New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Kanaban - flatness question

Posts

Kanaban - flatness question

#1

Kanaban - flatness question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi -

I am using a Kanaban (from Joel's Tools for Working Wood) and diamond paste to flatten the backs of flea market acquired handplane blades. It's taking a long time...but that's not my question. I have begun to wonder if anyone has had any experience where they have used a Kanaban and diamond paste found that it went out of flat. I suspect that all of them will, eventually, but I don't do all that much flattening to have thought it would have by now.

Also I don't really have a super reliable reference. I have a couple of flea market acquired Starrett combination square blades and they suggest it may be getting dished in the center. But since they are not new - or even nearly new - I am not sure how reliable they are.

Does anyone have any experience with these Kanaban...and/or any suggestions on how to check for flatness without investing in a new reference of some kind.

Thank you -

Dave

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#2

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

david weaver

Couple of points:

* those kanaban aren't always that flat to start. Mine isn't (I use one of the same thing with 100 grit diamond on coarse work).

* eventually they will go out of flat if you work loose diamond on them long enough, they'll go hollow in the middle where your pressure concentrates. If you're working something fairly large, you can reduce that by using the whole surface

* you can lap the kanaban on coarse PSA sandpaper rolled out on a truly flat surface to get it close to flat (especially if you have the kanaban permanently mounted to something).

It is mild steel and mild steel lapping is slow going, but you can do it.

If you want to use one for finer flatter work, you could try one of the tsunesaburo ground kanabans or LV's ground mild steel plates, they're essentially the same thing.

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#3

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Dave

I can tell you what I do, but emphasise that it is based on my logic, and not any empirical findings.

My assumption is that loose diamond will wear both sides of the sandwich. So, I smear the paste on the cast iron, press it in with the back of a blade, and then wipe off all excess. It is the diamond that is embedded in the surface that does the work. The paste is just the carrier, and left on the surface it will cause damage in the same way that loose diamonds do.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#4

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Yes, they go out of flat. I used mine for several years and noticed a marked depression in the middle.

Flattening them with sandpaper on granite will do the job. But it's not something you do quickly.

BTW, did you know they are two sided? You can flip them over and use the other side as well.

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#5

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

TomD

I can't say wear has been a problem for me. I did all my flattening like 30 years ago, pretty much does it for life. I used silicon carbide, for one thing it breaks down and eventually you get a mirror polish that is unlike anything else.

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#6

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, David.

I am using this mainly for course work. I am using the 45 micron paste from tools for working wood. I probably have let too much of the loose diamonds roll around for too long. I do use the whole Kanaban when I sharpen. As well I flip it around every so often. I probably will try to lap it against sandpaper and see how that goes. I was hoping to get this blade I am working on flattened before I started something else...like lapping a kanaban. Oh, well.....

Thanks for your thoughts.

Dave

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#7

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, Derek.

I have gone full circle on the diamonds on kanaban. Initially I did something similar to what you suggested. That is, I mixed the paste with water on the kanaban so that it became a suspension. Then I would press down firmly with the blade on the kanaban consciously trying to embed the diamonds in the steel...and I work my way down the length of the kanaban do this. When this was done then I'd go into the standard back and forth flattening motion.

But this I was away from sharpening and when I got back to it I just went straight to the sharpening motion with out trying to embed it into the steel. Only recently I have I worked to recover my original approach. I suspect that it was this interim period where I may have done most of the dishing of the kanaban.

Thank you for sharing your thoughts.

Dave

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#8

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, Dominic. Yes, I don't relish flattening one of these with sandpaper on glass...and, yes, I have already flipped it over some time ago. Unfortunately, this time when I flipped it over a second time apparently water (my paste is water soluable) had gotten underneath and on the back side so that it was pretty baddly rusted. Bummer.

I appreciate your taking the time to share your thoughts.

