New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

tenons

Posts

tenons

#1

tenons

wanda

Hi,

What's the best way to cut a tenon by hand. Where do I start the cut? Should I angle the board in the vice? Is that necessary?

If cutting a tenon in 2X pine would it be better to use a panel saw (rip) with coarse teeth rather than a 14" rip tenon a saw (10tpi)? I'm having trouble cutting through that thick a board with my LN 14" tenon saw.

wanda

Re: tenons

#2

Robert Wearing's method

Darren Brewster

I cut them exactly how Robert Wearing writes it in The Essential Woodworker which is to put the wood straight up in the vise and cut a nick in the far corner with a chisel to help start the saw accurately. Starting at that far corner saw across the top about 1/8" deep. Lean the wood away from you and saw down to your shoulder. Flip the wood around and angle it away from you again and saw down to the shoulder once more. This leaves a little triangle of wood inside the tenon. Straighten the wood back up again saw down strait to your shoulder line.

Re: tenons

#3

Re: tenons

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Wanda,

Welcome! Good advice from Darren. Just wanted to add...the basic principle is to saw at an angle such that your saw is following the marks on two faces at the same time, say the marks on the edge facing you and the top. Following the marks on two faces keeps you in the correct plane.

If you do this, it will mean that you're almost never trying to saw through the full width of the board, since you're going in at an angle, and from each side.

The key to sawing is to start right. If you can start a true kerf, that's 80 or 90 percent of the battle. For that reason, unless you're real good with the panel saw, I would at least start my initial headings with the 14" rip.

Are you able to get a good start?

Wiley

Re: tenons

#4

Re: tenons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wanda, we do sometimes use a rip saw rather than a tenon saw to cut larger tenons. It depends on the dimensions of the tenon, the precision desired, the skill of the worker, et cetera. I am a little unsure whether "2X pine" means 1X2 in cross section or 2X6.

Wiley, I don't think following two lines at once is what Darren is suggesting. He says to start at the far side of the top and cut across the top to the depth of 1/8 (1/8 deep all the way across the top). Then, keeping the saw in the kerf, gradually angle down the near side following the near side line. He is then depending on the kerf to keep the far end of the saw aligned while watching just the near line.

Re: tenons

#5

You're right!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Warren,

Wearing does speak to sawing one line at a time. Here's a video of a guy showing the difference:

http://www.renaissancewoodworker.com/wearing-tenon-method/

I don't find the video a model of clarity because he seems to be leaving his starting step out in places, but does get the idea across verbally.

Interesting thing. I use Japanese saws. So that starting from the far side and kerfing across the top to start out is intuitively what you do. From there, you're looking at two faces, so to me it's intuitive to work down both faces at once, with the work piece held vertical. However, my experience with pull saws is neither here nor there with respect to what Wanda is trying to do. So I'll defer to others.

One other point....those following the traditional Japanese way (I am told) will not use a vise as I do, but rather place the work on a bench surface, get down on a knee or two and saw with the saw held more or less vertical, and the bench supporting the work. So my way is not a model for eastern or western traditionalists. Oh well. And it works so well.....

Good catch!

Wiley

Re: tenons

#6

Re: tenons

Darren Brewster

Exactly, Warren. I have only cut a handful of tenons so far (a complete newbie here), but Wearing's methods have allowed my some early successes. I had only cut a couple practice joints before I jumped right in and made two frame and panel doors by hand, and while they aren't perfect, I am pretty proud of them. Much more challenging than cutting dovetails I find.

Re: tenons

#7

Notes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In the video Wiley mentioned, the guy often did not keep the saw in the kerf at the far end of the cut, probably losing a little accuracy. I don't know if he did not know to do it or was just inexperienced. A good sawyer can also do what Wiley suggested, just saw straight down, but it is perhaps also a little less accurate. On most of the period tenons I have seen the saw marks are still visible and they usually did do diagonal sawing.

Re: tenons

#8

What Will Neptune taught

Bill Tindall

Board is vertical in vise. Saw is at an angle with handle lowered. Start cut on near corner. Saw down front side till saw hits bottom of line and winds up about half way across top line. Reverse board in vise and repeat on what was the back side. Toward the end of the cut level the saw to saw out the middle. I was never successful in sawing good tenons before. This technique helped me and others in the class get a more accurate cut.

Some might dismiss this complication of cutting from each side. But when one is learning, or when a tenon is only cut occasionally, anything that makes the process more reliable can be justified.

Re: tenons

#9

Re: What Will Neptune taught

wanda

Hi guys,

I watched the link you posted .. (a video by Shannon rogers) I think I'll try the Wearing method first and see how that goes. I"m used to sawing dovetails by starting on the far side.

