New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Working with silver? *LINK*

Posts

Working with silver? *LINK*

#1

Working with silver? *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

The link at bottom is to a desk at the Gamble House in Pasadena, CA. This desk has silver ornament, including silver drawer pulls.

A detail of the silver pulls is shown here in a Flickr account:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/7623700252/in/set-72157630698807744/

Questions: How would you go about making those pulls? Start with 1/4" silver or argentium wire? Sterling or pure silver? Bend or hammer? Will silver work-harden quickly and have to be annealed as you go?

Any help greatly appreciated!

Wiley


Gamble House;  guest room desk

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#2

Re: Working with silver?

CJ in MPLS

For the pulls, start with wire of the appropriate gauge and cross section. If you cannot get the correct cross section, find a jeweler who will run it through a forming mill. Use sterling as it is cheaper, but pure silver is easier to work. Also, you may want to anneal the silver once it is shaped.

Clean up the silver wire as best you can and then bend it. At this point you can add the hammered finish. I'm certain that there are about a billion ways to do this. I just watched a woman make a silver belt buckle (same shape as your bails) in this way. Looked great.

I think that FWW had an article on making the silver wire ornamentation.

CJ

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#3

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

charlie belden

Pure silver is pretty soft. Sterling silver, which is only 92.5% silver is less soft. Coin silver, which is only 90% silver is even less soft. For pulls, sterling would be a good choice since it's relatively available. The link below should lead you to what you're looking for. You'll need a harder metal to connect the handle to the piece - they make nickel silver pin stock for that,

Yes, silver, sterling and coin silver will work harden - by bending or hammering. It comes usually annealed and "dead soft". It can always be gotten back to dead soft by annealing. To keep it from oxidizing when annealing it with a torch, mix powdered borax (20 Mule Team laundry powder is borax) with alcohol and dip your silver in it. The alcohol will evaporate or burn away, leaving a thin coat of borax on the wire. The borax will melt and serve as a flux, keeping the silver from oxidizing. You DO NOT want to have to get fire scale off your metal.

If you're also interested in doing silver wire inlaying into a piece, I've posted the link to several pages pn Michael Fortune's method, including a tool for cutting the lines for your silver wire - that you can make from an old scraper and a shop made device for getting a flat on a round wire. That link is in my next response.


Rio Grande jewelry making supplies

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#5

Re: Working with silver?

John in NM

I would use sterling, fine silver is way too soft for a pull. If coin silver were more readily available I'd use that instead. Pulls like that will need a heavy gauge, the usual jewelry suppliers probably won't have anything heavy enough, so you would need to either make it yourself or have a jeweler who does fabrication work do it for you. A lot of jewelers do trade work - setting repair, resizing stuff, etc, and may not have the rolling mill that makes wire (betcha David Barnett has one though :D )

If you start with annealed stock, you should be able to make the pulls without re-annealing, then add the hammer finish. You will need some degree of work hardening to keep those pulls from bending in use over the years. Annealing however is easy, heat it up red with a propane torch or air-acetylene torch if you have one, then quench in a mild acid - dilute H2SO4 is the traditional one, sold as "pickle" in the jewelry making shops. I've used straight vinegar in a pinch, smells awful though, at least to me :D

At a guess, those pulls are going to take 1-2 oz each, so be ready for some sticker shock :(

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#6

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Working with silver?

Stephen Shepherd

Silver easily work hardens and needs to be annealed, just remember it is opposite of ferrous metals, heat it up and quench it to soften, heat it up and let it cool slowly [in ashes] to make it harder.

Stephen

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#7

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#8

Mills remain common...

John in NM

Among art jewelers and those who specialize in custom stuff. What I meant is, I don't think I'd expect one at the local retailer who sells manufactured items, replaces watch batteries, and maybe builds up old and worn prong settings and resets the stone. I may be wrong about that though, its been years since I had any dealings with jewelers.

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#9

Follow-up and thanks

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

First of all, thank you very, very much for the wealth of insight and data you have provided. You have anticipated every question.

It appears possible for me to make the pulls, starting with rod as suggested by CJ, though David cautions to practice on something cheaper than silver to get the feel of it. And John points to the sticker shock (which is real). Will try to get through it without annealing, but can't assume that, given that I am starting with no metal-hammering experience. Thanks for the advice on flux or cupronil, in the event annealing is required. And also Stephen's point that annealing silver is the opposite of ferrous--who woulda thunk that?! I am familiar with the hammered finish on silver jewelry, so I do know how the finished surface should look.

Charlie's thoughtful information on inlay is very helpful, particularly how to make and use the routing tool, and the limitations on going cross-grain. Charlie's incredible graphics are stunning! Does this stuff just come out of his fingers??

Rio Grande, cited by David, appears is the only supplier of silver rod. I think it will have to be sterling, given the 1/4" diameter, so no avoiding tarnish. I called Rio Grande: they receive the 1/4" rod in precut lengths of 1 foot. Can't buy a single 2-foot length, which would be way more practical. It will be very, very close whether a pull can be made from a 6" length--even a fraction over that would necessitate buying 3 one-foot lengths, a 12" length for each pull. A big ka-ching. So prototyping with copper as David suggests will be useful to determine the exact length of rod needed for each pull, plus get the feel of metal bending. Plus figure out how to shape the metal a bit, since a perfectly round section throughout won't look right.

