubb the corner edges of the iron while doing this? How do you avoid doing this? Tia, Tom.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#19

Stropping

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Stropping is a very complicated subject. The last few operations we do to an edge are best evaluated on an empirical basis rather than a theoretical one. The feedback we get from using various strategies is more important than a textbook explanation.

In one stropping strategy, a fine abrasive compound is applied to the strop. Here the idea is that the compound is finer than the stones, making a more refined edge. This might not be so important in an era when we can manufacture stones with the same compound.

In another strategy, a fragile abrasive is applied to the strop. Here the idea is that the abrasive particles start out somewhat more aggressively and break down during use, giving a finer and finer polish. Historically this method could be used when very small uniform particles were not available.

Strops are also used without compound or dressing. The success of this method has caused some to insist that there must be some magic abrasive in the leather. I don't think there is much evidence of silica in the leather.

I have used a clean strop for more than forty years. I don't know how much dubbing occurs. I do think that technique is very important, and that the ability to evaluate the performance of the edge helps shape and refine one's technique. As I mentioned earlier, I think that secondary bevels and grossly convex bevels make stropping, already a sensitive operation, more difficult.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#20

Re: Stropping

Marhk

"Bevels will be less than perfect whether they are jigged or hollow ground or freehand flat or "micro bevel"."

Warren, if you please: It sounds like you use a gauge to be sure of a flat bevel. Is that true.

I suspect you try for a dead-flat back. Is that also true?

Thanks, Mark

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#21

Re: Stropping

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was trained to sharpen freehand in 1962. I can't remember ever using a sharpening jig. I think the bevels just naturally get flatter, the angle more consistent as one gains experience.

Dead-flat back? I like it to be flat enough so that when it is abraded on the stone the back gets worked at the edge. An eight inch plane iron does not need to be flat for eight inches.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#22

Re: Stropping

david weaver

I will second the clean strop. A bare leather strop is mildly abrasive, extremely mildly abrasive. if you strop a razor edge across one for 18 inches, you can just see a glint of light where the edge has been worn some on both sides. That's about 20 times as much work as you'd do to a tool edge removing undesirable bits left from the stone.

I don't find loaded strops preferable over bare strops. The end result isn't much or any better, and the abrasives that are used in strops now are aggressive - too aggressive, I think, for something soft.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#23

Re: Stropping

Marhk

Warren, thanks for the reply.

I learned the same way in 1960 - but, it has always been my feeling that a human is unable to hold a western bevel and sharpen it so it remains flat. Physiologically muscles can't lock that well. But, it can be close enough.

As to the back of the blade, do you use any tricks to put more pressure on the edge?

Mark

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#24

Sharpening

Warren in Lancaster, PA

but, it has always been my feeling that a human is unable to hold a western bevel and sharpen it so it remains flat. Physiologically muscles can't lock that well.

Well I certainly don't agree with these ideas. We have been sharpening tools since the beginning of the Bronze Age. I think locking muscles is kind of a dead-end strategy.

Re: Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)

#25

Re: Sharpening

Marhk

Warren, interesting perspective. The real question is: has anyone ever actually carefully tried to measure how flat a bevel sharpened by hand is - or is it a question of flat enough, and it really is a slight convex bevel. I still don't think humans can do absolute flat - nothing in Nature is flat. But "flat enough" is possible.

Now, what tricks do you use to sharpen the back at the edge?

Mark