Chopping wide mortises
rononkokomo
Do you guys use firmer chisels for this?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Chopping wide mortises
rononkokomo
Do you guys use firmer chisels for this?
Re: Chopping wide mortises
Darren Brewster
I've done some that were an inch wide with a bevel-edge chisel in pine. First one was pretty rough, but the next was better. The chisel did want to twist on me though. My 1/4" mortise chisel is my only other chisel, so using a bevel-edge was my only choice.
Re: Chopping wide mortises
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Ron
Anything over 1/2" wide and about 3/4" minimum deep in hardwood is just too much work for a mortice or firmer chisel. I then prefer to drill out most of the waste, and clean up with wide paring chisel along the perimeter and a bench or mortice chisel in the centre.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Chopping wide mortises
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
I'd rather make multiple passes with a narrower mortise chisel. Same principle as paring to the scribe line of the pins board in a dovetail joint--don't like to pare the sockets to receive the tails with a wide chisel even though it's right there. If I'm having to use a lot of force, it doesn't feel right, plus stuff can go wrong.
Wiley
Re: Chopping wide mortises
rononkokomo
I watched St. Roy lady night on an episode from season three chop a four inch long by one once wide by three inch mortise on Doug fir pretty speedily. Used what looked to be a 1 inch firmer chisel and a huge honkin mallet. Mortise looked to be very clean with no paring.
Ron
Re:It's not the chisel, it is the hammer
TomD
I have mortising, and temple carpenter chisels up to 1 inch. But a 1 inch chisel needs at least two times the hammer.
That's not a chisel ...!
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
If you think that the Ray Iles mortice chisels are large ...
I have a 1/2" Oval Bolstered mortice chisel (I think it is a Ward). This is a large mother! Even with an equally large hammer I hesitate using it to a depth of 3/4" or greater in some examples of our local hard woods. It would be like slamming into concrete. I already have a tender golfer's elbow I am nursing.
Ward 1/2" with RI 1/4" and Ward 1/4" ...

Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: That's not a chisel ...!
rononkokomo
The one tat Roy used was a firmer chisel. Not a pig sticker.
Re: That's not a chisel! THESE are chisels *LINK*
charlie belden
A while back, Jim Wilson was making REAL mortising chisels and selling them through Steve Knight's wooden (and now infill) hand planes site.
Alas, Jim is no longer making them for sale. The great think about these mortising chisels is the sharp square corners on the bevel - that cut.
While trapezoidal cross section mortising chisels are less apt to bind in a mortise, and rectangular cross section chisels can - once you get the mortise started the rectangular cross section keeps the chisel from wandering.
Jim Wilson on Mortising Chisels
Re: Chopping wide mortises
Bob
I wish I had one of the ones listed here. I just had to do a double through mortise & tenon 3/4" X3 7/8" X3 1/4" I used a regular 25 degree bevel chisel and my hands still hurt.
Re: Chopping wide mortises *LINK*
wilbur

Wiley may not remember, but I asked him about chopping deep 1" wide mortises for my workbench as opposed to taking multiple passes with a narrower mortise chisel. I don't remember exactly what he told me then, but it was along the lines of, "Multiple passes with a narrower chisel would be the easiest way. But if you get your hands on a 1" wide mortise chisel, and chop them all at once, you'll have a great story to tell when you get it done."
So I got one of these.
And chopped:
And wound up with this:
And I have a great story to tell.

More details at the link below.
Chopping 1" wide mortises for my workbench