New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

thanks for help

Posts

thanks for help

#1

thanks for help

eliot d

> Thanks for your note; you have stuck with me throughout the whole thing! It

> is a bit crazy, but I do indeed consider it a minor triumph; I became more

> or less obsessed. I couldn't have done it without your help. Now I have to

> put in a pin, sharpen and fit the sub iron, flatten and scallop the sole,

> and do some subtle stuff that I know you know about, like cutting those

> small "squares" at the sides of the mouth, etc, etc. Probably wait till I

> get back to MD.

>

> I did the whole thing with exactly three Ohchi chisels, one Greenlee that I

> picked up by pure luck at the Junk Shop in Canton,CT, one 3 mm Sorby chisel,

> and a blunt-sharpened file ( used it a lot) , and a few assorted marking and

> angle measuring tools. Didn't have much luck with dry erase marker; did

> better with ordinary soft pencil graphite. Never got around to trying candle

> soot.

>

> I do have the feeling that not many woodworkers over here-- even on the

> superb WoodCentral site -- have done it. I know Stu, for example, hasn't. Of

> course, I'm furious with you for telling me that " chiseling out a golf-ball

> size wedge" was not much! Are you kidding? It was a bear to get right! But I

> certainly got my feet wet using chisels and the blunt chisel thing. A real

> experience! Now I have to start thinking about starting all over on fine

> Japanese white oak. But I'm going to take a break for a while here in CT.

>

> I'm going to switch to my other interest-- I paint mostly so-called

> non-objective ( totally abstract) stuff usually on paper. I've gotten into a

> few juried shows, but Kandinsky I"m not!

>

> Anyway, thanks for all your interest and encouragement!

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>>

>

Re: thanks for help

#2

Re: thanks for help

TomD

"> I do have the feeling that not many woodworkers over here-- even on the

> superb WoodCentral site -- have done it. I know Stu, for example, hasn't. Of

> course, I'm furious with you for telling me that " chiseling out a golf-ball

> size wedge" was not much! Are you kidding? It was a bear to get right! But I

> certainly got my feet wet using chisels and the blunt chisel thing. A real

> experience! Now I have to start thinking about starting all over on fine

> Japanese white oak. But I'm going to take a break for a while here in CT."

You rock as the kids say (they would probably deny saying it).

On chiselling out the small piece of oak. Way! Look at the recent Sellers post in which he removes a piece of wood about the same as yours (width is 3/8 but square, and he does 2 of them, so that is about 1 1/2" width similar to yours, in 8 minutes. One key to speed is to go after the right size chip. In the musical instrument business a number of custom makers used violin size micro voicing planes to waste the wood on jazz guitar plates. Then they get repetitive stress injuries. That probably doesn't happen much any more, more an 80s or 90s thing. But I don't see many using an adze either.

I would still get some 2x4 and make like George Washington in a cherry grove, before I tried that fancy piece of wood. Get some chips flying.

Have fun with the hiatus!

Re: thanks for help

#3

Re: thanks for help

eliot d

I guess you're trying to tell me that I'm not quite ready for the good wood yet. You know, I kind of, sort of, got the same response when I went to buy the wood from Suzuki in California. She tried to tell me that her Japanese kanna-making friends suggested that I use just whatever local wood was around my house. I told he that my wife, Claudia, was insulted that someone would suggest "ordinary" wood for a fine dai, and she immediately relented and sold me two fine blocks of Japanese oak! I suppose it wouldn't hurt me to do another one from some local wood. But I may just go ahead and defy the odds and do it with one of the good blocks; I did learn a lot form this first one. Thanks again for your attention.

Re: thanks for help

#4

Re: thanks for help

TomD

Actually I was not suggesting that. I was more worried about the whole time on task thing. One way to speed up is to practice, and get a feel for when you can go fast and when you have to scale down to micron removal. There is a place for each, though not in each other's place. My concern is more if a person wants to learn how to chop down a tree, they can't learn the axework by using a less risky alternative like a saw. But maybe they won't learn it that well by trying to chop down a tree that is circled on 3 sides with electrical wires. Practice makes perfect, then take the skills to the big time.

I think there is something to be said for the idea that certain things should be saved for later, when one deserves them. But:

- I am not sure how special that wood is.

- Also there are certain tasks where a beginner, while making heavy weather of them can still do a virtually indistinguishable job if they try. I have seen some amazing guitars, and canoes made by people who had never woodworked before.I am not sure Japanese planes are 100% that way, but you can make a decent one.

- Also, the first Japanese plane I ever made, I still use. I guess I am glad I made it in white oak and thereby know that works OK, but I have also been using this tool for 30 years, and part of me wishes I had used the "good stuff"

- Also, the final strokes are what determine the result, and those are undertaken by people who buy Japanese planes from sellers who never question them. Those people are far less prepared, conceptually and possibly technically than someone proceeding from scratch as you have.

Re: thanks for help

#5

Re: thanks for help

eliot d

You mention first guitars. I have made two of them. I showed the first one to a real pro , who praised it and then told me that it would probably take me another 20 years to do one as well!

Back to the dai, I wonder if there is something to be said for taking most of the wood out with some sort of power tool and then doing the fine work by hand. Is that ever done? I thought of repeated cuts across the width of the dai with a 'V' -shaped router bit: You could easily get a 45 degree ramp with a 45 degree 'V' by moving it over and down the ramp, over and down the ramp, etc. I suppose this would be cheating, but the real magic occurs only at the final steps anyway. what do you think?

Re: thanks for help

#6

Re: thanks for help

TomD

The pros use a machine that hogs out the basic ramping step. Dave here has one. Inamoto, can be seen without a few fingers on his hammer hand, and it is one of these machines that did that.

Simpler options are to use a mortise machine, to trench in a relief column, so the chips come out more easily. This can go all the way through, for some planes. One can also use a mortising machine with jig, or inclining head, or table to cut the ramps right down. There are other options out there.

On the other hand it should probably come out in a few minutes so whether one is ahead by substituting machines for skill is a question. There is almost always a machine that will do something, but at some point one gets to cherishing the opportunity to use the hand tools in practice situations if one ever wants to actually get the skills together.