New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

Posts

To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#1

To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

Paul Erickson

I am at the glue up stage with the base for my new workbench. For budget and other reasons, the base is made of Fir, and I am wondering if I should put a finish on it, and if so what? I have seen many discussions about what finish to use on the bench top, but so far have found no discussions about what to do with the base. I can think of reasons to finish and reasons not to, but would appreciate hearing others thoughts and experiences.

Thanks in advance.

cheers, Paul

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#2

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base qu

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You seem to be asking the question of function, rather than appearance.

I suppose if you live in an area of extreme, rapid humidity swings, a finish might slow down the absorption/release of moisture and reduce the chance of warping.

And fir can be splintery; a film finish will help control those splinters that can spring off the surface and attack you.

Otherwise, I'm not sure that a finish does much in this setting.

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#3

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base qu

wilbur

My workbench is made out of Douglas fir. I didn't use any finish on it at all. As far as I can tell, that was a perfectly good decision.

There's no need to apologize for using fir in a workbench, either. It's a perfectly good wood for a workbench.

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#4

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base qu

CStanford

Linseed oil would be nice. Buy four of the cheap throwaway roasting pans. Pour a little linseed oil in the bottom of each pan. Put each leg in a pan. Leave until it wicks all the oil up the legs. Finish the rest of the base with BLO in the normal manner.

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#5

Good call, especially in a basement shop.


Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#6

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base qu

TomD

If it was mine, I would probably use a finish with some build like a Maloof oil and varnish finish, or a straight varnish. I don't like straight oil on softwoods, but I haven't tried them on D-Fir either. The main reason I would finish the base would be to make dust easier to remove, and generally keep the surface clean. My current bench started out with metal legs, as I was recovering from an accident and could not get up the energy to make them out of wood. Eventually it got a Poplar base, that like some softwoods, is a little soft for oil, but testing showed it would work, so it got some industrial furniture oil I needed to use up. The can had rusted and the finish essentially stained. But the point is that the tests showed it would work, and that is what I ended up using, even though I don't keep stain around the place, for the most part. So regardless of what you decide, I would certainly run a test piece first. If the top of a bench were D-Fir, I would leave it raw.

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#7

the dual role of finish

Bill Tindall

Finish protects the wood and enhances appearance. Once you decide whether you want, or need, these two attributes your choice of whether to finish and how to finish will be obvious.

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#8

Re: the dual role of finish

Patrick Gibbons

My bench is about 10 years old and the base is made of Douglas fir. I finished it with tung oil and it has held up nicely. It still looks great. I think it would be just as good if I didn't finish it.

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#9

Re: Fir (?) being DF

Bruce McCrory

Doug Fir is one of the finer working woods. My in-laws had a DF bench built of 2x4 framing that developed a fine, smooth patina at rub points. It also can nick and splinter.

White built a masterpiece of economy in Doug Fir that showed up in several Fine WW bench articles. The various timeframes were well documented by shades of grime build-up, which proved someone used it. I don't know what finish will reduce adhesion of glue or stain and paint that you may encounter and not want.

Hemlock, DF's first cousin, is less strong and does like to splinter, hiding stilettos openly. I have fought with that problem in our trim for years. I want to think a finish, or paint minimizes splinter growth in hemlock.

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#10

bench cover

Bill Tindall

I regard a sheet of Masonite on my multitasking bench top a must. I replace it every few years.

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#11

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base qu

Paul M.

I built my first large cabinetry bench with a doug fir base. I finished the base in some glossy varnish. It looks pretty, but it was entirely unnecessary.

I'm almost done building my second dedicated guitar bench (much smaller to fit into my small humidity controlled work room). It has a western red cedar base, and I do not plan to finish it this time around. It just doesn't seem necessary.

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base questi

#12

Re: To finish or not to finish a workbench base qu

Paul Erickson

Thanks everyone for the input. I have decided to go with a BLO/Varnish/Turpentine mix. I want to minimize dimensional change due to humidity changes and to prevent the splinter growth and well as ease of keeping things clean. Thanks again for the time and attention.

cheers, Paul