New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

New article is up! *LINK*

Posts

New article is up! *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

New article is up! *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Hi folks,

We've just uploaded David Weaver's new article on Setting a Cap Iron to our articles department. It is a recap of the chipbreaker/capiron research done by Profs. Kato and Kawai that we've been discussing here for the past three months. David talks about how he puts the "cap iron effect" to practical use, to prevent or at least drastically reduce tearout.

Thanks to everyone who participated in the research, the ensuing discussions, and the production of this article. The primary contributors are mentioned and credited in the article.

Ellis




"Setting a Cap Iron"

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#3

Re: Thanks to everyone else more..

david weaver

I literally only came up with the text. All of the editing to make it readable, all of the diagrams, pictures, links, credits, etc, came from the efforts of everyone else involved - a considerable task on their part.

As a lazy man of the first order, it is nice to have that kind of support. The by line should probably credit everyone involved.

(oh yeah, and thanks for the compliment, btw).

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#4

Re: New articles?

William Duffield

Does this mean you've found an article editor? That would be a major advancement!

I see only two articles published on WoodCentral this year, none last year and only four in 2010.

I was almost considering starting my own blog, but who would vet it, and who would read it, and who needs another woodworking blog anyway? I don't have time to check all the woodworking blogs I have on my list now.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#5

Thanks and a question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

David -

Let me join the chorus of thank yous. I had been wishing this could happen and I appreciate your labors.

But I do have a question. In the "Now you see it, now you don't" paragraph you say to set the cap iron back "just .1 mm (~.004")". That is 1/256 ". That's pretty small. I'm not sure I have any rulers in the shop that go that small. Is that really what you mean.

Just checking.

Thanks again,

Dave

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#6

Re: Thanks and a question

david weaver

Well, those pictures and the caption are actually Ellis's contribution, so I'm assuming that he set his plane there. Maybe he can clarify.

But .004 or so is not too difficult to do. It's really just a tiny touch more than not being able to see the back of the iron glint back at you at all. It'll get to the point where you are accidentally probably setting an iron closer than that once you've done some repetitions of setting the cap iron as close as possible.

One thing we wanted to get away from is measuring anything, you only need to know the .004 number to know that it's .004 and not .04, etc. Your real hands-on approach should be to set it as close as you can and see what the results are. I guess it will depend on your eyes and light source, but if you set it as close as you can without spending several minutes to get there, you'll probably be in the ball park. You can forget, though, about trying to measure something that small if you follow that.

Then you can see what the shaving does, if it bunches up, you're too close. If you take a fairly coarse shaving and it still curls up nicely like a single iron shaving would, then you know you're probably not set close enough to have the cap iron doing anything other than protecting you from getting gigantic tearout if you accidentally set a deep cut when adjusting the plane.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#7

Re: By the way..

david weaver

... in the picture credited to steve, with the cap iron set, I think that set is probably in the range of .008" or something like that. You can go less than that if you want to set really tight (steve can clarify if that's about what the picture shown is displaying).

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#8

Ellis Walentine

Exactly

Ellis Walentine

The major findings in this paper were that a cap iron had to be set back a distance comparable to the thickness of the shaving. If you're flattening something and taking .004" shavings, you would want a setback in the .004" -.005" range to get the cap iron effect.

It all varies with the wood and the thickness of the shavings.

Ellis

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#9

About that picture . . .

Steve Elliott

The cap iron in the picture was set .007" from the blade edge at the center, and more than that at the blade edges because the cap iron has a bit of camber. This was measured using a microscope.

In the camera image, counting pixels and comparing the 2" blade width, the set appeared to be .012" in the center. I can't explain the discrepancy, but the microscope was more accurate.

The image that appears in the article has been altered slightly in Photoshop to make it look the way the blade looked to me as I held it in my hand. I usually don't alter images but in this case it seemed appropriate.

The "ballpark" for cap iron distance is about the thickness of a business card or 3x5 index card. If you're old like me you might need reading glasses but not a microscope. David is right about watching the shaving and the wood surface, they're the real guides.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#10

Re: Exactly

david weaver

One thing that we will probably find out is that everyone will either do something a little different or do something that feels a little different.

I have, in my thoughts and attempts (like I said, I haven't measured anything, if for no other reason, just to avoid touching the edge of an iron that is in perfect shape) kept the cap iron set close to about 2 times the thickness of the thicker shavings, which I guess protects against bad tearout in a thick shaving, but in a thinner one allows the sharpness of the iron maybe to control a little more. It's hard to say exactly what's going on, but we don't need to be an expert of which part of the whole assembly is preventing tearout, but rather what the result is.

And I think that's where warren comes in with saying that it becomes difficult to communicate what you do in bullet point fashion, it will be built on experience tempered by results rather than specific method.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#12

Thanks David et al

Larry Barrett

This article really sums up the discussions in a very readable and understandable way. The tip to undercut the cap iron a bit is useful and maybe new - I don't recall reading that in the earlier discussions.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#13

Not Exactly

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The Kato study reported a good surface was obtained with a .004 shaving thickness and a .012 cap iron setting. The cap iron distance was three times the shaving thickness. Furthermore, Kato did not test with .016 and find it insufficient. My experience is that putting the cap iron the same as the shaving thickness does not yield the best surface.

