Let me try this again ..
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
David, thanks for your detailed response. My apologies, but I was not clear in what I was asking.
It is the coarse end of the spectrum that creates the most difficulty when sharpening. The coarse end, in my opinion, is the most important area. It is not the glamourous side of sharpening - the 16000 waterstones, 0.1 micron diamond grit, and diamond sprays hold this honour - but they are merely the way we finish the process. Where and how we start the journey paves the way for all that follows. An out-of-flat 1000 waterstone can do a lot of damage. It is very difficult to abuse a blade on a 16000 grit.
Consequently I am always searching for the perfect coarse medium. Coarse waterstones tend to wear rapidly (they must do so to open fresh grit). Coarse diamonds seem a way to go, however I have been disillusioned by the short life span of DMTs, and that is why I asked about the Eze-lap. Diamond paste appears to have promise, and it was this that I referred to as needing frequent replenishment (the higher grits, by comparison, appear to last a much longer time).
What is a coarse grit? I was looking at something for lapping the backs of vintage blades. That would need to be in the 45 micron range. In the choices offered by Eze-lap, the coarse is around that area.
What next? The 600 grit is about 25 microns (that confuses me because it does not act like this). It acts like it was about 10 microns (which makes more sense to me). Still, if we go by grit ratings, then the wonderful "fine" may actually not have a place to play (unless we view it as equivalent to 10 microns). Why so?
I think a good rule of thumb is to follow the diamond lapping film spacings offered by Lee Valley. I worked with them on these, and so I know they work to create the most efficient jumps between grits. The grits go from 15 micron to 3 to 0.5 to 0.1 microns.
Using these as the rule, the extra fine Eze-lap (9 microns) fits in after the fine, and then one can go directly to either green compound, a 16000 waterstone, or 0.5 lapping film.
So back to the orignal question: how reliable is the coarse Eze-cut diamond stone, or could you recommend something else in this range? We both like the Fine, and yet the ratings do not seem to fit in with our experience of this diamond stone, so which is the better choice, it or the super fine?
Its late at night and I am not sure how clear I am sounding, but I must answer your post now, or lose the momentum.
Regards from Perth
Derek