New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

Posts

From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

#1

From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

Bruce McCrory

Bill Tindall's Dovetail Marking device Post is de-volving; and too interesting for my following thoughts.

I remember my youth, and a "junk store" chest of drawers of birds-eye maple veneer, and machine-made dovetails. Definitely, pre-teen (single-digits) at the time. Dovetails were explained to me. The mystique remains.

That said, I finished a kit-build bedroom set at least thirty years ago. Every joint is fully glued, filleted with white glue. The drawers are pine, with sides less than 3/8" thick and joined to the face-fronts with sliding dovetails.

I never heard of wood expansion then, and probably would ignore it today, if I wasn't brainwashed.

On that last note, I add the next:

My wife is a Goodwill, Value Village, Thrift Store "diver". Shortly after my success with the bedroom set, she came home with a pile of rock maple--literally.

I have forgotten what she paid for it, but I spent more in rope to bind the warped and split pieces into what I consider a fine desk. The 'twist sticks' were 2x4s. There are, at least, two pounds of the heaviest brass screws I could find holding the desk together--along with 'gallons' of carpenter's glue. I poured boiling water onto the wood, and floated the wood in boiling water before reefing pieces back together. There is not a single joint that was not used to bring the parts into their former selves. The dust-liners were conscripted.

The only joints that have failed in the desk and chest were dovetails.

Look at most woodworker benches. The finger joints, the dovetails are all separating. Every old finger-jointed box I have seen is failing.

I love Dovetails. I always want to use finger joints. But I don't think they are all they are hyped to be.

Re: From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

#2

Respectfully disagree

rononkokomo

I have seen some pretty old stuff with still wonderfully intact dovetail joints.

Re: From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

#3

Re: Respectfully disagree

Bruce McCrory

You are probably right. Some day, I will jump over the museum barrier rope and inspect furniture drawers.

I do love the looks of dovetails.

Re: From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

#4

stores not museums

Bill Tindall

Visit antique stores. I have never been in one that didn't honor a request to inspect a drawer. I always ask permission to open a drawer in a shop. Once the owner sees that I know about furniture and respects furniture I am usually given the keys to the store.

Re: From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

#5

Re: From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail

TomD

Dovetails I have not had problems with. I now have some of my own that are 30 years old, and the are "as good as the day I made them". :) And I share the opinions of others on antiques. In theory, if you use hide glue, in addition you can simply re-glue them and be back to the beginning.

Finger joints I have seen a lot of failures. The reason for that is somewhat hard to fathom. In part it has to do with the mechanical advantages to dovetails, in drawers for instance. Beyond that there may be a pinching effect, just as they can be assembled without clamps, that somehow gives them an advantage should uneven moisture pull on them. That is speculation. I made some drawers with finger joints and they are doing great. I think that finger joints are very dependent on set-up. A minor change in set-up could scour the glue, or leave the joint too loose to work well. They can't be easily clamped, so there can be minimal pressure during glue up. When one looks at the massive advantage in glue surface area, it is not clear to me why finger joints seem to fail at a so much higher rate. Anyway they aren't that much easier or faster to make, if at all, and they add little to a piece.

Re: From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

#6

Ellis Walentine

How do finger joints fail?

Ellis Walentine

I have a box I made for my wife in 1974, with finger-jointed corners, and the joints are still holding their own. You will always have cross-grain expansion and contraction wanting to wreck a perfectly good joint, but the joints should at least hang together. I have an old beer carton from the early part of the last century that was finger-jointed, and it's still hanging tight, though it's been in houses and outside in sheds for 30 years or more, and probably 50 years before that.

Maybe this is more of a discussion about glue flexibility.

Ellis

Re: From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

#7

I think you're right...

John in NM

Its the glue more than the joint, assuming the joint isn't too loose in the first place.

I have a bunch of old dynamite boxes from the mid 1960's that have been dragged around with hardware and who knows what else in them for the last 50 years. Not left out in the weather, but more or less abused in every other way. Finger joints still holding just fine.

Dad and his partner used the dynamite to "dig" prospect pits on mineral claims, back when you had to do that when staking the claim. Less work, more fun he said.

Re: From-Directions for making dovetail (they fail)

#8

Re: How do finger joints fail?

TomD

I don't know. The only obvious example was the back of a silver drawer where it just got pounded out, that is a directional problem where dovetails would have been better. But I have spent a fair amount of time fixing the little darlings, and I have seen a lot go. One place I worked had a ton of in/out baskets, and every one of them needed fixing. In that case the joints seemed tight enough. I think it is possible that they would do badly in moisture variations due to uneven take up of moisture. If that does not occur with perfect uniformity then there will be a tension across the joint faces. Since dovetails are angled, you have more of a shear situation. But as I said, beats me.

By the way flexible glues are rarely an advantage in wood construction. Wood is outstandingly stiff and hard glue is almost always better.