We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
OK, so what's the best way to sharpen a knife? I mean just a good pen knife. (T1 steel -- any good?) I have a Tormec, but I suspect that it may be only the first step. I have various stones, too; diamond DMTs and Nortons. And I sometimes use a hard felt wheel at high speed with the green stuff or the white stainless steel stuff for honing; but I fear dubbing it over this way. I think it's more difficult to do than a chisel or a plane iron because of its curved shape --even though I have that Tormec knife-holder.
Here's what I arrived at, after years of being a dissatisfied pocket knife sharpener....
1. Don't pussyfoot around, trying to finesse an edge on the knife. First, take it to a coarse stone--I use a 400g diamond stone, but no reason why any other coarse stone wouldn't do just fine.
2. Put a long, low bevel on it. The included angle on your knife will be double the bevel you put on each side. If you think 25 degrees is a nice low angle, remember the knife will end up with an included angle of 50 degrees. Compare with 25-30 degrees included angle on your plane and chisel blades. I shoot for an eyeballed 15 degrees each side.
3. Work fast and vigorously initially, pulling the blade toward you down the side of the stone, and rotating as required at the end of each stroke to cover the curved portions of main blade and spey blade. Turn knife over and at same low angle, push away the length of the stone's side.
4. Now go through as many finer grits as you like, doing same as above. Depends on how much tooth you do or don't want on the knife.
5. Be careful with stropping, so as not to round over the low angle. For what a knife does, I don't think stropping is needed, since a little tooth doesn't hurt things. But to strop, I suggest a wooden strop, using powder or diamond. For me, ultimate edge is LV 0.3 micron green paper on a hard surface (for all blades, actually).
6. To renew edge, I don't usually strop, because I inevitably steepen the angle reaching for more sharpness. Instead, go back to final stone or second to last stone.
I just bought a Lansky sharpening jig last week for putting a consistent bevel on my knives. It works pretty well. It doesn't really do anything that someone with a consistent hand can't do, but unlike a chisel or plane blade, a pocket knife bevel isn't long enough to be able to feel when you've got it seated properly on the stone. This jig does just that.
My first try was a complete success, but it wasn't a complete sharpening, though. The finest stone that comes with the basic kit might be about 800 or 1000 grit, and it's simply not enough to get a truly good edge. Lansky sells a finer grit for not much more, maybe $10 or so, but I found that if I just stropped the knife a few times on leather charged with green compound, the edge was very good. I got mine on sale for about $27.
"Best" is a really difficult concept to get everybody's mind wrapped around at the same time. Or, to paraphrase Yoda, "There is no best, there is only do."
I'll tell you what works for me, and I can show you the bloody band-aid wrapped around the end of my finger where a recently honed paring knife slipped last night while peeling and pitting peaches. The knife didn't slip, nor did the hand holding the knife, but peaches are really slick.*
To this end, I use one of these (reference the link). An extra fine card is not where you start, if someone abused the knife when you weren't watching, but for maintenance, touch-ups and restoring an edge to service, it works fine. Perhaps most important is having effective sharpening tools near at hand wherever and whenever the knife might need sharpening. I don't keep it in the same pocket as the knife, for obvious reasons, but it's always in my wallet, and it takes up no room. If you tend to take hunks out of your knives while you are using them, you can slip a coarse card in right next to the extra fine card. This strategy also keeps sharpening media out of the kitchen cabinets, where someone with else might use them to abuse an edge that you'd spent a lot of time on. If I'm away demoing somewhere, or sharpening someone else's turning tools, they always go straight from the low speed grinder to the card before I return them to their owner. I'll even use it for chisels and plane irons. The only problem there is making sure it's flat, as it's easy to bend it in your back pocket, especially if you're jockeying a fork lift moving heavy iron. Of course, it's just as easy to straighten out again, if you know to look for the problem. In the kitchen, I lubricate it and clean it up with a little soap and water; if in someone else's shop or classroom, I can usually find some WD-40 or mineral spirits.
