Review of Lee Valley PMV11 Chisel Part 1
Bill Tindall
Review of Lee Valley PMV11 Chisel Part 1
Background- I offer this background to help the reader better put into perspective this review. A bit over 10 years ago a friend and I set about to make a set of chisels. The knife building community and the technical staffs of the steel companies were valuable sources of information for choosing the best steel. I had access to a microscopy laboratory and pictures showing how chisel edges responded in use guided our steel choice. I learned some about steel and edge failure(dulling) for chisels. It became clear that a robust steel was required for a long lasting edge in operations where the chisel is struck with a mallet, for example dovetailing. Paring and carving were less demanding.
At something over $50 each for a premium chisel I am not going to buy a specialized chisel for all the tasks a chisel is called upon to perform. The chisel needs to be a multitasker, performing paring, carving and dovetailing satisfactorily. It is in this context that I am reviewing this chisel. In Part 1 I will discuss the steel and review the chisel for carving and paring, operations where ergonomics is paramount. Later in Part 2, I will review the chisel for chopping out dovetail waste, a task that will challenge the performance of the steel Lee Valley chose.
The Steel. What is PMV11. “PM” steels are steels manufactured using “powder/particle metallurgy”. (Some companies use “particle” and others “powder”, see http://www.crucible.com/eselector/general/generalpart3.html) In a nut shell this manufacturing process enables a steel to be alloyed with beneficial alloying elements to improve performance over simple carbon steel, yet maintain a very fine grain(crystal) structure essential to sharpening to a fine, long lasting edge.
To improve properties such as toughness and abrasion resistance elements such as vanadium, chromium, molybdenum, etc. are added to the iron and carbon found in simple carbon steels. When the melt containing these additives is cooled, slowly because a ton of steel cools slowly, these additives can segregate from the bulk iron melt and grow large crystals(gains) of these elements and their carbides. These elements “do more good” when there are dispersed as tiny crystals(grains).
In the particle process the molten steel is atomized to form a fine powder which cools instantly, precluding the growth of large grains of the alloying elements. The resulting powder is compacted and worked back into a solid bar or sheet of steel. The PM steel process produces steel that has better wear and toughness, superior sharpening and easier fabrication than traditional alloy steels.
Paring and Carving The benefits of the PM steel will be put to the test in Part 2 of this evaluation. However, for paring and carving it is the ergonomics of the chisel that are more critical. (To judge my hand size I wear a size large glove.)

Picture 1 compares the shape of three common chisel types and the Lee Valley chisel. I want to draw your attention to the bolster area and compare this area among the four chisels. The smooth neck in the blade near the bolster and the smooth transition from handle, through the ferrule and then the blade naturally accommodate the shape of the hand in carving and paring as illustrated in Pictures 2 and 3.

Pictures 2 shows a typical hand position when the chisel is used for carving (right handed I must point out), as taught by Mary May, master carver. The left hand is the anchor and the thumb wraps that neck of the blade to provide a comfy pivot point. Everything about the chisel just fits the hand in this operation.
Picture 3 shows a typical hand position when paring. Note that the chisel provides a conforming location for the index finger to “point” the location of the working chisel tip. Alan Batty, master English craftsman, taught me the utility of using the index finger to “point” the direction of tools when paring or using lathe tools. Again the chisel comfortably and naturally conforms to the hand in this position.
For the way I use a chisel for carving and paring the Lee Valley chisel is superior to the other three chisel designs. The handle as received has an unnatural slick feeling compared to the unfinished dogwood handled chisels I am used to. I may eventually roughen the handle a bit. Shortly I will be preparing a set of drawers and I will then be evaluating the Lee Valley chisel for this dovetailing. Stay tuned for Part 2.