About five years ago a Chris Schwartz blog stated that according to Kato the cap iron needed to be within .004 inches to be effective. I knew from experience that this was not true, so I read the Kato study myself. I then responded that anyone who thought the setting needed to be within .004 ought to reread the Kato study. Raney Nelson reread the study and apologized, but many people to this day continue to quote the faulty .004 information.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#14

I'm with Warren here

Steve Elliott

I recently set a cap iron at .008" and took a shaving about .006" thick, which came out crumpled. When I reduced the shaving thickness to .004" the plane left a good surface in hard maple with extremely adverse grain angle. That shaving was more or less straight.

I think a cap iron setting about twice the shaving thickness is more like it although I don't have the range of experience Warren does.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#15

Ellis Walentine

Well then, ...

Ellis Walentine

... what is the best way to summarize the Kato findings? Is there more than one answer?

Ellis

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#16

what the Japanese do

Bill Tindall

Kato and Kawai wrote a paper to teach how to set the cap iron. It is partially translated and very confusing. I think they are looking at shavings as a metric but there is a ton of force data in the paper so maybe they are suggesting something about the feel of the plane is used to judge when it is optimum. I will "take the bull by the horns" and have Mia ask them how to set up a plane to get the most effective cap iron effect and see what they say.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#17

Re: Well then, ...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Kato's study showed the effectiveness of the double iron plane for controlling tear out and gave insight into how it worked. He did not study the range of shaving thickness or the variety of species or the variety of grain configurations that a woodworker faces.

I think those who insist on a formula for setting the cap iron will not get optimum results, that it is better to get a feel for the various situations and to get feedback from the surface and the shavings. In any woodworking it is helpful to have experience with the species at hand. Peter Nicholson wrote in 1812:

The distance between the cutting edge of the iron, and the edge of the cover [cap iron], depends altogether on the nature of the stuff.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#18

yes but.....

Bill Tindall

In a paper we have only partially translated they did study these variables. The objective of the paper was to teach how to set the cap iron. The paper is very confusing. The English abstract seems to have little to do with the paper and it is hardly related to our translation of the Japanese abstract . The paper has many graphs of the force on the plane iron vs various variables. The forces always shoot up abruptly as the cap iron is made close to the edge as one might expect when the cap iron started pushing the shaving back into the wood. They also measure shaving length and similarly saw an abrupt decrease in shaving length caused by it scrunching up Accordion style. But we never could understand how these data were being used to set the cap iron. They did specifically say that the cap iron was not set according to some measurement from the blade tip. Clearly they took a test cut, determined some property unclear to me and then refined the cap iron setting. I have sent an email to them asking for clarification.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#19

Re: yes but.....

James Watriss

My experience so far is that an accordion shaving means the cap iron is too close. Either back off the blade or the cap iron.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#20

Question

Bill Tindall

With the Japanese planes they are using would it be feasible to incrementally adjust the cap iron to where the scrunched shavings occurred and then reliably/conveniently back of the cap iron a bit? I ask because this procedure may be what they are describing in the paper. Again the paper has tons of data on the shavings length and forces on blade as the cap iron is moved to various positions under various conditions. Somewhere buried in there is a conclusion(I suppose) I have yet to find from the quick translation Mia did.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#21

Re: Question

TomD

I don't do it that way. It is easy to selectively lower the blade or the cap iron, the reverse gear is to hit the back of the plane, this jumps both settings back, you can put hand pressure on the blade and maybe get a differential adjustment. I am not aware of anything you can hit on the blade or breaker to pull it back by itself. I always set blades on wooden planes on the downstroke. If I overshoot I back out and start all over, but I rarely ever overshoot. Maybe someone else has a solution. Oh, one can walk parts a bit by hitting them on the sides, but I prefer the control I get setting things on the downstroke, however one can try side tapping and if it works, nothing is lost.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#22

Re: Well then, ...

AlanWS

You can say that the cap iron (chipbreaker, or whatever you want to call it) should be set on the order to the thickness of the shaving from the edge. This does not say the distances are equal, but that they are of similar size.

You could say that the chipbreaker should be set close enough to the edge that bending the shaving will apply downward force to the stock in front of the edge. Stated this way, it's easy to see that with a very thin and easily bent shaving, this distance will likely be very close to the shaving thickness, but as the shaving gets thicker and stiffer, the distance may increase more.

I think people focus on the short end of the range because that is seen as more challenging to set, and applicable to the most difficult stock.

I think it's interesting that these results emphasize the importance of being able to set a plane with a hammer, even though they show the utility of metal planes that are usually set by knobs instead. That's because the simplest controllable way to set cap iron position from the edge is using a hammer.

Re: New article is up! *LINK*

#23

Experience setting with a hammer

Steve Elliott

My favorite planes don't have blade adjusters so I normally set shaving thickness using a brass or steel hammer to tap the blade or a strike button on the back of the plane. When I have a cap iron set close to the edge its setting can be changed by tapping the blade into position. Several times I've had disappointing results from a closely set cap iron, only to discover afterwards that the cap iron distance had been increased when I tapped the blade into position.

I now tighten the cap iron screw down as hard as I can and use lighter taps on the blade to adjust it.