As far as the pine goes .... I was referring to a 2" thick board 2"X6" I was having difficulty cutting the tenon for the leg on the saw bench I'm attemting to build. (the Christopher Schwarz saw bench) The 14" tenon saw was struggling to keep a straight line. It was cutting way too slowly. Probably need a larger saw with coarser teeth.

wanda

Re: tenons

#10

Re: tenons

CStanford

Nicking the board to produce a little trough in which the saw can rest, the 'Wearing Method,' in my mind implies a much too deeply gauged line. Deep gauge lines can be the enemy of accuracy in many instances. You need to gauge lightly and simply start sawing at the back of the board (I do agree with Wearing on this) but right beside the line though be aware that this implies a pretty fussy, at first, setting of the mortise gauge right on the corners of the chisel.

If you are practically plowing a grooves with the mortise gauge you're going to find your tenons either way to fat or too sloppy, rarely dead on.

These gauges need to merely produce a nice, fine, scratched line that is left in its entirety when the sawing is finished.

Re: tenons

#11

Why the back of the board

Bill Tindall

Everyone I know except me saws dovetails front to back. Why would tenons be done the other way around?

Re: tenons

#12

2 of us

rononkokomo

I start all cuts from the back and track all cuts back toward me.

Re: tenons

#13

.??

rononkokomo

Lots of folks teach to bisect the line.

Re: tenons

#14

Re: tenons

rononkokomo

I thought you were supposed to bisect the line?

Re: tenons

#15

Re: Why the back of the board

CStanford

Because the straight hang of tenon saws makes starting a cut on the back easier - tenons, housings, halvings, etc.

Re: tenons

#16

Re: .??

CStanford

You don't want to lose your signposts when fitting the joint. If the gauge setting matches the sawing then the joint will fit right off the saw (rare for me) If all errors are fat to the line then you have a definite mark to trim to, the lightly gauged line (lightly is key). If you gauge heavily and err fat, you might need to trim into the middle of the line or all the way to the other side of the ditch you created when you marked out (depends on the gauge setting to the chisel) and it's easy to lose your way or at least it is for me.

Gauged lines mark the boundary, they are not part of the boundary, everything up to and including the mark is the good wood. It's so logical. You have a mark to trim to (but is never consumed in any way) that you can always count on.

It is no different with an incised line, as long as it was incised with a single-beveled knife/cutter/chisel, etc. - the straight wall left by the cutter's incision marks the wood to be kept. The bevel is always in the waste for an incised line.

Re: tenons

#17

Darrell in Oakville

Re: tenons

Darrell in Oakville

"Splitter!!" (Monty Python's Life Of Brian)

Here I am, once again the odd man out.

I will quite often split off the waste from my tenons with a wide chisel or a spare plane iron instead of sawing. Clean up the cheeks with a paring chisel afterward. Since most of us choose clear straight grained woods for the frame and reserve the crazy grain for the panel this trick usually works.

Darrell

waiting for everyone else to get out of bed so I can get to work in the shop...

Re: tenons

#18

Stephen Shepherd

I split my tenons too

Stephen Shepherd

Even in hardwoods it is much easier to split off the waste and not spend time sawing. After cutting the shoulder, I go to school on the grain and sneak up to the score line. Flat wide chisel and occasionally a rebate plane, but most times it is fine off the chisel.

Leaves the joint rough enough to get good hide glue contact.

I do sometimes saw very small tenons.

Stephen

Re: tenons

#19

Re: tenons

CStanford

Whether or not you split the line depends, and solely I might add, on how you set your gauge off the mortise chisel that will be used to chop the mortise.

Re: tenons

#20

Re: tenons

Darren Brewster

I have split my tenons for the first time recently. The first one wasn't great (I think I messed it up when I was pairing it after splitting). The second one came out surprisingly well. This was for a bench. I'm not sure if I trust myself enough for something fancier in a piece of furniture.

Re: tenons

#21

Re: What Will Neptune taught

CStanford

Your intincts are right - too fine and too small a saw is the enemy of accuracy.

If you arleady cut dovetails starting on the back arris then do the same for tenons.

Re: tenons

#22

Re: What Will Neptune taught

wanda

Hi guys,

after trying a few of the methods mentioned here on the forum I think I will try cutting my tenons the same way I cut my dovetails. I will start the cut on the back keeping the wood vertical in the vice. Isn't that how Rob Cosman cuts his tenons?

wanda

Re: tenons

#23

Re: Bite into the easy part

Bruce McCrory

I start on the front, but use a pull saw. So, I think we are in-synch.