New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Skew plane blade angle?

Posts

Skew plane blade angle?

#1

Skew plane blade angle?

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi -

Is there a way to determine the skew of a plane blade if one knows the bedding angle of the blade and the angle of the edge of the blade (relative to the side of the plane?

Thank you -

Dave

Re: Skew plane blade angle?

#3

Re: Does this help?

Dave (Arlington, VS)

Thank you, Wiley, but I don't think so. That link is for the formula for the effective cutting angle when you skew a plane. I want to reestablish the edge on a skewed blade. So I think that is different - and might require a different formula, but I'm certainly not good enough a math to be sure.

I appreciate the link.

Dave

Re: Skew plane blade angle?

#4

Re: Skew plane blade angle?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Dave

Are you trying to determine the ideal angle to hone a plane with a skewed blade?

If so, two ideas: firstly, looking at this more generally, there are example for different planes here (I wrote this before Lee Valley came along with the angle jig for their Honing Guide): http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/Advanced%20Angles%20on%20the%20Lee%20Valley%20Honing%20Guide%20Mk%20II.html

The second method much easier: simple insert the blade until it just exits the mouth. Then run this over very fine sandpaper to mark/wear the angle on the blade. Now grind to this mark.

Was that what you were after?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Skew plane blade angle?

#5

Re: Skew plane blade angle?

TomD

I used to calculate all this stuff, but these days I model it in Cad because it is faster. Of course if all you wanted was the blade angle you could scribe it from the mouth. If i was stuck having to calculate it. I would use the simple math to project the degree to which the higher line on the bedding angle is higher than the lower, then I would simple project that longer line to the mouth. That would give me the length of the edge, and from that I could easily calculate the angle since I already know blade width.

Re: Skew plane blade angle?

#6

Deleted a prior post re 'math'


Re: Skew plane blade angle?

#7

Belated thank you to Derek and ThomD

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Derek and ThomD -

Thank you for your reply - back on August 20th - to my question about skewed plane blade angles. My apologies for the belated thank you. I lost my hard drive on my old computer along with alot of files and data. The first two new replacement computers didn't work out of the box and had to be returned. The third one worked but it's taken a long time to retreave as many of my files as possible and reconstruct the important ones that I lost. All this plus back to school time for my kids...all this is TMI, I am sure. But these things have soaked up a huge amount of my time, and I wanted you to know my failure to reply earlier was not for lack of gratitude for your taking the time to reply to my question.

Derek - think I will take you sandpaper advise on the one skewed angle plane that I top of mind when I wrote my question. The edge of the blade is noticeably irregular and I am justing trying to figure out the right angle when I try to correct. Needless to say because of my computer problems I haven't had much time to spend on this blade, as well. However, I do want to also thank you for the link to your website. Another of my skewed plane blade questions was because of a #79 that I have where one of the blades is spot on but the other is out of whack. Your pictures emboldened me to give it a try and it worked...in short order this evening. I got the angle right on the messed up blade.

ThomD - I thought I was fair at math but your simple math seems beyond me. I still think I'm okay with the Euclidian/Two-dimensional stuff, but this 3-D stuff has me baffled. Also - saddly - I have no experience with CAD. Nonetheless I am appreciative that you took the time to reply to my question.

Many thanks to both of you.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Skew plane blade angle?

#8

Re: Belated thank you to Derek and ThomD

TomD

Glad for the entertainment value. My sister has the PHD in math, I just have a sharp pencil.

Re: Skew plane blade angle?

#9

Re: Belated thank you to Derek and ThomD

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Dave

I have this love-hate relationship with computers - they're amazing what they can do, and they seems to keeping doing so much more all the time. However ... they do hiccup every now-and-then - probably to keep us on our toes and ever grateful to them! :\

Good on you for going for it. That is the only way. I am pleased that it worked as well for you as it did for me. Since that article, LV brought out an angle guide for the Mk 2 Honing guide, which makes it much easier.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Skew plane blade angle?

#10

Correction!!!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bloody computers .. I hate them!!! :)

Especially the self-correction facility, which changes what you write. In this case, I did not edit out a word. So, if you struggled to read a sentence I just wrote ..."I have this love-hate relationship with computers - they're amazing what they can do, and they seems to keeping doing so much more all the time." It should have been ."I have this love-hate relationship with computers - they're amazing what they can do, and they seem to be doing so much more all the time".

Regards hblkjlk Ptryf

Dkj.,k