New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

heating, tempering etc.

Posts

heating, tempering etc.

#1

heating, tempering etc.

eliot d

Let's say you have an ordinary pen knife-- some kind of nothing special steel. Is there a way to heat treat, temper, etc. to improve it, or will it always be just an ordinary blade no matter what you do? ( I'm not talking about sharpening, which is something else.)

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#2

Ellis Walentine

My 2¢

Ellis Walentine

I am not a knife enthusiast or maven, but I think that better knives are made with better steel, and it's already tempered to the hardness you want. Cheap knives are made with poorer steel, and it's anybody's guess as to whether you can improve on the edge-holding or hardness or anything else.

Ellis

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#3

Re: heating, tempering etc.

John in NM

My feeling on it is about like Ellis' the manufacturer has probably hit on about the right balance for hardness vs. toughness for the particular steel they use. If you were going to try it, you would have to dis-assemble the knife, steel has to get pretty hot and then quenched, much easier to do the individual blade than the whole assembly.

You might have some luck with making the bevel steeper though, I usually carry a multi-blade knife and keep one blade at the factory grind and sharpen another more steeply. The steep blade dulls faster, but it's good for tasks where you really need all kinds of sharp.

I have some German knives I really like, made in the last 20 years or so. Steel takes a great edge and does discolor some in use, but doesn't get the little rust specs that my current knife does (1095 I think). No idea what those Germans used, but I like it :D

You can see knives are yet another slippery slope :D

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#4

Re: heating, tempering etc.

Patrick Gibbons

Ellis is right. Cheap knives are probably a lost cause. Older stainless was almost impossible to sharpen. This has changed greatly and stainless blades are now available that can be sharpened. Knives tend to be hardened less than a chisel or plane blade. I believe the need for toughness is greater. If your knife is of good quality it may still be more a matter of sharpening rather than improving the temper.

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#5

I agree.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Besides which, that knife will have to come apart. There is no way to heat the blade only that I can think of without torching the scales or the rest of the knife.

Not only that, but take 440 stainless for instance. There are at least four grades of 440 but only one of them makes an acceptable knife. So if the blade is stamped 440, you still don't know what you have. You don't know what steel is in the blade. That is important because each type of steel has its own heat-treating schedule.

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#6

Re: I agree.

TomD

The premise that the maker probably did the best that could be expected from the steel is not really true. One example to the contrary was in that Jim Cummings shop tips video, where he discussed that one could vastly improve blister pack chisels of the day by heat treating them to a decent hardness. Another example was a few years back when the knife industry faced a shortage of 440C, and substituted various other metals that had always been the ones that they marketed against as being shoddy. A bit of a "repositioning" job was in order. The upshot of which was that, sure, they could use that stuff so long as they HTd it to their specs.

Of course, one can argue that the makers got exactly what they wanted out of their lower performance efforts, the main point being that a lot of people can't sharpen, or do sharpen with stuff like steels, files, etc... So these efforts may not have been mistaken, they hit the numbers they were after.

As far as this project is concerned, the biggest barrier to re-HTing a blade is knowing what the steel is. Home shop methods often can not be applied to stainless, and even if the steel is HC, if you do not know which kind it is, then you could burn the blade up trying to hit your numbers. Other than that, the difficulties mentioned do have technical answers, but really, pocket knives by the likes of CRKT are so cheap that a good lifetime knife can be the cost of a movie and popcorn. I am a believer in some of the cheaper maker's offers, Or home made O1, because while I treat all tools with great respect, I there are times when you need to use a knife up or leave it, and you don't want to leave anything too distinctive, or valuable behind. ATMO.

Most recent knife, and it is pretty nice at that:

http://www.warriorsandwonders.com/CRKT/CRKT_Tuition_Plain_Edge_1060

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#7

Re: heating, tempering etc.

R Payne

That is a complex question.

First is what do you want out of a knife?

What is available in the store often has little to do with getting the best cutting edge and more to do with making something that won't break and injure someone when it gets abused.

I've made myself a few knives and left them harder than what can be bought because I know what I want and how I'll use them. I've made one or two softer that I can be rough with (as in hammering the spine).

To re-heat treat a knife you'll have to take it apart. And if you don't know the alloy then the heat treat becomes a guess. Carbon steels are fairly easy but higher alloys have very specific heating and cooling requirements. Just because a knife is "ordinary" or "cheap" doesn't mean it's a carbon steel blade.

It's easier to make a knife from scratch then take one apart, re-heat treat it (possibly getting it wrong) and put it back together.

ron

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#8

Re: heating, tempering etc.

Brian from Monument

If you have a knife that has a not so great blade.

Replace it.

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#9

A good cheap knife

Patrick Gibbons

There are many good cheap knives that can be put into service and not break the bank. Two classics are the German-made Mercator kat knife that is available at world knives for about $20. Lee Valley offers the equally good French-made Douk Douk knives. These are both a study in minimalist less-is-more construction. The steel is simple high carbon steel, about like 1060. There are also a number of Case pocket knives that can be had for $30 and less. I'm not big on Asian-made knives but many recommend some highly and they can be very inexpensive.

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#10

Correction

Patrick Gibbons

Lee Valley does not carry the Douk Douk knives but they do have Opinel which is another classic. Garrett Wade carries the Douk Douks.

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#11

Stephen Shepherd

Re: heating, tempering etc.

Stephen Shepherd

Since no one answered your question, I'll give it a shot. Take the blade from the rest of the knife and heat the edge up cherry red and quench in water. Do this by plunging the hot edge in the water and move it around until the hissing stops then plunge the entire blade into the water.

Use fine sandpaper, wire brush to remove the discoloration so you have bright metal. Then gently heat up the back of the blade until it turns a straw color and plunge in water.

Sharpen and reassemble the knife.

Stephen

Re: heating, tempering etc.

#12

Re: heating, tempering etc.

TomD

That works assuming the blade is high carbon steel, which most pocket knives today aren't.

Testing with a magnet is a better bet than cherry red, though unfortunately these transformation points do not relate perfectly to the transformation point of metals. So for o1 the point at which it demagnetizes is 50F below the transformation point. What I do is take it one visible colour change above the demag point. Some steels are fine at demag.

Quenching in water is risky. Mineral oil, olive oil, or bacon fat/drippings is less likely to break a knife blade when quenched. For a small thin object swirling around, which I certainly do , has to be done carefully since with fragile projects it can warp a blade. So normally more a vertical motion, with enough quenchent to have some room to work in. However, straight down into a can of grease works fine, watch out for the flames.

If one was doing the hardening with an oxy torch, like a jewlers, etc... use, then it might be possible to differentially harden the blade without removing it from the handle. In this approach the heat is targeted only for the edge third of the knife blade. With oxy the heat builds so fast it might not have time to run into the handle enough to do damage, and one could use some heat sink foam. Normally the correct way to do this is to carry the hardness down past the edge of the knife just enough so that it carries into the shoulder, and there isn't a stress riser at the choil. But one could skip that and reduce the heat transfer further.