From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)
Bruce McCrory
Bill Tindall's Dovetail Marking device Post is de-volving; and too interesting for my following thoughts.
I remember my youth, and a "junk store" chest of drawers of birds-eye maple veneer, and machine-made dovetails. Definitely, pre-teen (single-digits) at the time. Dovetails were explained to me. The mystique remains.
That said, I finished a kit-build bedroom set at least thirty years ago. Every joint is fully glued, filleted with white glue. The drawers are pine, with sides less than 3/8" thick and joined to the face-fronts with sliding dovetails.
I never heard of wood expansion then, and probably would ignore it today, if I wasn't brainwashed.
On that last note, I add the next:
My wife is a Goodwill, Value Village, Thrift Store "diver". Shortly after my success with the bedroom set, she came home with a pile of rock maple--literally.
I have forgotten what she paid for it, but I spent more in rope to bind the warped and split pieces into what I consider a fine desk. The 'twist sticks' were 2x4s. There are, at least, two pounds of the heaviest brass screws I could find holding the desk together--along with 'gallons' of carpenter's glue. I poured boiling water onto the wood, and floated the wood in boiling water before reefing pieces back together. There is not a single joint that was not used to bring the parts into their former selves. The dust-liners were conscripted.
The only joints that have failed in the desk and chest were dovetails.
Look at most woodworker benches. The finger joints, the dovetails are all separating. Every old finger-jointed box I have seen is failing.
I love Dovetails. I always want to use finger joints. But I don't think they are all they are hyped to be.
And I share the opinions of others on antiques. In theory, if you use hide glue, in addition you can simply re-glue them and be back to the beginning.


