New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Joel - Norton HB8 Question

Posts

Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#1

Joel - Norton HB8 Question

david weaver

Joel - just a question about the norton stones. I noticed that it's easy to find the 8x3 stone everywhere now, but it's getting much more difficult to find the HB8 (full thickness 8x2 translucent for people not named joel who have no idea what I'm talking about).

Did Norton decide to quit making that stone?

I saw one go by on ebay yesterday for $96 and figured it was a little high until I looked at what the last ones left new are going for. Same guy got me on two different vintage translucent stones. His sniper sniped my sniper.

Anyway, just curious, because you are the only person left with a remotely reasonable price on the HB8. There are other places that are between $280 and $410 for the thing.

I've come to appreciate that size more than the 8x3, I think it's easier to keep it flat without lapping it (to me, lapping a broken in stone is nearly a mortal sin).

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#2

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

Joel Moskowitz

As far as I know Norton has no plans to discontinue the stone. It's a classic size and costs more because of the thickness. But we have them - how many do you want?

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#3

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

david weaver

haha....I did see one place was selling packs of 5, but their discount price per stone was still more than your individual price.

We'll see how my luck goes on ebay, if it doesn't improve, I'll probably just buy a new one.

Like I said, I missed one that looked unused (and vintage) at $96 yesterday, but who knows where it would've gone if I bid higher, may have matched new price. Same person was buying all kinds of fine stones on ebay yesterday, and that's not really a common stone to find anywhere else (as opposed to the india stones, carborundum stones and various soft arkansas stones that appear at flea markets and yard sales).

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#4

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

CStan

Somewhere a nickel is holding up a dime.

Pull the trigger.

Please.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#5

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

david weaver

Something is telling me I should stretch it (the decision) out a little bit and post about all the details in the interim.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#6

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

CStan

Oh I think you should. Ask Joel a bunch more questions that I'm sure he'll graciously answer, compare his prices to everybody elses, including God's.

Please, that's just what you should do. Get your extra fifteen dollar's worth.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#7

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

CStan

You said Joel's price was reasaonable in your first post.

What are you waiting for?

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#8

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

david weaver

Joel's is very reasonable. Norton's is not, they've put him in a pinch with buyers trying to figure out why two stones of the same volume and grade are different in price by a factor of 2.

You seem to be worried about joel's business, which he can handle himself. In this instance, I might be the tire kicker, but most often i just visit his site and order with no questions. I doubt he needs your help.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#9

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

Joel Moskowitz

In case you are curious about the price difference it's very simple. Arkansas stones are easily flawed. The waste factor on mining is appalling. it is easier (and therefore cheaper) to cut flawless wider thin stones than narrower and thicker thicker stones.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#10

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

david weaver

I had figured that thickness was the issue. I'd like to get some of the waste (seconds) stones. In my experience, a lot of translucents are like guitar wood - the stuff that doesn't look quite as good is functionally just as good as the stuff that does, but it's difficult to get a hold of. Maybe at some point, i'll call norton and see if they can dig me up something interesting and ugly off their scrap pile (being that I'm already a loyal customer of their "perfects").

But I understand that norton doesn't want to sell most of that stuff.

I've seen a lot of vintage stones that have huge inclusions and imperfections norton would never sell. I think they're interesting, and it's funny how different groups value different things in stones. Color variation in japanese stones that doesn't otherwise affect sharpening often brings a lot of extra money. In arkansas stones, it's often described as cosmetic flaws.

At any rate, if norton says that it doesn't make economic sense (by their explanation) to order 8x2x1 stones, then I will follow their lead. I do have curiosity about norton's black stones, which I also wish were offered in 8x2 and one inch thick (which is not rare like it is with translucents), but I have never seen one from norton, and I've not been that excited with new black arks that I've tried elsewhere. So I ordered one of the black 8x3's instead.

