New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Think diamonds are exotic material?

Posts

Think diamonds are exotic material?

#1

Think diamonds are exotic material?

Bill Tindall

Had a nice chat at the Eze Lap booth. They were selling polycrystaline 3 x 12" diamond sharpening plates for $60. I could have gotten an 8" plate from a Chinese vendor for $25. In quantity single crystal diamond sells for 3 cents a carat while the faster cutting, longer lasting polycrystalline is 10 cents. The cost of the diamond on our sharpening products is almost insignificant.

There is no technical reason to prevent plates with particles smaller than 15 micron (extra fine) from being made. The EzeLap person didn't know there was any market for a finer product.

Diamond coated cutters were prevalent at IWF. Edge life over carbide is 100 fold!

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#2

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material? *LINK*

William Duffield

Exotic, and hard, doesn't stop with polycrystaline diamond. If you follow the links in some of the comments to the linked article, it gets even more interesting.

Of course, right now, crushing fullerenes between diamond anvils yields only one bit of grit at a time, so it is sure to be a while before Joel starts carrying stones made from anything like this.


New Form of Carbon

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#3

mono vs poly

ebushee

I'm curious as to the differences in monocrystalline vs polycrystalline diamonds. DMT, for example, has spent a considerable amount of time and effort to convince us that monocrystalline diamonds are more durable, more expensive to properly make, and overall better for sharpening tools. Respected dealers have parroted their claims. Then I read things from polycrystalline users that state the exact opposite. Is there really a noticeable difference in performance between a 600-grit monocrystalline and polycrystalline diamond stone?

(my apologies if this is an old subject that's already been addressed here)

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#5

After your discussion with the Eze-lap guy,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

do they now understand there is a need for finer grit products?

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#6

I wonder......

Bill Tindall

if the reports of poor abrasive life for diamond "stones"/plates is a result of using monocrystaline diamond sparsely coated on expanded metal substrate? In contrast I am using a continuously coated polycrystalline plate and it is still doing good as new after several years of use.

The EzeLap person lectured a potential buyer that a new plate needed "breaking in". When that aggressive initial feel matures into a slower more uniform abrasion it does not mean the plate is dull. It means it is broken in and will continue to deliver its current performance for much longer.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#7

EzeLap and the wood working community

Bill Tindall

We have only recently been discovered. He talked of being at some show where some famous English furniture maker was lecturing and in the lecture mentioned that he used diamond sharpening. The EzeLap person was surprised to find the woodworkers exiting the lecture and heading to his booth to buy plates.

At IWF his booth was mobbed by persons buying EzeLap diamond products and it was hard for me to engage in a conversation with any continuity. In fact he was sold out of 12" plates well before the show ended. I am not optimistic he recognizes the need.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#8

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#9

Diamonds are forever

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... not. Or so I keep telling Lynndy. :)

I have faith in one and only one diamond plate I own - an Eze-lap 6x2, which I think is a 600 grit (but behaves like a 2000). This is 10 years old and still going strong. By contrast, a DMT 10" Coarse plate lasted about 12 months.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#10

David, have you used ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... the Superfine (1200 grit) and the others in the range (Medium and Coarse)? If so, what do you think of them?

I think we all fantasise about finding a sharpening medium that requires minimal maintenance, is capable of working on all steel types ... and lasts forever. This is the appeal of diamond stones. The reality is that diamonds wear and some makes wear more than others. My experience with DMTs is not encouraging. Diamond paste is an alternative, but has the disadvantage of needing to be recharged quite frequently at this end of the spectrum. The diamond mesh sold by Lee Valley is superb, but it is to be treated carefully.

Is there a diamond plate that is reliable in the coarser grits?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#11

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#12

Let me try this again ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, thanks for your detailed response. My apologies, but I was not clear in what I was asking.

It is the coarse end of the spectrum that creates the most difficulty when sharpening. The coarse end, in my opinion, is the most important area. It is not the glamourous side of sharpening - the 16000 waterstones, 0.1 micron diamond grit, and diamond sprays hold this honour - but they are merely the way we finish the process. Where and how we start the journey paves the way for all that follows. An out-of-flat 1000 waterstone can do a lot of damage. It is very difficult to abuse a blade on a 16000 grit.

Consequently I am always searching for the perfect coarse medium. Coarse waterstones tend to wear rapidly (they must do so to open fresh grit). Coarse diamonds seem a way to go, however I have been disillusioned by the short life span of DMTs, and that is why I asked about the Eze-lap. Diamond paste appears to have promise, and it was this that I referred to as needing frequent replenishment (the higher grits, by comparison, appear to last a much longer time).