Deepest thanks to all for the supportive but realistic advice!

Wiley

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#10

One more thought....

John in NM

For practice you can use #4 ground wire, costs maybe $1+ per foot last time I bought any. It will give you some idea if you can get two pulls from a 1' piece, also some idea whether the silver will need annealing mid-way through, though you'd have to anneal it to start. Copper won't work harden as fast as sterling (that is a seat of the pants statement, based on recollections from years ago :D ). If the copper ends up needing it then the silver will definitely need it. I'd guess you'll get away without though.

Copper also makes a nice looking A&C pull :D

It does sound like a really cool project too, Wiley, I can't wait to see some pics of the results :D

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#11

Re: One more thought....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

John and all,

Those are helpful ideas! Copper as the prototype appeals, because I'll find a use for it somewhere down the line.

Trying to think of an approach to the wire inlay on legs and uprights. The varying line weight can be gotten by filing. But how to hold it down? I won't be able to sink the wire very deep into the wood (Ceylon satinwood). Am thinking that each segment of wire, say 2" avg. length, will end in right-angle tips, which I will drill for--this makes the heroic assumption that thin silver wire--annealed--will take right angle tips. To sink the body of the wire....Outline shallow channels with different-sweep gouges, excavate with 1mm and 1/2mm veiners, deepen and square with a very fine plough-type tool--then pick the right glue to hold the wire to the wood. From experience with another G&G inlay project with varying line weights and tight bends, I know it's really tough to make it look convincing. A near miss looks Mickey Mouse.

Thanks again for any and all ideas!

Wiley

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#12

Stephen Shepherd

Wire Inlay

Stephen Shepherd

I learned wire inlay from a gunsmith, the 'chisels' are made from broken pieces of hack saw blade, one broken end is rounded over and the other end is sharpened to a point. It is also possible to make them curved by bending and filing the end. I have 5 or 6 different shapes and widths.

Then simply pound the blades into the wood along the pattern making a small recess without removing any wood. I then prepare thin, less than 1/8" wide strips of silver sheet the thickness of the wire inlay. I think it should be called silver ribbon inlay. Bend the pieces of silver ribbon to the shape, etch with garlic and apply hide glue before pounding it down into the groove edgewise until it is nearly flush. Then scrape off the excess silver, saving the scraps.

Stephen

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#14

Stephen Shepherd

Do you have a picture?


Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#15

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Strip inlay works well...

Stephen Shepherd

It looks like they used two different widths of ribbon for the inlays. I would have to examine the piece closely but it just looks like a bad inlay job to me. Looks like the ribbon was bent when installed and not scraped off smooth giving it that look.

Stephen

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#16

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#17

Re: One might think that...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thank you David, Stephen, and Charlie, for the inlay methods!

The aesthetic point that Stephen makes (using one syllable* words) is best answered by seeing that nature is often a little imperfect when you look close--vines are twisted, not always smoothly; leaves will be bug chewed or sun scorched, or have tips bent at odd angles, or the 'wrong' number of lobes, and so on. Japanese artisans have long been onto this point, and Charles Greene used it in the Gamble House ornament. That said, my own effort may well turn out to look like--and be--a bad inlay job. Trying to avoid that.

I think the inlay on that desk is slightly raised. It looks to be a little proud of the ground, and raised inlay was used on other furniture in the Gamble House. Will verify this on the G&G forum to make sure.

I began with the notion to shape the wire, then cut the channel somehow in varying width to match. After reading and re-reading David's posts, it looks like it should be the other way round--the channel will be used to shape the metal, to avoid gaps where the metal doesn't fill the channel. Though it should be possible to press a shape into the wire against a wood or metal anvil just prior to sinking it. The craftsmen executing those G&G designs were often European ex-pats; but I've seen nothing describing their methods.

Am now thinking three stages:

1. Outline the channels shallowly with various gouges, and perhaps a graver (never used a graver). Gouges will be ground to thin bevels.

2. Deepen and shape channel with tools from scraper stock (per Charlie), hacksaw blades (per Stephen), and maybe a graver if David has a particular suggestion. It looks to me like a 'tooth' which tapers could be pulled along the channel to vary the channel width--more upright to thin the channel; held at a flatter angle to broaden the channel.

3. Undercut slightly with a thin, curved 'tooth'.

4. Choosing and working the wire will have to be an experiment--never done it before.

All further suggestions will be most appreciated!

Wiley

_____

*Winston Churchill, ".... “Short words are best, and old words, when short, are best of all.”

Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#18

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Working with silver? *LINK*

#19

Re: One other option for your item #4

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David and all,

Those last two posts of yours add great clarity. I'm ready to order and start ground truthing. In step 1 ('various gouges') I mean to make shallow stab cuts end-to-end to transfer the pattern from paper onto the wood. Have given up the notion of using veiners or v-tools to start the pattern, because there's not enough control of channel width with them (in my hands). There's a lot of hardened steel around to shape the small tools from--scraper stock, saber saw blades, used-up M2 lunchbox planer knives, etc.

This project is going to take me forever and a day, but will photograph my learning process probably starting about Christmas, for the benefit of others, and also for critique.

Much, much thanks!

Wiley