(Message Deleted by Poster)
(Message Deleted by Poster)
#1
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: The 'feel' of polycrystalline diamond stones
Steve Elliott
What do you use as a lubricant on polycrystalline diamond stones? I've just ordered the 600 grit Eze-Lap.
My experience with coarse DMT stones was the same as yours and I haven't bought a new fixed diamond stone in many years.
Re: The 'feel' of polycrystalline diamond stones
Marhk
These comments about diamond stones poly vs. mono are interesting and relevant to my experience as well.
I have used Norton polycrystalline stones for years. They continue to work well even as I go back and forth to other media. I seem to end up back at the Nortons. Interestingly the size is exactly the same as the Eze-Lap stones. I wonder who makes what? I also agree that the mono type diamond stones don't seem to continue to perform as well over time. Although I can feel a difference between the types in use, I'm not sure I can express the difference. No doubt this is topical as we begin to move to harder steels.
Lubricant for diamond plates
Bill Tindall
This discussion came up at the EzeLap booth. I use a 1:10 dilution of water based machine tool cutting fluid. Works sweet. I keep it in a spray bottle by the sharpening stuff. It was agreed at the booth that a bit of detergent in water does well too.
Personally, I prefer the "extra fine" 15 micron plate.
Re: Lubricant for diamond plates
Marhk
The Trend people make a lapping fluid for use with their diamond stones. I use it. I like it. I have no idea what's in it. It does seem to keep the stone from clogging. BTW, the Trend double-sided stone (300/1000) isn't half bad. But same problem: mono diamonds. I bought one to carry. So far hasn't dulled too much. I like the Nortons better.
Re: The 'feel' of polycrystalline diamond stones
david weaver
I, too, like the polycrystalline stones better. I don't have any really good ones, just a pair of $45 combo plates that are copies of the koyama iwood plates that I got several years ago. Both of them are still cutting well, despite the fact that the aggression is long gone. The worn one (one that I used a lot, and hard) is now in the kitchen where the 1000 side is just the perfect tool for keeping knives in the kitchen sharp. It still cuts fast enough to sharpen knives the way I like to sharpen them, which is just freehand leading with the bevel side pushing into the stone instead of pulling.
That is as sharp as my wife will tolerate the knives. Like many, she grew up in a household where sharp knives were seen as dangerous and most of the knives left were barely functional. I've never been able to change that.
Anyway, I got more use out of my poly stones than I did out of my DMT combo. If I had the need to get another one (which I probably will not), I'd probably go with the ezlap stone.
Re: The 'feel' of polycrystalline diamond stones
wilbur
The feel of diamond stones is exactly why I don't like using them. For me, I get that "fingernails on a blackboard" feeling whenever I've used diamond abrasives to sharpen tools. That's enough for me to prefer waterstones, even if I lose the benefit of having a surface that will stay flat in use when sharpening.
The best sharpening system is the one you will use often.
Re: The 'feel' of polycrystalline diamond stones
bridger
I have been using a spray bottle with alcohol to lube diamond stones in the shop. it feels a little wetter than water, cleans up very well and leaves no residue. it dries fast, which is a disadvantage, and has an odor which I'm not fond of. it does seem to perform well.
for on site sharpening I use the diamond stones dry.
Bridger