New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Wood movement, cherry

Posts

Wood movement, cherry

#1

Wood movement, cherry

Joe Grittani

I'm making a new top for an antique drop leaf cherry table. The top itself is made of two boards and

is 19 1/2 wide and about 13/16" thick. The original top was screwed to the aprons from underneath. I'm trying to figure out if this willl work with the new top, but have no idea how much seasonal movement to expect from the cherry. I don't have a way to measure moisture content.

Due to the design of the leaf supports, attachment points are limited. The original configuration was two screws on each side and one on each end.

I'd appreciate any info you could give me on the movement I might expect.

TIA.

Joe Grittani in balmy Dayton, Ohio

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#2

Re: Wood movement, cherry

Bruce, a MN Galoot

When I've made solid top tables, I've connected them using screws through small slots cut into the support. The slots allow for seasonal movement. In your case, I'd use three screws across the width, the center one with a simple hole to cut the movement in half, and slots on either end.

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#3

Re: Wood movement, cherry

William Duffield

In general, everything you need to know to calculate how much your table top will move, and therefore the length of the slots Bruce recommends, can be found in Chapter 12, "Drying, Control of Moisture" of "FPL-GTR_113, "Wood Handbook--Wood as an Engineering Material". You can but it on paper from Rob Lee,

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=45997&cat=1,46096,46109

or download it in PDF for free from The USDA Forest Products Lab.

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/products/publications/several_pubs.php?grouping_id=100&header_id=p

From the formulas and tables in this document, you should be able to estimate the equilibrium moisture content of cherry (or other wood you might commonly work) which has been acclimated to your shop, and depending on the month of the year when you build the top, you should be able to estimate the amount of wood movement (both shrinkage and expansion) which will be expected in the location where the table will live. It will let you calculate this for non-climate controlled conditions* and also for centrally heated and air conditioned buildings.

*For example, power was out here recently for seven days, with extremely high temperatures and humidities, and we were lucky. This is what global warming will look like.

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#4

Re: Wood movement, cherry

Bill Tindall

In an air conditioned, hence dehumidified home, you won't see any movement. I have kept track of a 20" piece of walnut for several years and it doesn't move as much as 1/16".

The tables are near useless for estimating. The values tabulated are averages with ranges of up to 30%. If you are making and using the table in typical conditions there will be enough wiggle in the screws to accommodate any movement. If one were making a table in Louisiana and shipping it to Phoenix then you might consider some fastening to accommodate more movement.

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#5

Right On Bill

Bob Lang

As a group we seem to take great comfort in scientific data, numbers and charts. So much that we lose sight of practical experience and historic evidence. I've seen wood move, but never so much as the charts in Hoadley's book, or the online calculators imply. One of the problems with reducing things to a formula is that every board is an individual, and it is an extremely rare case where one individual is a good match to the charts, graphs and calculations.

As I get older, I look more and more to what the original makers did, what worked and what didn't. This often flies in the face of our modern rules. Yes wood moves. Yes extreme and rapid changes in temperature and humidity will make wood move. On the other hand, wood that has been treated well during drying and not worked when in motion behaves pretty well.

I would find a nice wide piece of cherry, fasten it securely in the center, allow a bit of wiggle room on the edges and stop worrying.

Bob Lang

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#6

Great Wisdom

Bill Tindall

"As I get older, I look more and more to what the original makers did, what worked and what didn't."

Years ago we had a furniture maker/restorer give programs at our club. The most important thing I learned from him was to look at antiques to see what works and doesn't in furniture. I in an area not blessed with fine antiques but every chance I get when traveling I poke around nice old furniture to see what I can learn.

By the way a great place to see some very fine English furniture is in Shelbyville, KY at the shop where the girls school used to be (Science something or another in center of town on one way street heading west. )

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#7

Re: Right On Bill

Bruce, a MN Galoot

You must not live in an area like the upper great plains, Bob. I don't air condition unless I have to (even these awful, humid days), and the difference between summer humidity and winter humidity is staggering. The dew point ranges from many degrees below zero (with central hot air heat) to 85 last week. I work in an un-air-conditioned garage and my projects live in sometimes air-conditioned homes, sometimes not. (The advantage is that I know for certain that my drawer sides will never bind) What then?

BTW, the method I posted I learned in magazines such as FWW and PWW.