What is a coarse grit? I was looking at something for lapping the backs of vintage blades. That would need to be in the 45 micron range. In the choices offered by Eze-lap, the coarse is around that area.

What next? The 600 grit is about 25 microns (that confuses me because it does not act like this). It acts like it was about 10 microns (which makes more sense to me). Still, if we go by grit ratings, then the wonderful "fine" may actually not have a place to play (unless we view it as equivalent to 10 microns). Why so?

I think a good rule of thumb is to follow the diamond lapping film spacings offered by Lee Valley. I worked with them on these, and so I know they work to create the most efficient jumps between grits. The grits go from 15 micron to 3 to 0.5 to 0.1 microns.

Using these as the rule, the extra fine Eze-lap (9 microns) fits in after the fine, and then one can go directly to either green compound, a 16000 waterstone, or 0.5 lapping film.

So back to the orignal question: how reliable is the coarse Eze-cut diamond stone, or could you recommend something else in this range? We both like the Fine, and yet the ratings do not seem to fit in with our experience of this diamond stone, so which is the better choice, it or the super fine?

Its late at night and I am not sure how clear I am sounding, but I must answer your post now, or lose the momentum.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#13

Benchmark for back flattening

Bill Tindall

Benchmark: One evening Phil Smith and I flattened 30+ chisels and plane blade backs. The steel was highly abrasion resistant CPM 3V and the tools were as received from the heat treating shop, which means they required considerable flattening. We used a Makita horizontal(flat) wheel with water lubrication for the rough flattening and finished up with diamond plates.

Personally I find that the coarser diamond grits work better embedded in acryllic(Plexiglas), lubed with glycol/water mixture I have done a bit of flattening by this route. But removing much metal from a relatively large surface by hand grinding is going to be slow no matter the route chosen.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#14

Derek...

Schtoo

Here's a little tid-bit of information you might find interesting...

Diamonds frustrate me. Not just a little bit. Frustrated enough to make my daughter cry with my shortened temper.

I'm sure they work really well, and it must be something I am or am not doing.

Every single time I read about them working so well, I pull out my own diamond gear (I've got lots of it) and give it another try, and then put it all away again swearing.

If I can crack the problem, I'd be really happy.

Sorry I can't be of more use, and no this is not a case of sour grapes at all. I'm sure they must work really well, but for the life of me I just can't manage to make them work for me.

Stu.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#15

Re: Derek...

TomD

I consider most of the diamond stones I have bought to be cases were I would rather have the money back. There is one wheel I got for cheap that so far has proven very useful when limited to grinding carbide as suggested. And I like the paste. But the stones I do not consider worth the trouble. And there are so many alternatives that I would reach for first. Power grinding is the solution to 21st century sharpening, and will open up so many avenues in hand tool making. And as far as sharpening tools is concerned there are many cheaper and satisfactory options.

This is just my experience. I could get by handily with my King stones from the 80s, or scary sharp. It is like the guy with one gun, learn something well, whatever you choose.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#16

Re: Let me try this again ..

TomD

To me hand tools does not mean hand tool only, but then there are tools like my Japanese tools that rarely see anything other than their matched stones. But I am secure enough, and busy enough, in my hand tool use that it isn't a game for me. Sometimes I need to get er done. Just like the folks who are making the tools that people are subsequently handling in possibly quaint terms.

I agree about the coarse, which extends to the tools themselves also. Get some chips flying. If you really are up against the clock getting stuff flat etc... power is the way to go. There are grinders out there that will swallow a whole blade in a moments inattention, and they will flatten or rough flatten your blades in seconds.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#17

Re: David, have you used ...

david weaver

Derek, I'm not the right David, but I think you'll find that in the long run, if you're flattening something, you'll want to go with the ceramic stones and not the diamond hones. IME, they are never that long lasting rubbing the backs of anything with pressure.

I always start with 100 grit diamond on a kanaban if I need something really coarse, and a holder so I can apply pressure.

After that, I go straight to any 1000 grit (claimed) stone. shapton pro with slurry is very fast, so's any stone. The shapton pro, bester 1200 and stu's hardest 1200 offering are all good, you've tried all of them I'm sure.

I've never had a diamond hone in the 1000 grit range that gave me a long term good feeling.

However, after all of that work is done, the marginalized speed of a diamond hone to work on the bevels is just fine, they should never need that much work, anyway, unless someone is trying to exclude the grinder on purpose (something I would never do) and work work large areas.

