New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

The "black translucent arkansas"

Posts

The "black translucent arkansas"

#1

The "black translucent arkansas"

david weaver

I yammed on about a black translucent arkansas in an earlier thread. It arrived.

Not a big fan so far!

I don't see much of any translucence, and while the density is in the right range (it's 2.85 specific gravity based on its weight), it does feel like a fine hard gray arkansas stone, but not as fine as a translucent. It might be comparable to the newly cut black ark I had in the past.

It will get finer as time goes on, and probably be decent to use, but it is a touch more coarse than the norton translucent and 2 or 3 times as coarse as the dan's translucent I got when sierra trading post was blowing those out for $37.

It can be hard to tell when stones are new, though, especially if they come off of a diamond cutting machine, which leaves a dry powder of the stone on the surface and leaves the surface pretty coarse. I read somewhere that dan's laps their stones, maybe that's why they feel so fine, but the dan's stone I got went much finer with use.

The search continues for a good vintage black arkansas stone.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#3

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

CStan

In my case, ignorance is apparently bliss. I have a black Ark, a Norton bought from TFWW. It's sort of translucent at the edges but not in the body of the stone. It's probably about like the one you aren't thrilled with. All I know is that it's finer than the stone I use before it and it'll raise a burr with a little rubbing. Seems about right.

Good luck with the Holy Grail.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#4

Re: I found the boxes and wrappers...

joel moskowitz

"Behr-Manning"

means it's a Norton Stone.

Behr-Manning was their distributor in some markets. Norton eventually bought them out.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#5

Re: I found the boxes and wrappers...

david weaver

Just the edges are translucent, and just a little. As you've probably found out, it'll be 6 months or so before I know what it really is. The dan's translucent that I had was so fine grained you could tell it was great right away. The norton translucent was fine, too, but it was bettered by the dans stone in fineness to the point you could skip stropping after it.

But backing away, all of my japanese stones (the natural ones) are better than the arkansas stones that I have, finer and faster for their fineness.

And the spyderco glazed over is finer than anything else I have short of green chromium oxide, and that might be a close contest with just a little something on the surface of the spyderco.

I think you're right about the pat thing, I may end up going that route.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#6

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

david weaver

If there is such a thing as a holy grail, I already have it. This stone will get better, it's just starting from a lower point some of my other stones started from.

This is just play. I'd make a golf equivalence, but I usually turn over a set of golf clubs about once every 10 years, I don't have the same curiosity about it.

Why do you want a burr off your finish stone?

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#7

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

CStan

I want a burr, a scratchy sort of thing, so I'll know I'm not rounding the edge. I couldn't care less about imparting a high degree of polish.

A lot of times I just stop with a No. 1 Washita which produces a burr in a hurry. Removing bluntness is 99% of the exercise, the rest is basically time spent not necessarily rewarded on a one-to-one basis with edge longevity or even better performance, tool on wood (serrated edges, relatively speaking, cut just fine). I don't look the gift of a tame board in the mouth, I just go with it. My budget, even when working on a paying basis, doesn't always allow laying in a stock of expensive, beautiful but gnarly tropicals and highly figured domestic woods like so many here seem to have an endless supply of. The vast majority of the time I don't need an edge with a glowing halo from God around it. As such, I don't worry about trying.

That said, I suppose I could rub on the Arky (they are slow cutting things you know) until my arms ached just like anybody could. I just usually don't want to nor have a need to. Honestly, it's usually an attention thing. Honing bores me to absolute tears. The longer I stand there the more likely I am to blunt whatever I'm trying to get sharp.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#8

That is roughly what I do too...

John in NM

Only I use a soft Arkansas because that's the one I have - friend of my dad's gave it to me years ago when he switched to those nickel plated diamond plates for his knives. I have a coarse synthetic for rough honing, then the soft Arkansas for fine. Works for 99% of my needs.

When I need polish for some fancy smoothing, I hollow grind and buff the edge with a hard felt wheel and some stainless polishing compound on a hand cranker. Talk about a fast edge :D

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#9

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

david weaver

There was like 10x as much said there as there needed to be.

That sounds like a false dilemma, fast or sharp.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#10

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

CStan

Whatever you say 'bro.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#11

Re: That is roughly what I do too...

CStan

My Washita definitely has a good side and a "bad" side. 'cept I like the toothier, dragier bad side. I form a burr on that side very quickly and then flip the stone over and take a few strokes on the 'good' side. It's almost like having two stones.

