New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Stropping on a wheel

Posts

Stropping on a wheel

#1

Stropping on a wheel

roninkokomo

Help me here. How does stopping on a leather or felt wheel dub a cutting edge? I have read this several places. Last night I stropped some couges on a delta grinder fit out with a cloth wheel that had need rubbed with a magic white compound. These things are like razors. No evidence at all of dubbing and I did some pretty aggressive stropping. If it matters, the wheel was rotating toward me, so I held the gouges down at the bottom of the wheel.

Why wouldn't this work just as well on plane irons. This wheel is about all the carvers use to hone.

Ron in Kokomo

Re: Stropping on a wheel

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Stropping on a wheel

#3

Query was theoretical

roninkokomo

I am deliriously happy with my honing of flat irons and chisels right now. So I am very unlikely to change methods. I have just heard about wheels dubbing edges, and wondered at the explanation.

Re: Stropping on a wheel

#4

Re: Query was theoretical

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have a hard felt wheel on my grinder that I don't use very much (mostly because the blasted grinder is a 3750 rpm model and it's very hard to charge it - the compound melts). Having said that, it works wonders on turning gouges, providing I use a light touch. I have not noticed any dubbing of the edges, but then with a turning tool it wouldn't matter that much anyway. It works very well on my teeny palm-sized carving gouges, too.

Re: Stropping on a wheel

#5

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Stropping on a wheel

#6

now THAT is slick.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

one of the dumber things I ever did was pass on the opportunity to buy a watchmaker's lathe with a bunch of attachments for $75. I said I didn't have the need for it. How dumb is it possible to get?

Re: Stropping on a wheel

#7

Stropping

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have done a lot of carving, but I have never used any kind of wheel on any of my tools. It strikes me as being very sloppy. None of the reproduction carvers I know use a wheel.

There was a discussion below about horse hide strops having abrasive grit. My grandfather taught me to use a straight razor in 1966 and in 1969 he got Parkinson's disease and gave me his horse hide strop. The strop was about 30 years old at the time and he told me he had never put any paste on it at all. I have never put anything on it. The strop did it's job again this morning. It could be that we have been constantly exposing fresh grit all these years, but I think the strop does its work without abrasive action. I use a clean strop on plane irons and carving gouges as well.

Re: Stropping on a wheel

#8

Re: Stropping *LINK*

William Duffield

My post was speculation, with a certain amount of tongue-in-cheek. It was based on my observation of the stropping efficacy of the natural leather I grow on the palm of my hand, and the dulling efficacy of tree bark, especially of trees that are exposed to blowing dust from adjacent farm fields. However, I don't know enough about the natural and manufacturing processes to say how much of the silica that is picked up from the vertebrate's environment is later slewed off with the death and replacement of the epidermis or removed in the subsequent tanning processes, and how much of it naturally works its way down into the lower layers of the skin. I suspect that not much if any abrasive is contributed by biological processes of the animal itself (from inside). OTOH, the leather itself is made primarily from collagen, a protein, which I think would not be hard enough by itself to have much of a wearing effect on hardened steel.

Some answers to the processes involved in the making of the leather might be found in the linked article, but I'm not willing to pay $40 for it, and I don't have a microscope and chemical assay tools competent to analyze the composition of the leather for embedded silica.


Journal of Materials Science - Anatomy of Leather

Re: Stropping on a wheel

#9

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Stropping on a wheel

#10

Re: A posteriori reasonings *LINK*

William Duffield

That of course is the problem with suspicions. They can easily be refuted by carefully controlled scientific experiments, and even long in-depth experience. I like the explanation.

The results with the cobra are interesting, and having kept snakes (but not cobras), I can easily accept their conclusions. Horses, however, have a completely different method of locomotion. :) Maybe we should ask the horsebuttmongers to stamp the backside of the leather with those arrows one finds on the back of sanding belts :D so that we may strop in the most effective direction.

I guess I'm going to have to get one of these (ref. link) from Joel and stop risking severing a tendon in my right hand. It's a lot less expensive than my SawStop, and I had no problem justifying the outlay for that.

Your explanation would indicate that I don't really need the green crayon that Joel promotes with the strop. Do I understand that correctly?


Horse Butt Strop

Re: Stropping on a wheel

#11

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Stropping on a wheel

#12

Re: My butt's not green

William Duffield

Does this mean that it would be effective to use my 0.5µ diamond paste (that I also got from my favorite huckster in Brooklyn) on the strop? I've used it on rock maple and snakewood, and am considering charging an old 9x12 cast iron surface plate with it, but have been concerned that, like when I tried it on acrylic, it might just bury itself below the surface, like water on Mars.

Re: Stropping on a wheel

#13

White stuff

roninkokomo

Whst about those white hunks of compound that I see carvers using on cloth wheels. Is that finer than the green stuff?