New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

Posts

Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

#1

Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

david weaver

Somewhere, not that long ago, i saw a listing of different sharpening stones somewhere online. It included stuff like turkish oilstones, charnley forest stones, dragon's tongues, etc...It was written from an englishman's perspective and mentioned novaculite (arkansas) stones, too. I think charnleys and cutlers greens and such might also be novaculite hones, just not from the states.

Does anyone remember ever seeing anything similar?

I'm curious only because I have a charnley forest on the way, one that is destined for razors (so it's not really woodworking). But what made me curious was Joel's comments about arkansas stones being finer than charnleys, which won't necessarily be the case for this one, but maybe that was the case with many of them.

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

#2

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones? *LINK*

Peter Evans

There is a good reference available:

Hones and Stones Natural 19th and Early 20th Century Sharpening Stones and Hones by Brian Read and Doug Morgan,

from TATHS, scroll down the page a bit to find it.


http://www.taths.org.uk/special-publications.htm

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

#3

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones? *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Richard Knight wrote a survey of stones about 200 years ago. His work is quoted in Holtzapffel and other technical books. Here is some on Stephen's site


Stones

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

#4

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

joel moskowitz

Holtzapffel's list is important because the earlier edition (1840's) is pre-arkansas stones and Washita's are just hinted at. The updated edition (1870? 80's) list's them.

Knight's list doesn't include arkansas stones at all (too early) but he does imply that the Charley Forest stones are not as fine as either the german green hone or a good turkey stone.

If you don't own Holtzapffel volume 3 a person with your interests should (we stock it). I would guess there is a digital scan available somewhere but I've never looked

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

#5

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

david weaver

His implications do seem to translate into the modern world of razor users, where the sharpness and the properties of the edge still matter and are easy to notice. Ebay has made it easy to get anything if you're willing to outbid someone else, including ultra rare 10 inch german hones (not something I would buy).

That is, at least for the german thuringia region hones. A search through ebay shows how much a yellow/green graded escher brand hone will bring, they are crazy money for fairly small stones. Like $800 for a 6x2 hone. Too rich for me, but they are regarded as the best. These were hones that were $2 in about 1900 for y/g and $1 for a gray or blue escher brand hone.

Charnleys get alternating press on there, because they are often irregular, varying fineness, and like any novaculite stone, when they are broken in, they are slow. That itself isn't a big deal, but the japanese and thuringian hones are just as fine and not slow.

Genuine turkish oilstones are a bit less easy to find, they seem to be fragile and the ones I've seen look in rough shape. I wonder if their reputation for cutting anything has to do with their friability (but I don't wonder enough about it to track one down).

I've never seen anyone mention using one on a shaving forum, they are probably hard to get, as folks otherwise mention trying all manner of stuff they shouldn't be shaving off of (like soft arkansas stones, etc).

The rest of the stuff on the list, I've tried some of the slates though they don't go into quite so much detail there, but the historical context of the link warren gave makes it sound almost as if someone would buy a charnley hone and do almost all of the work on an edge with it (which would explain why the washita became so popular).

I'll check your site for the book. Thanks for the heads up.

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

#6

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

david weaver

Thanks for the link, Warren. I saw that text reprinted in a book about iron on google books. It's a pretty broad summary. I think that's probably the same list I remember reading, it just looks more familiar now because I've tried some of the stones on it (the fine ones) or seen them often on a razor forum.

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

#7

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

david weaver

Thanks, Peter. I'll have to ask them if they post to the US.

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

#8

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

david weaver

Never mind, I see they direct people in the states to astragal press.

Re: Documentation of Old Sharpening Stones?

#9

Re: The Charnley

david weaver

Well, I did get the charnley forest yesterday, so one more stone is knocked off the list of curiosities.

It feels like a softer arkansas stone (not much softer), but it came with evidence that someone flattened it with a belt sander or with coarse loose grit (I fixed that, and polished off its lapping with a hard gray ark, which left both stones with an aggressive coating of loose novaculite on the tops).

All of this bolsters my statement that even the finest natural stones are likely to have abrasives that are still larger than the super-fine synthetics (like the SP 13k that's at 0.73 microns, or the shapton 30k or gokyumo (did I spell that right?) hard stone that's also 0.5 micron like the shapton 30k.

Despite the charnley being a bit coarse at this stage of its use for razors (it will settle in) it's easy to see why craftsmen forced to go from sandstone to charnley or sandstone to slate to charnley would have welcomed the washita. It's like the missing link in terms of medium stones, and like many charnleys, this one is long and thin (11x1.5"). I'll break it in with tools, but it is more suitable for small knives and razors.

I think the best natural stone with oil that I have tried so far is the purple slate hone that a seller on ebay has (I think he's actually mining them). The grit is very fine, but it is aggressive enough to use, and it's hard enough to hold flatness. It also takes well to a slurry stone of its own kind, which allows you to speed up sharpening and still get a very good edge. If it weren't for his shipping, it would be cheap, too.