Sharpening, Overall Collective Approach (Long)
Marhk
The collective woodworking sophistication of this group is amazing. I would like to draw on this knowledge while trying to categorize individual sharpening techniques in a way that illustrates the many ways to the same goal - a sharp long lasting edge that is simple to resharpen. I would like folks to point out the various recipes that they use.
To start: What method are you using and happy with? More interesting to me is what edge configuration are you trying to achieve? Which shape is the best in terms of ease of sharpening, sharpness, duration?
Method -
Coarse steel removal can be accomplished by "grinding" using a wheel grinder, flat disk grinder, belt grinder, sand paper on flat surface, very coarse stones (water stones or diamond) or loose diamonds on cast iron. Honing is then by stones (water, oil or diamond), hard felt wheels, fine sand paper and/or leather stropping. A honing guide may or may not be used.
Configuration - bevel
There seem to be 3 approaches to sharpening the bevel side - concave, flat and convex. All these with or without a micro-bevel. (Don’t know of anyone who uses a micro-bevel with a convex main bevel - I have done it, it will work however with an acute convex bevel. Also don’t know anyone who uses a concave main bevel without a micro-bevel - too brittle and unhonable except maybe on a hard felt wheel.) The micro-bevel can be achieved by using a gauge, by tipping up slightly or by registering a concave bevel’s proximal and distal edges on the stone.
Configuration - back
The flat side (I'll call this the "back") needs to be sharpened. Some say dead flat. Some want it slightly hollow (not just Japanese chisels). Some call for a micro-bevel (ruler trick). I have even heard of a knife-like secondary bevel on the back of, for example, a carving tool. Some call for a slight hollow with a micro-bevel. (Charlesworth)
As to the back micro-bevel this can be achieved alternatively with the ruler trick, by slightly lifting the back as it's being honed, by pressing especially hard on the edge when honing the back, by stropping the back so as to create a slightly rolled-edge micro-bevel or by using a hard felt wheel to briefly touch-up the back.
So, it's obvious that a new woodworker faces a mountain of conflicting information. Just trying to comprehend the overall forest, let alone the individual trees is a daunting task. I wonder if we can even define the "best" way. Some of the super-surfacer data that was recently published seemed to illustrate a technique to comparatively study these various edge techniques. Too bad this type of comparative work hasn't been more exhaustively done! A magazine with roots deep in woodworking and the scientific method is called for. Too bad that doesn't exist!
My own journey through this sharpening asylum is as a life-long hobby woodworker (starting with 4 years of high school shop classes back in the early 60's). Lately I've been playing with the Sellers' method of sharpening using a convex bevel - with good, quick, sharp results. The convex bevel doesn’t need a guide and is surprisingly easy if one remembers to always start at a coarse stone - that to me is the secret to this technique. (Prior to that I used Charlesworth’s technique for about 8 years or so and prior to that, for most of my life, I just honed the flat bevel and didn’t think about it. I guess, I thus used a convex bevel during those years.) I don't think the convex bevel sharpening lasts as long as some of the other techniques, however. But, it is quick to redo and no tool or guide is required. (But, remember one hand clapping is not statistically significant - this is the problem throughout all of these discussions. We need real comparative data!) Recently I was browsing the ECE (wooden planes) catalog. They point out that a convex bevel is bad because it creates heat and dulls quickly. Maybe they are right. Just to be complete, I use a belt sander to reshape an edge. I think that with the heat sensitivity of A-2 steel that makes more sense than using a wheel. I have a flat disk grinder that I use for rehabbing old chisels and blades. It works to flatten the back but I've never seen one of these devices get a blade dead flat. I still have to flatten further on water and/or diamond stones. Sometimes I strop to renew an edge.
We touched on what various people do to finish honing the back during the discussion about the Kato / Kawai study. So, how do folks here deal with the bevel of a western blade - concave with a micro-bevel or flat with/without a micro-bevel or convex? Do you use a gauge? Note that I really wonder if anyone can hone a flat western bevel perfectly flat by hand - they really end up slightly convex. (Sort of what Sellers has been doing all along.)