Grit contamination from loose diamonds in the 25 grit range is real, it's nicer to use loose diamonds only for the final step as part of a regular honing routine, where they can't really contaminate anything due to their fineness.

I don't think you're going to find a good long term solution that is actually flat enough in diamonds in the 1000 grit range. Even if you go to 1000 grit loose diamonds, you're still going to have to make sure you wipe them and their lubricant off of everything before you go to a next step.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#18

Well, what is the problem exactly?

John in NM

If you're using bonded plates I can see the limited life being a problem, and having them cut a lot slower than you expect. I'd no idea for example, that eze laps didn't seem to share this fault.

If you're using paste or loose grit on some kind of plate I'm curious what the problem could be.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#19

Re: Well, what is the problem exactly?

Schtoo

What was the problem?

Lack of speed. Not much more than that I suppose.

When I was flattening the back, it would work well initially, then taper off as swarf built up. Didn't seem to matter with more or less diamond, more or less pressure or whatnot. Nothing seemed to bring it back, other then clearing the mess and starting again.

(And mess is a relative term. I find the paste to be horrifically messy. Maybe it's the stuff I have, water based, sticky and nasty.)

Too much fooling around to keep the ball rolling for my liking I'm afraid.

As I said, it's probably me more than anything and I blame being both familiar with stones and having good stones to get the job done.

(I also have the luxury of a horizontal wet grinder, but don't always use it because not everyone has one and I need to know what will work for folks who don't have nor want one of them.)

I'll keep at it, I want to get that nugget cracked and worked out.

Just kind of frustrated with them I suppose.

If I had crap stones, then I can see where diamonds are better than them already.

It's not too big an ask to be better than a soft, mushy crap stone though, is it?

Stu.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#20

Coarse grits are tricky

John in NM

They don't really show diamond's advantages due to mechanical crushing effects generally not seen with the finer grits. I've only used coarse (320 grit, ~30 micron) on stone, for which one makes an oil/diamond slurry that gets spread on a copper lap and pressed in with a ball bearing on a stick. It cuts aggressively for 30 minutes or so, and acceptably fast for another few hours before needing a recharge.

Now how this applies to chisels? No idea really, but I would say you'll get better results with a plate that the diamond can be pressed into, like copper or tin (and these days that's a pretty pricey option). Having the grit rolling around on the plate knocks the sharp corners off that much faster, though it does seem to be limited to coarser grits.

Re: Think diamonds are exotic material?

#21

Re: Well, what is the problem exactly?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What was the problem?

Lack of speed. Not much more than that I suppose.

When I was flattening the back, it would work well initially, then taper off as swarf built up. Didn't seem to matter with more or less diamond, more or less pressure or whatnot. Nothing seemed to bring it back, other then clearing the mess and starting again.

(And mess is a relative term. I find the paste to be horrifically messy. Maybe it's the stuff I have, water based, sticky and nasty.)

Too much fooling around to keep the ball rolling for my liking I'm afraid.

As I said, it's probably me more than anything and I blame being both familiar with stones and having good stones to get the job done.

(I also have the luxury of a horizontal wet grinder, but don't always use it because not everyone has one and I need to know what will work for folks who don't have nor want one of them.)

I'll keep at it, I want to get that nugget cracked and worked out.

Just kind of frustrated with them I suppose.

If I had crap stones, then I can see where diamonds are better than them already.

It's not too big an ask to be better than a soft, mushy crap stone though, is it?

Hi Stu.

Notwithstanding David's comment below (which is very relevant), my experience accords exactly with yours.

In my experience, the coarse diamond paste that I have used (45 microns) cuts so slowly that I lose patience with it. I keep wanting to, and often do, recharge it because it seems to have given up the cutting ghost. However it actually is cutting and no matter if I renew the paste or add more (actually I think that that is a problem), it does not cut faster.

My method of use: I spread paste over the caste iron (I use old plane soles), rub it in as best as possible, pressing it down with a blade, then wipe down both blade and surface. I am interested in the inbedded diamond, not the loose diamond. Neither way is faster, but I am concerned that the latter method may wear the substratum.

I use oil-based paste ... and it is just as messy. Black goo! Yuck.

This is why I asked about diamond plates. I really do not view them with optimism. I do not, however, have a power method for blade backs that I trust. My belt sander will leave undulations and round off edges. It creates work I have to undo by hand.

In the end I work the backs on waterstones, but the coarsest I have are a 1000 Shapton Pro and a 1200 Sigma. The Sigma (10 micron) is almost as quick as the 45 micron diamond paste!

Regards from Perth

Derek