Dave

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#9

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Tom -

Yes...it would be nice to have all the back flattening over. That is also one of the advantages to buying your tools new...that is, relatively less time spend flattening the backs of blades or trying to remove pitting. It appears to me to be a little discussed occupational hazzard of getting into this whole thing of building your tool set from flea markets and antique stores. It's always seems to be time vs. money.

Thank you for sharing.

Dave

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#10

Alternatives to metal sometimes work better

Bob Hackett

If you look in the archives for threads about using loose diamond in the more coarse grades I think you`ll find that one of the best substrates for doing what you`re doing is actually a plastic like plexiglass.

The advantages include; more of the coarse diamond is embedded, easier to charge the plate, no corrosion (of the substrate at least, the swarf will still rust) and when it wears to the point where flatness becomes an issue it`s a whole lot easier to sand plastic back to flat then it is metal.

I find that while theory may be fun, nothing beats actual experience in the field and there`s a boatload of experience with diamonds floating around here. You can start by searching the Archives for Bill Tindall`s posts and then look for David B`s in depth explanations of the hows and whys of what he has been doing for years. Both these gentlemen have been instrumental in illuminating the proper use of diamonds for beginner and experienced hand alike.

I know they, as well as others here, have been a huge help to me when it comes to sorting things out to get the best results and experience in the shop and the shop is where something either shines or falls flat on it`s face.

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#11

Check your references

James Watriss

Starrett blades are generally hardened. And if you have two, you can check them against each other. To make sure the reading is good, turn one end for end and check again

Never lapped a kanaban. But I did recently file the sole of an old infill. Yes, it takes time, but it's doable.

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#12

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

TomD

Good point, i tend to belt sand that level of tool. Not out of disrespect, but it seems to be a good bet if there is pitting. Or course some are too delicate for such treatment.

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#13

Re: Alternatives to metal sometimes work better

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Bob -

I'd sure be willing to give plexiglass a try...at the right price. I did look at some of Bill's posts and, if I recall correctly, he suggested MSC as a supplier, but they sell it by the (big) sheet and I don't want to pay that much for that much when this would be - at least initially - just an experiment to see how it goes.

Do you know where a person can pick up a small bit of this stuff at a decent price? Also, how thick does it need to be? The big box sells the thin stuff.

Thanks.

Dave

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#14

Re: Check your references

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, James. On the starrett combination blades - good idea. I'll give it a try.

And, yes, this does look like it going to take a while. Not sure I have the patience for it. Bad enough flattening the backs of these flea market plane blades and chisels.

Best -

Dave

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#15

Re: Alternatives to metal sometimes work better

Bob Hackett

You can glue the thin stuff down to a plywood backer. I get plenty of high quality ply scraps from the local boatyards. While you`re down at those boatyards ask about thick scrap lexan or plexiglass from hatches or portlights (portholes). you never know until you ask.

I`d also ask around at local glass shops. Many of the places that do glass replacement will also work with plastics as well.

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#16

Re: Alternatives to metal sometimes work better

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thanks, Bob. Don't get down by many shipyards, but we do have a number of glass places not too far away. Great suggestion. I think I may give one of them a try. In the meantime perhaps I will try with gluing one of those thinner ones on a piece of plywood and see how it goes. Might beat lapping my kanaban flat.

Best -

Dave

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#17

Re: Alternatives to metal sometimes work better

William Duffield

Dave,

I've got some plexiglass scraps (from a boat builder), probably around 1/2" thick. I'd be more than happy to mail you one, if you'll e-mail me your address. I've misplaced it, and all I remember is 30th something. I've actually used some of it as a substrate for diamond paste. How big a chunk do you need?

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#18

Re: Alternatives to metal sometimes work better

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi William -

Thank you! I hope you are well. It has been quite a while. Your offer is incredibly generous...and your memory is excellent. My email address is: david.shoultz@verizon.net.

I'm not sure how much I need. What was your experience with diamond on plexiglass? Did it dish much and/or quickly? Could it be flattened? I'm not thinking I would use it for all my sharpening...just to flatten backs of flea market acquired plane blades, chisel blades and the like. Still, as you know well flattening backs is pretty hard on ones sharpening resources. I'd be very interested in your thoughts and experiences. The whole diamond on plexiglass is new to me.

