New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Sellers Remorse

Posts

Sellers Remorse

#1

Sellers Remorse

Patrick Gibbons

Sunday some auctions I put on eBay closed and I had succeeded at selling some tools. I have a lot of tools I don't use much and they take up valuable space all the time sitting around rusting and needing care. What I no longer use may be just the thing for someone else. Selling these on eBay is the right thing to do. Still I feel a bit of sadness. It's silly. There are some tools I won't miss while others I have an attachment to though they're hardly ever used anymore. I'm trying to get my kit of tools down to what I actually use. One of the tools I sold was my low angle jack plane. It was one of the tools most would consider to be one of my better ones. I've owned this tool for about ten years and have never used it much. I've never liked the way it felt in use. Another is a low angle Record block plane. It was never comfortable in my hand and didn't perform nearly as well as my Veritas and Lie Nielsen blocks. I won't miss the jack but I will the block. The block was my first plane. Hand tools are very personal items. I've recently read some blogs where others have expressed similar feelings. All this makes me realize that how I work wood is as important as what I build and how well. I read someone else who said he'd never feel this connected to a router or table saw and that goes for me too. I have a hand saw that's at least 130 years old. I wonder where my Dewalt router will be in 2142.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#2

Re: Sellers Remorse

david weaver

I'd rather have seller's remorse than buyer's remorse!

I have a rule in my shop, if a tool rusts twice, it's gone. I usually take some steps to mitigate rust, but if a tool goes unused long enough, it won't get viewed, and eventually it will rust, at least that's what I've found.

I have sold some tools that I thought were really fantastic and fantastically made tools because I realized that I was unlikely to use them, and when that's the case, I just become a custodian and I don't like that, no matter how much I like the tools.

Same thing with sharpening stones, which I have a thing for. I have gobs of them, but from time to time, I will move a few on, even though some of them are really spectacular.

The only thing I won't ever do is sell a gift.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#3

Re: Sellers Remorse

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The only thing I won't ever do is sell a gift.

Amen.

The only tools that have real "value" are those with a personal association or memory. All the rest are just tools for the using.

I really envy those who have inherited tools from parents and grandparents. It must be so cool using something like this. Perhaps that is one reason i have not developed an emotional bond with so many vintage tools, because they are just old and not connected. My father designed buildings and furniture but his tools of choice were a ball of string and a roll of duct tape.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sellers Remorse

#4

Re: Sellers Remorse

jossimbyr

I could never consider selling any of my tools. There are a couple of items that I've received as part of a 'lot' of tools won on eBay that I wouldn't mind giving to others in need, but the items that I actually want are things that I plan to keep forever, no matter how much I may or may not use them.

On the other hand, I'm very thankful for people who don't mind selling their items, since I wouldn't be able to get any old British saws or Millers Falls items otherwise. Nothing against the new items that are out there these days, but there are few things that make me want to spend my money the way a Groves backsaw or MF plane will do.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#5

pricing

Jerry Gibbs

Sentiment aside, here are my observations. If I got it for free, I will give it away or price it low. If I paid fair market value, I will try to get the new, reduced, fmv. If I paid too much for it, I will keep moving it and tripping over it. Jerry

Re: Sellers Remorse

#6

Re: Sellers Remorse

Mark Hennebury

I think that had you purchased a vintage cast iron table saw and stripped it down, removing every nut and bolt and washer, the cleaned and sandblasted all the castings and primed and painted them, then rebuilt the motor and fitted the dovetailed ways with lapping paste, replaced all the bearings and bushings, lapped the entire table top and dial indicated and trued up the sliding table and made the machine work better than the original, that you would find quite an emotional attachment to it as well.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#7

After a while...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Most of my tools have come to me courtesy of garage sales. The thing about garage sales is that you rarely find the really, really sweet tools first; instead, you find adequate tools. Once those have settled in, if you're lucky, they send out pheromones that draw the sweet tools to you as you go to more garage sales. Or something like that. This frees the first-purchased tools to be sold on, so that they can wander the world and have exciting adventures, although I do keep one extra of any given plane size (for instance), in case I drop my best one on the floor.

Some (mainly mechanic's tools) have come to me through family (father and uncle, mainly). Those don't get sold (although some of them, when I wound up with way too many duplicates, got donated to Habitat).

A few tools I bought retail. I tend not to sell those.

This philosophy has somehow allowed me to accumulate way, way more tools than it is reasonable for me to own. Maybe I should rethink it.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#8

Re: Sellers Remorse

Paul M.

