New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

Posts

Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#1

Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

Bill Tindall



At IWF Atlanta I came upon Excalibur, the legendary chisel forged of PM V11 steel, embedded in a block of solid Canadian maple. It was guarded by a Veritas troll.

Only one smitten by the magical powers of modern steel and devoted to the higher calling of chopping dovetails had any chance of withdrawing the blade and claiming it for the Kingdom of their shop. (the troll hinted that taking advantage of the show special of free shipping on catalog items would increase my strength, which would increase in proportion to how much I took advantage of the offer)

Fortified by a large purchase and a promise of pampering Excalibur with diamonds, even though the legend revealed it was not essential to pamper with diamonds, my hand withdrew the chisel from its sanctum.

First impressions:


This picture shows the relative size compared to two other common chisels. This 1/2" size weighs 114 grams, only 10% more than the very light weight comparable chisel I made for dovetailing tasks. Grasped near its bevel it will be readily moved about and precisely located for dovetailing operations. The handle will suit me fine for paring. My chisels are required to be multitaskers.

Testing: I am about to make drawers for a chest of drawers. I will sharpen Excalibur equivalent to my home made chisel made from extremely tough CPM 3V particle steel. I will alternate chopping out dovetails with the two chisels and compare the experience. Stay tuned.

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#2

Ultra high carbon steel

Patrick Gibbons

Roselli knives made in Finland use ultra high carbon steel with a 1.5% to 2% carbon content and hardened to Rc 64-66. I've wondered if anyone knows something more about this and if it would be useful in woodworking applications.

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#3

Re: Ultra high carbon steel

Bill Tindall

There is Japanese cutlery steel that is similar. By all accounts it performs excellently for plane blades and chisels when the forging and heat treating are done precisely by a skilled craftsman.

There are two approaches to a high performance blade. A high carbon steel can be heat treated and forged to achieve superior properties. This is the path to some of the high performance Japanese blades and tools. Alternatively, one can choose a steel that has high performance built into the steel as a result of alloying and fabrication at the steel factory and simply grind or mill out the desired shape. Each camp has it passionate followers.

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#4

Re: Ultra high carbon steel

david weaver

I don't know what roselli uses, but that 1.5+ is beyond even super blue steel (which IIRC is around 1.45 or 1.5%).

There are high speed steels that go to at least 3.4% or so, but that is beyond where a plain carbon steel tool will be usable, and they are so tough (and expensive) that they would be a nuisance to grind with a dry bench grinder. At least to me.

We also don't know what the lowest angle would be where they would hold up, and if it's more than a degree or two above 30 degrees, they wouldn't be useful.

It'd be helpful to know what they use if they specify alloys.

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#5

Re: I just looked them up..

david weaver

... they say it's a proprietary steel between 1.5% and 2.0%, or something to that effect, and the result is twice the edge retention of W75.

It is probably a high alloy steel to allow that type of carbon content with enough toughness to use it in a knife, but the proprietary steel spec is probably intended to keep users from being able to spec buy on the web (i.e., you look at a maker who uses CPM10V and then decide that you want to price compare and you find a manufacturer who makes knives out of the same steel in volume for half the price).

But double the edge retention of W75 is pretty pedestrian, and I'd imagine the good quality A2 steels are already there, and the high speed steels used right now in any volume (especially the powder steels) are already past it.

If you want to tickle your brain, you can go through the tool, powder and high speed steel data sheets here:

http://www.latrobesteel.com/technical_datasheets.cfm

Or you can look up Hitachi's steel page, where they still do make a lot of high quality high carbon plain steels as well as some of the alloys that LSS specs.

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#6

Re: Ultra high carbon steel

Schtoo

Maybe it might be alright, if it's made right, but even so I can't help but think it's pushing the envelope a little too far.

Ok, the steel is hard and being plain carbon it should be easy enough to sharpen but simply hacking a blade out of a larger lump and heat treating it most likely won't yield a 'great' blade, only a good one.

There's more going on with the Japanese blades than most people realize, and one of those 'things' is that the steel itself is merely the starting point. What's done with that steel makes more of a difference than the actual steel.

(And then you get the steel mill playing tricks with the stuff so you end up with a super tough HSS that sharpens fairly easily, shrugs off severe abuse and makes good M2 HSS look pretty ordinary.)

If this very high carbon steel isn't too expensive, then maybe it might be worth a look. It may well be that it's actually one of the 'starter' steels folks use here for blades too.

Who knows.

I'd like to know, but don't have the gumption to do anything beyond merely wanting to know if, and only if, someone else does the hard work. ;)

Stu.

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#7

Re: Ultra high carbon steel

david weaver

I doubt it's a plain carbon steel like you or I would use the term "high carbon" for. More likely it's a steel with a lot of alloying in it, and the carbon content is described for the purpose of marketing the blade to "paper spec" buyers (i.e.,"if this one has 1, then this one with 1.5-2 has to be better").

It could very well be something as simple as D2.

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#8

Re: Ultra high carbon steel

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I hadn't heard of it before Patrick brought it up. It's claimed to be unalloyed:

http://www.worldknives.com/manufacturers/roselli-35.html

I think I recall that wootz steel--true damascus, ancient, hand-forged, originated in south of India--was ultra high carbon in the range cited, 1.5-2%.

I believe Wilbur did some researching of these olde-tyme methods a few years ago.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#9

Good Catch!

david weaver

Good catch. Who is going to buy the knife to try it out? :b

I'm surprised someone can work steel greater than 1.5% with no alloying elements and get a tough edge out of it.

I'm also going to guess that he's not going to tell us his secrets, but I wonder if he's forge purifying the steel so that it ultimately ends up having a high carbon content, but not as high as the initial spec?

If he's putting it in knives, and it works at that carbon content and takes a very good edge, there is a lot of money to be made selling razors made of the same steel. I have seen razors advertised by thiers issard as having carbonsong steel in the mid 1's.

It's curious to me now, but I am in a cheap streak, so I'm hoping someone else is more curious. I had figured that the white #1 that the good smiths make good chisels out of would be somewhere near the practical limit when toughness is still important.

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#10

Another question..

david weaver

...anyone have a clue where the knives are actually made? They aren't terribly expensive. I've been watching a lot of James Randi videos lately - it makes me want to see an independent appraisal of edge holding as well as an independent verification of the carbon content. :b

Re: Excalibur discovered at Lee Valley in Atlanta

#11

According to my sources....

Bill Tindall

It is knives made from particle M4 and CPM 3V that are winning the knife contests.

Given a knife, chisel or plane blade made from any steel company's "best for the task" steel I doubt many of us could distinguish any difference in performance among the contenders, unless it be ability to sharpen with "classic" abrasives.