New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

Posts

Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

Stephen Shepherd

It is Tuesday and the night we gather and discuss HAND TOOLS and related subjects. I hope my computer / connection problems are over the test is this post. The topic will be open tonight but I am interested in discussing posture while woodworking.

The fun and frolic all starts at 9:30 o'clock PM Eastern Time and runs for one scheduled hour.

Just click on CHAT ROOM on the left and join in.

All are welcome, hope to see you there.

Stephen Shepherd

Host - Hand Tool Chat

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#2

David Barnett

Sounds like your system's in a slump.


Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#3

Re: Fancy gunwork

TomD

One thing I was thinking about a few days back is whether any of you have some gunslinger twirls in your wood working. I flip chisels end for end like a knife fighter, and I flip hammers. Boggs flips spokeshaves. I don't do it to show off, since nobody sees me do it. I do it to build comfort with the tools and speed.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#5

Re: Funny thing, that

TomD

Having seen Asian students do that, even back when I was in school, or for that matter their martial arts, I just figured they had to have some stuff like that happening with their tools, but I have not seen it...

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#6

Re: And more to the point

TomD

You want to do this kind of thing, it impacts the kind of chisels you like. In my experience ones that spin can also take a hit, because having some weight in the hand is part of that.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#7

you're no slouch! 


Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#8

Ellis Walentine

Whoo. Now we're talking!

Ellis

I'm all for ways to incorporate gunslinging into woodworking. I think that learning to woodwork is like learning to tango. You learn the basics and then you practice until it comes naturally. It can take years, maybe forever, before you get the rhythm, but then, it's off to the races. If I could instill one awareness into budding woodworkers, this would be it. Practice. Tune into your tools and the feedback from your work.

Ellis

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#9

Re: Whoo. Now we're talking!

TomD

Practice is something I emphasize a lot. By which I do not mean doing a lot of stuff in the middle of an over the head project. Go to the driving range. But you know, very few people will ever do it. I'm teaching one daughter archery, and we have been discussing how Zen in the Art of Archery, says, strength, form, hit stuff, while most people start trying to hit stuff, move on to form, and probably never are strong enough to handle the bow. Archery, and everything else, is way more complicated than that. The hit stuff, aiming thing, is the last thing on a very complex pyramid, but it is the first thing people try for.

But the gunslinging thing is another thing entirely. I want to sit down in front of a 48 hour John Wayne marathon, or whatever, and hold a chisel in my hand and just do spins with it. So at the end of the day it is an extension of my body. Won't do a thing as far as practice is concerned, I just want to have the ease with the whole thing.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#10

Re: Whoo. Now we're talking!

CStan

99% of it is making marks on the wood in the right spots and cutting up to, but not over those marks, all with a modest kit of tools that a budding craftsman, by definition, will get to know intimately if the kit isn't constantly being turned over with tool purchases and sales.

The biggest enemy of achieving a decent level of craftsmanship and productivity is the lure of constantly fooling with tools - new tools, vintage tools, make your own tools, shop for tools, staying on top of new tools, tools, tools, tools.

If someone works wood enough, pain usually tells them when they're doing something wrong. Waking up with 'the claw' in the morning usually indicates saws and chisels are being held too tightly. Learning to work to prevent sheer fatigue is teacher enough.

The whole Zen and the tool is an extension of my body stuff gets a little creepy when it passes a certain point. It probably all sounds fine if you're Art Carpenter or somebody like that - a bona fide artist whose chosen media happens to be wood. Not so cool if you're copying Shaker and Arts and Crafts rectilinear stuff by the truckload.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#11

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#12

Re: I truly love slow practice

TomD

I remember one guitar guy saying the key was to play the piece backwards.

By the way, my family has two real virtuoso piano players. My mom was also good, but a little thin skinned. She gave up piano when she was playing Scarlatti exercises of some type. and the chameleon we had turned black in protest. It was our observation that their colour changes were mood driven, not camo related. That was a new excuse to me.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#13

Re: Whoo. Now we're talking!

TomD

"The whole Zen and the tool is an extension of my body stuff gets a little creepy when it passes a certain point. It probably all sounds fine if you're Art Carpenter or somebody like that - a bona fide artist whose chosen media happens to be wood. Not so cool if you're copying Shaker and Arts and Crafts rectilinear stuff by the truckload."

A lot of that generation were more pragmatic. There probably aren't many points in flipping chisels. On the other hand, you watch my mother knit, which is mostly something she does so she can justify non-academic reading, and it looks way more competent than Klausz or Odate put together. This was just some home economics thing people her age were taught. So perhaps before we erect barriers to further progress we should determine what is the level beyond which we should feel embarrassed, because I rarely seen guys who are there. Driving is another example. High level of skill combined with a fair amount of gutsy behaviour, regarded as normal.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#14

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Posture

#15

Re: Chromataphoric dissent

TomD

She wishes, it was the playing that turned him black.