You don't need to buy it from Woodcraft, and if EZE-Lap has an equivalent multi-crystaline plate, you might want to carry one of those instead. And, don't believe Woodcraft's ad copy about "utmost," as there's always room for improvement by honing the blade on some leather. Since my wallet is nylon and velcro, not leather, I can't hone with it, so I use the palm of my hand, but hopefully not immediately after unpacking a carton full of sandpaper or wrestling a pallet from China onto the back of someone's pickup truck. Contamination, no matter where you find it, tends to leave deep scratches in the blade.
TSA has never asked me about them yet, even though it would be really quick to use the coarse plate to convert the extra-fine plate into a shiv.
* Another recommendation: 3M Nexcare waterproof bandages. If you are bleeding all over the place and dripping peroxide on the floor, they still stick, and you can apply them with one hand.
I free-hand mine on the Tormek, and use it right off the leather honing wheel. It's shaveable sharp, and pocket knives (mine, at least) seldom hold their edges for long, given the varied substances they're used to cut.
I've used oil stones, water stones, ceramics, and the Lansky and SpyderCo jigs/fixtures with success, but the Tormek is quicker, easier, and does just as good a job.
I've had mine for 20 or so years now. Keep it in the living room and resharpen my pocket knives while lounging on the recliner. It's fast,easy to set up and consistent.---Jack
Thanks to all. And to William, it actually turns out that I have one of these credit card diamond stones; I just never thought about using it to sharpen my knife!
FWIW: I've fallen in love with my 1 x 42 belt sander. Surgisharp leather belt from LV with green crayon or Trizact belts for mangled edges. Best edges in town. Kitchen knives are just done on a 3 wheel ChefsChoice machine.
The thing that has restored the edge on my knives the most over the years are crock sticks, The Spyderco trueangle, or the the Gatco. These will get a commercial knife that has micro bevels back to razor sharpness without messing up the geometry or look of the knife. And they are dummy proof, yet work well enough that a serious user can be happy with them.
Most knives are sharpened somewhere around and angle of 45 degrees, or 22.5 a side. There are all kinds of knives, and yeah, that is pretty obtuse. But if you grind a commercial knife much lower you may wreak or mar them, or at least be regrinding them. Of course eyeball the edge to be sure it is at that angle, and conform to whatever you find.
Most knifemakers sharpen on a belt grinder, and I have both 1x42, and 2x72 units with appropriate paper, you can even get leather or cork belts to buff out edges. Belts are great for convex edges, while most modern knives are hollow ground, and have micro bevels. Sharpening on crock sticks is fast enough, and if you don't have the touch it will be a lot safer for the knife, not to mention you can throw a knife around approaching some belts from the wrong side. Belts are great though, when people learn you can sharpen a knife and give you 10 of their dull as a 2x4 knives with edges so rounded it would take a month to refresh them on a crock set-up. Couple of seconds on a grinder and they are dangerous to all who use them. Some of the Crock set-ups like the Gatco, any that have multiple stones I guess, will handle some rough grinding, but nothing speeds it up like a belt.
Stones can be used freehand if you really want, and they have a wide variety of stones available.
When the time comes to sharpen anything with an exotic steel, if you need to re-work the primary bevel, any time you feel like it's going to be a chore, Lansky's the way to go.
My everyday work knife is made from D2. Damn near bulletproof, but when it needs work, it needs a lot of work. So, I put on a DVD, and pull out the jig. It means I don't have to pay attention for the entire hour that the task inevitably requires.
Yeah, it's an old Benchmade, with a 4" blade. It's a tank.
I typically use the regular lansky stones, charged with diamond paste. It makes for pretty quick work. Messy, but quick. I can get a good edge, it just takes time... And it rapidly degrades from there to 'pretty good,' and stays there for a while.
A couple years back I bought an updated version of the same model in M4. MUCH less time to sharpen. Holy crap.
I would sharpen it on stones if you have a medium stone aggressive enough. Just like you would sharpen a razor, but lift the spine a little.
If quick counted, on a belt grinder with a platen and a trizact belt, followed either by a quick touchup by hand on a finish stone, or some belt loaded with compound.
A nicked blade on a cheap belt grinder should be completely polished, stropped sharp and nick free in about 2 minutes. If you want it that sharp.