I keep it wrapped in a red shop rag from Auto Zone. It's not boxed. I just plop it down, rag and all, on my Workmate and do my thing. If the burr is a little too distinct it takes the black Arky and a strop to flex it off. Once the burr gets a certain size it seems to take too long to get it to break off on the Washita.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#12

Sharp isn't a binary quantity

John in NM

There is a huge continuum between dull and as sharp as possible, and for a lot of us who build things with edge tools, a medium grit is simply good enough for an awful lot of work. A polished edge simply is not necessary for a glue surface, inside rail surfaces, the underside of tops, and so on.

I suppose there are similarly large degrees of dull too (sharpening conversations put to one side :D ) but no one is interested in that direction.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#13

Re: Sharp isn't a binary quantity

CStan

Diminishing marginal returns and the risk of putting blunt what I just made sharp - reason No. 1 and No 2 for me.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#14

Must be a run on em

ron in Kokomo

I looked again on Ebay last night to try to help you find one. Dearth of Arkansas stones of any kind except for the small ones for pocket knives.

I still think some of the old tool dealers like Leach or Donnelly are going to help you within a month or so, if you ask them to be on the lookout. They cast a pretty wide net.

Ron

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#15

Re: Must be a run on em

david weaver

I would imagine the recent uptick on the blogroll (I have seen several people mention on the forums that they wanted to try oilstones because several of the bloggers have returned to them) has made stones harder to get and more expensive, especially the vintage black or any translucents.

There is also a push for them on razor forums lately, which also goes up and down.

Trouble with both internet grups (wwers and shavers) is obviously that positive press sends people right to ebay, and the razor people have deep pockets. The only 8x2x1 available on ebay is from a random seller who lives in arkansas, a white translucent, $169 or something like that, and several have sold. It's one thing for them to be listed at that, but another when they start selling there.

For comparison, my dan's HTA 8x2x1/2 (which is now down the road) was $37 from sierra trading post. It was a *very* good stone, the kind you can add to a regimen like charles describes literally lifting a tool and wiping the edge for 5 seconds to remove the wire edge.

It's just a curiosity want, anyway, I'll wait until the craze is over and if it never ends, it's no big deal.

Thanks for looking, though.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#16

Re: Must be a run on em

Ron in Kokomo

I switched back to Arkansas stones for several reasons. Cheapest least hassle method. I get plane irons that will smooth curly maple with no tear out at all. Plenty good enough for me. Is there a way to get the sharper? Don't care.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#17

Re: Must be a run on em

TomD

You can't argue that they are good enough. There was a world before waterstones, and it was one of far greater achievement in wood, in the West. I went back to oil stones for winters, a while back, but then drifted to sandpaper, and then diamonds. It doesn't really mater. There comes a point where you are no longer reaching, and know you are going to get the job done.

Re: The "black translucent arkansas"

#18

Re: The reaching point..

david weaver

..should be after your first sharpening session if you've done a little study about it.

I never worked with a hand tool before buying my first plane on the advice of someone else. A buddy gave me the charlesworth DVD and I bought some of the cheaper king stones, and had a shaving sharp edge the first time (I followed the instructions on preparing an iron to the letter, which took 45 minutes).

Since then, it's been all about curiosity, and while the natural stones are plenty capable, I think the ones that can be bought reasonably by us are outclassed by the synthetics - signficantly. Most of the better mines in japan have been played out in their ultra high-class layers, and what's left is super-hard asagi stones. Supposedly the novaculite stones of vintage were better (which makes sense, as it did with the japanese stones, why would miners in the past who know a LOT about the stones and their use not take the best ones first).

Coticules are hardly mined at all because the miner would rather mine architectural stones from their mines, and I guess the super stones from thuringia are played out, too. Mining of new cotis appears to be incidental, which cuts the supply and makes them really expensive.

I get the sense from old catalogs and old instruction material that even 200 years ago, people were nutty for the best stones. The barbering manual (aimed at barbers, not consumers) that I have (1890s or so, maybe very early 1900s) stresses that no barber should work with an inferior hone and suggests using thuringias (escher brand would've probably been the popular one then) and "strange mystery hones from japan", as most of the problems described in honing (edge chipping, "overhoning", etc) don't exist with those two types of stones.

I think stuff like that is interesting, even though it's not necessary for woodworking at all.