Again, many thanks!

Dave

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#19

Re: Alternatives to metal sometimes work better *LINK*

William Duffield

The important thing is that diamond paste on plexiglass is cheap. If and when your sharpening practice dishes it so much that it is no longer giving you the desired results, you turn it over. When you've dished the second surface, you throw it out, or use it for something else, like an auxiliary fence or a stop block or a dovetail gauge. The only problem with reflattening it is that you need something sharp to flatten it, and the diamond that is still embedded in it will dull your cutting tool. Adam Cherubini explains the concept (see link). Be aware that acrylic is tougher than UHMW, but the concept is the same. When machining it, it will chip more easily, and it will melt more easily if you don't cut quickly.

The main limitation is with the finest grits of diamond, which tend to get embedded so deeply in the plexiglass that they do not cut effectively. At some point between sharpening and polishing, you will get better results by switching your substrate to cast iron.

I found your address, e-mail, phone, etc. I'll square up the blocks I have for you and send them off.


Arts and Mysteries - Planing Plastic

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#20

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: Alternatives to metal sometimes work better

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Well how to you like that? I totally forgot about using acrylic! I just finished a home project that required me to cut 4" wide x 28" long pieces of 1/4" thk US resistant plexiglass. I have a couple pieces that'd be perfect for this

Would gluing/fastening them to a piece of 3/4" MDF be a good idea?

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#21

The "coastal approach"

Bob Hackett

Most times I use the "smallest stick" approach (AKA the Todd H technique) to most things. First thing I did was to just lay it on top of a large, flat granite slab (a drop from a local counter top company) and attempted to put it to work, when it slid around too much I used hot glue to attach a few battens to the granite to trap it. The idea being that if I didn`t glue it then I could flip it when it dished. Never occurred to me that if you put the dished side down then the thin stuff will just flex and the flat side becomes dished as you bear down on it. Who woulda thought it.

So I flipped it back over, used some 3M spray adhesive I had hanging around from my scary sharp days to glue it to a scrap of high grade marine ply I got from our "transfer station" (AKA, the dump. Man I love our dump good stuff for nothing and it`s also the social center of our local universe here. Local politicos do some major campaign work on the weekends there.)

The ones I find most useful for the back flattening are ones I screwed and glued another ply batten onto so the whole thing forms a T. The leg of the T is so the whole thing can be gripped in the nearest vice or clamped up against the edge of a bench or sawhorse if you like to work out on the driveway on sunny days like I do. I shaped the part I grip in the vise so it`s comfortable to use as a handle when I have to sand the plastic flat again (just be sure to use at least one grit size finer on the sand paper from the diamond size you are using to flatten the plastic). If you use marine ply, good exterior grade ply or seal the whole thing you can just give the vice handle a spin to free it, dip the whole thing a few times in that bucket of rainwater you have next to the driveway and you`re ready to go again.

If you`re cheap like me you could even reuse the ply backings by prying the plastic off, scraping the adhesive off and then sanding the whole thing a bit on that old tablesaw table (another dump find) covered with sandpaper I keep in the corner (used that same 3M spray glue, love that stuff almost as much as the dump) that I use to sand the plastic flat again with.

When things get too grungy or tweaked too far out of whack from all that dipping, being stored in the rainwater bucket, or being left out on the driveway in the rain too often I take it back to where I found it (the dump), debate with a few local power brokers for a bit and then go scout out the pile for replacements to start over again with.

Worth moving to Maine just to gain access to our dumps.

Re: Kanaban - flatness question

#22

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: The "coastal approach"

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Thanks Bob. I plan on giving it a try this weekend (if possible!)

I have some nice 3/4" mdf and ply scraps that'd work perfectly. I even have some 3/4" dowels I turned from osage that'll fit perfectly in the dog holes of my bench.

Pretty much the same arrangement I used for my leather strop

Leather strop