I have a thing about tripping over stuff. I just can't stand having to step over things and kick them around. It triggers the same extreme adverse reaction I get whenever I get near a shopping mall. I've spent a lot of effort trying to make everything have a place, but that never seems to be very... ummm... permanent. The free radicals start finding new homes underfoot.

Having a limited shop space means that when I get something in, then something else must go. I usually keep a mental list of what is next on the to-go list. My large planer is next to leave as i haven't used it in years. That will help make the few remaining plugged-in tools on the power side of my shop much easier to move around.

Boy did I dance the happy dance as my piece-o-something-I-would-not-want-to-step-in Shopsmith drove away with all of the stuff that goes with those monsters. I've never had a single second of remorse after that one left. I've had no tablesaw for 2+ years now, and haven't missed it at all.

Usually, by the time it gets off the to-go list and gets sold, it's been on that list for a while. So I've not experienced sellers remorse, since the time to adapt to the departure of the item is front-loaded. I'm glad for the space for more jigs or whatever.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#9

Been there,done that

Bob Hackett

When you have an understanding with a machine it`s hard to give it up. One of the reasons that is so is the realization that you`ll have to repeat the process and all that work in order to arrive at the same point with the new machine.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#10

Not for me

Ron in Kokomo

I know that what you say is true for a lot of folks, but the older I get the more I can understand and really appreciate the distinction that Paul Sellers makes between tools and machines. I get very attached to tools. Machines...not so much.

YMMV

Ron

Re: Sellers Remorse

#11

Re: Not for me

William Duffield

I hope you have remorse for sneaking that pun into the conversation, potentially inciting an exchange on denotation vs. connotation and the fine line between a seller and a huckster. :D

Of course, the Grammar Police should have chastised Patrick immediately for his faux pas in misspelling "Seller's Remorse." :D :D

from the Apple Dictionary, available under the GNU Free Documentation License:

huckster |ˈhəkstər|

noun

a person who sells small items, either door-to-door or from a stall or small store.

• a mercenary person eager to make a profit out of anything.

• a publicity agent or advertising copywriter, esp. for radio or television.

verb [ trans. ]

promote or sell (something, typically a product of questionable value).

• [ intrans. ] bargain; haggle.

DERIVATIVES

hucksterism |-izəm| noun

ORIGIN Middle English (in the sense [retailer at a stall, hawker] ): probably of Low German origin.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#12

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Sellers Remorse

#13

Re: Sellers Remorse

CStan

Same for me years ago over an old Craftsman tablesaw. I busted my butt on that thing. Used for a while and upgraded. I still miss that little cuss.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#14

Re: pricing

Jay Samuels

That last part is so true. There are probably studies on stock market behavior that confirm we irrationally hang onto economic losers.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#15

Re: Yeah, I just had to find out...

Patrick Gibbons

That was the original way I learned to sharpen. I'm going back to it because it's just easier to me and it works. YMMW

Re: Sellers Remorse

#16

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Sellers Remorse

#17

Re: That was tongue-in-cheek

david weaver

I'm in your camp. All of that farting around in the middle with mid-level stones perpetuates the myth that it takes a long time to make something really sharp.

One stone to clean up the bevel, and one stone, lap or belt to polish the back and the burr, it should be 30 seconds, with a 30 second grind mixed in every 4-8 times depending on what's going on.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#18

Re: Ditto the..

david weaver

...groves and the millers falls.

i understand how people can get wrapped into reconditioning old machines, especially if they are working metal and need precision to do things like polish with the lathe.

But the tools (especially groves) that were made by someone with a good eye and good hands...hubba hubba.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#19

Re: That was tongue-in-cheek

Patrick Gibbons

I figured you were kidding around. Was just making conversation.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#20

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Sellers Remorse

#21

Re: It was really the only way I knew...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It WAS funny...glad I got to see it before it mysteriously vanished!

Re: Sellers Remorse

#22

Re: It was really the only way I knew...

William Duffield

The National Emblem quip is still there, but it's only rude.

Re: Sellers Remorse

#23

Re: It was really the only way I knew...

Patrick Gibbons

David, I always appreciate your humor, wit, intelligence, depth of knowledge and curiosity. I'm sorry to be missing some interesting quips. I have to agree it is hard to pass up a good setup for a joke. But it's sometimes way too easy to misinterpret a written statement compared to a spoken one.