On choosing a glue
Bill Tindall
I know of shops of impeccable reputation as well as individuals that build stuff rivaling these shops. Among these possibilities there are craftsmen using each of the common glues- white, yellow, liquid and regular hide. It is a testimony that any of these glues can be successfully employed in skilled hands to make lasting furniture. In this sense no choice is better than another and once one becomes experienced with any choice there is little incentive to change. Yet each has advantages and disadvantages that the experienced shops and individuals have learned to deal with, yet the less experienced person should carefully consider. It is the less experienced that this post is directed to.
For the reasons enumerated in the previous post I mainly use yellow glue. So long as each surface is wet with sufficiently wet glue and clamping pressure is sufficient it is nearly fool proof in edge joinery. Its quick tack means that panels can be typically worked within an hour. The rubbery squeeze-out is easily removed so long as it is removed while it is still rubbery. And, like all these glues the adhesive is stronger than wood. For simple mortise and tenon joints, for example a table, I use the yellow glue because there are data that shows it to yield a stronger joint than the hide glues. However, for complex assemblies its fast tack leads to stressful assemblies.
For example,

In this chest of drawers there are 24 of these housed dovetail joints, 12 glued M&T joints for front of the runners and 12 dry M&T joints for the back of the runners. Furthermore, if the housed dovetails wind up perfectly flush with the case side there is less fiddling with a hand plane to get the face in one perfect plane. I have assembled such a case with yellow glue but it is vastly less stressful doing it with liquid hide glue.
Yellow glue tacks quickly so one must proceed quickly to locate the drawer divider perfectly flush with the case side. In contrast, liquid hide glue is very slow to tack and it acts like grease on a joint, enabling it to slide together smoothly, something beneficial when the goal is perfect alignment. The long set time of a liquid hide joint means the case can be coaxed into square if it doesn't naturally wind up that way.
Because case assembly is something that is predictably planned the preparation time for hot hide glue is really not a significant disadvantage. However, I believe that the the learning curve to use it is significant and hence seeing no advantage for it I have never tried it.