I noticed in holzapfel's 3rd book last night (which I read after making my comment about narrower stones being easier to keep flat), that the same comment was made in there, that many of the stones sold to craftsmen in that era were narrow due to craftsmen having a better time keeping them flat without resorting to scuffing off their surfaces.

Thanks for entertaining the discussion, Joel.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#11

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

William Duffield

Why do you need 1" thick stones? You won't wear out a half inch translucent Arkansas stone in 3 generations. If it's 3 inches wide and you want it 2 inches wide, rent a tile saw @ the Borg.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#12

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

CStan

I'm sure Joel can take care of his business.

Why don't you send him some?

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#13

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

CStan

.... and send me the cutoff inch... grind it into slipstones.....

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#14

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

david weaver

The elevation of the stone surface is nice (it keeps your knuckles away from the sides of wood boxes and gives you room to work).

But the same can be achieved by gluing something to the bottom of the 1/2 inch stones, which is probably what I'll do. As you mentioned, I'll cut it to width with a batten and a diamond bladed angle grinder if I have trouble keeping it flat without lapping it.

Presumably the old craftsmen also preferred the elevation of a 1 inch stone since the companies mining the stones went with that thickness, even for the best stones where they could've otherwise made and sold nearly two thinner stones for each thick stone.

The only old stones I've seen at 1/2" thickness or so are the highest quality thuringia (used mostly for razors, though some of the razor folks have found unusual large eschers in tool boxes). Escher quality stones, though, are truly rare and were exhausted sometime around 1910 or 1920. The material was so desirable that the dust from cutting the original stones was made into bonded stones once the natural stones were exhausted.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#15

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#16

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

CStan

Dude, dude, dude....

Really?

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#17

Re: Jasper

david weaver

That's something I haven't seen outside of razors, and it's been spoken about little enough that I have no idea what its properties are other than it's hard. Is it a lot like novaculite or any of the other quartzish stones?

The sypderco wide hone is also about 1/4" thick, the narrow hone is 1/2" thick. The wide was probably the wrong thing to get (much more expensive, too), but wide is nice for honing a razor, and treated the right way, spyderco stones do unspeakable things to a razor edge (which is something you sharpen only once a month or two - unfortunately).

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#18

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#19

The razors...

david weaver

.. the "edge chasers" in the community of razor folks in using something like jasper is to take an already sharp edge off of another finisher and change the properties a little bit. I'm not sure it would do anything good, but people will try just about anything.

It's not something I do, I just go for sharp and fast, but it is interesting to me, anyway, because it's like anything else we do - manipulation of materials for one reason or another.

Novaculite is as hard as I've gone, and no matter how good the novaculite, the edge always benefits a lot from a follow up on a balsa chromium oxide powdered strop.

As far as woodworking goes, clearly the best thing to me is one medium stone and a very fine ceramic stone. The edge is better than a novaculite stone, and the cut is faster, without having to go too small in abrasive.

But that doesn't keep me from experimenting out of curiosity, it's still interesting, even though the edge from everything else, save possibly the finest slate hones, comes up short of the modern ceramics (and they are not nearly as fast).

I've seen the word "chert" several times but never identified exactly what it meant. Now I know. Thanks :)

Once it was in a question to me (from someone japanese) and the other time it was reading an advertisement from a japanese supply house that said that the stones they were retailing gave a "better edge than any chert".

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#20

As far as minutiae..

david weaver

...won't bother me a bit, I'm sure something else will catch my interest as I'm working my way through Holtzapffel III.

Given that you seem to have experience with quite a few of the applications, I can't think of a better place to bring it up.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#21

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#22

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#23

Re: Holtzapffel III

david weaver

I wish I could find that. My printing (astragal press, I didn't check the copyright date) has a foreword in it that states that it's numbered differently than old versions. Sooner or later I'll run across it.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#24

Re: Charles, you do more needling...

david weaver

I would've mistaken the needling for self-aggrandizement.

At least when a diabetic pricks a finger, they get some useful information.

Re: Joel - Norton HB8 Question

#25

David Barnett

Snap!