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#8

Re: Right On Bill

Bob Lang

Hi Bruce,

Here in Cincinnati, we have similar extremes, although we're far enough South that AC is needed. I don't think there is really a contradiction between what I've said, either in my response to Bill or in anything I've ever printed and what you're saying. My point is that I think the charts overstate a worst-case scenario, and there is a lot more to what and how a piece of solid wood might do than what the calculations say.

You're absolutely right to do things the way you do, given your decisions about the atmosphere in your home and shop. An online calculator tells me that Joe's cherry top will gain or loose half an inch from summer to winter, and I am saying that the right piece of wood, handled the right way and treated with respect will be OK if fastened in the center and left some "wiggle room" at the edges.

I've done what Bill has done, kept wide cutoffs for a few years and measured now and then. Everybody ought to do that, and use that experience as a guide instead of relying on something printed somewhere.

And Joe should let me know where he's finding wide cherry.

Bob Lang

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#9

Wide cherry- where it went and it is at

Bill Tindall

We sold hardwood lumber for many years and getting cherry with any decent widths was impossible back when it was a hot item and much was being exported to Europe and what used to be good saw logs were being veneered.

Imagine my astonishment when I dropped by Banish Lumber Company in Bristol TN to chat with the owners and encountered a pack of 12" and wider cherry on the yard. And the price was not greatly higher than random width and length packs. There was lumber in the pack 20" wide! I was told that the cherry market is down and better lumber is available. But there is more to the story.....

Related to this incident I found my self seated next to the inventory control person from Bailey Lumber Company at an affair in Greenville, SC. Of course we soon became engaged in a conversation about lumber. This giant sized lumber operation does some sawing but mostly they buy lumber from saw mills and resell it, millions of bdft per year. Some years ago hardwood was bough and sold by National Hardwood Lumber Association grade. A pack of random width and length FAS1F was just that, as it came from the saw mill. Bailey still buys from the mills by grade but then their value added is to repackage this lumber in custom grades for customers. They sell 51 grades of white oak, and 30+ grades in the other species.

So I asked, suppose some local lumber dealer orders a pack of lumber to resell and they order by NHLA grade. What do they get? The answer was that they reassemble a pack of lumber from inventory to "sort of look like a pack of random widths and lengths". But be assured all the wide and figured stuff is no longer in such packs.

This information revealed why when we started selling hardwood lumber years ago that packs of lumber would have wide lumber and maple would have curly lumber, etc. And with the development of huge "repackagers" like Bailey the packs of lumber we ordered were no longer "random widths and lengths" as the saw mill sawed it.

So, if you want wider cherry you need to find a place that is ordering packs of cherry specified to be 12" and wider, or some similar "custom grade". Be assured one will find no such wide lumber in an ordinary pack of lumber unless it didn't pass through a company like Bailey.

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#10

Where the shrinkage Tabes came from

Bill Tindall

Random samples of each species were obtained, measured and then dried to zero per cent moisture. The amount of shrinkage observed was then divided by the moisture loss over the range where shrinkage occurred to get an average shrinkage. Then this value was averaged over the number of specimens tested to get a grand average.

These data are useful for revealing that beech responds more to moisture than cherry. They are useless for predicting how a specific board in a piece of furniture will respond to humidity changes in its environment. And they vastly overestimate the changes likely to occur.

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#11

I don't believe slots work , or are necessary

Bill Tindall

If a top is snugged down to a frame with the typical flat head screw I don't believe the screw head will slide back and forth in a slot if the lumber expands and contracts. Rather I think the screw head will remain fixed and the threads will wiggle back and forth a small amount. I just drill an over sized hole to let the screw wiggle some as needed. It can't wiggle much as its head is seated.

The "L" shaped table top fasteners will enable a top to slide around some if they are not seated securely. But don't see this arrangement on antiques.

Re: Wood movement, cherry

#12

Re: Right On Bill

Joe Grittani

Bob -

Thanks for your comments.

I bought three boards ranging from 11" - 12 1/2" from The Hardwood Store in Enon, Ohio (just northeast of Dayton). They had a huge stack of this stuff and a lot of it was very nice. The boards I bought about two months ago remain dead flat.

They don't always stock this kind of stuff, so a call ahead would be in order. their phone number is

(937) 864-2899.

As per usual, I have no connection, financial, emotional or spiritual, to said vendor.

Joe