New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

Posts

What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#1

What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

david weaver

What are my chances of finding a good vintage black arkansas stone?

I have had a newer halls black arkansas, and I wasn't that impressed with it. It was a decent stone, but it was uninspiring.

I never find any good ones locally here (admittedly, I don't look that often). When I do find oilstones, they are beat up india stones or carborundum stones.

Being the pig that I am, i don't want anything less than 8x2, nor do I want anything more really, I find the wider stones a bit harder to keep dead flat without ever sending them back to something to flatten them (and I've never liked to subject fine natural stones of any type to surface abrading).

I see a lot of people mention that they have vintage ones for sale, but I never find them. Where have people gotten them? Is it a matter of luck?

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#2

No idea really...

John in NM

But I am somewhat amazed at the thought of a black Arkansas stone ever needing to be flattened :D

I have a soft Arkansas and a hard white (probably sold as "translucent" though it isn't - they were hand me downs.). The hard is an uninspiring stone, it's too dense or too polished for honing, really more of a polishing or burnishing stone, hardly ever gets used. I also have a true translucent slipstone that cost about $5 used. The thing is amazing. I'd be all over a vintage one of those, probably skip the black stone entirely, but that's just me.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#3

Re: No idea really...

david weaver

Someday, I'll kick this sharpening stone habit. None of these antique stones will be finer than the 13k sigma power stone, nor finer than the spyderco ultrafine, which will basically turn to glass if you don't scuff the surface of it.

But I do like nice stones, and nice vintage is even better.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#5

Re: You've noticed that, too, have you?

david weaver

Yeah, it gives you a wide range of finishes to work with if you want to play with it. When it's totally fresh, it cuts like an 8k stone - like a very fast 8k stone - and leaves an edge like that.

When it's glazed, if you work with it, you can get a sharper edge than any other synthetic stone that I've ever seen (judging by the hanging hair test - a 25 degree chisel will do HHT-4/5 with it), but it is tricky to use like that and use effectively, and it's not practical.

It makes a decent substrate for diamonds, though, and they don't seem to dig in. Same with a natural stone nagura, it can wake right up with some paste from a nagura on the surface.

I haven't finished a razor on it yet, but I don't know if it cuts fast enough glazed to do that, and I have a lot of purpose-made razor stones that are really nice to use, so I probably won't tinker with it.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#6

Re: I didn't find a vintage black ark..

david weaver

..but I did find a place selling what they call black translucent, it's sort of a bluish black. Something interesting that I haven't seen before, and they had them in 8x2.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#7

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#8

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

James Watriss

I've usually found mine on eBay, but they were usually 6x2.

I buy the cruddy old ones, because they're easy to clean up, and most folks want nice looking ones, so old and cruddy goes for cheap.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#9

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

Patrick Gibbons

This is one case where I think brand may make a difference. A new black hard from Norton I have heard is as good as old. I've never found one in the wild but have an old one from my father. However it's only 1x3 and was used for pocket knives. While it's tough to compare, it doesn't seem to be any better than my new Norton hard translucent 8x3 I got from Joel at Tools for Working Wood. I also can't confirm it's a hard black. That is what my father said and I have wondered if it was a razor stone which used to be commonly available. I think the idea of buying a gunked up one on eBay and cleaning it up makes a lot of sense.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#10

Re: Have to try the nagura on my netsuke knives

david weaver

I only like small diamonds on it, like 0.25 micron powder, which works pretty well in combination with a glazed stone.

As you get the surface of the thing to wear in, you'll notice that if you wipe the swarf off each time, you'll get a glassy surface without the typical discoloration that you get if you abrade the surface and then use the stone.

My stone is almost white again, but the surface is reflective. It is hardly cutting by itself, and I remove any particles from it if I'm actually going to fool around with chasing an edge with it. It cuts so slow that it no longer takes those black tire marks that it quickly loads with when the surface has been refreshed.

it fits right in the context of yesterdays bits about whether we are burnishing the edge, etc.

But at that point when there aren't metal particles on it, but it is shiny and clear on top, that's when it does extraordinary things to edges that are nearly finished already. And it's easier to see what it's doing when the surface has returned closer to clear.

At that point, the diamonds don't seem to stick around in the surface long, because if you wipe them off, it will cut very very little, unlike steel where what's left in the steel keeps cutting and cutting.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#11

Re: Tricky

david weaver

buying a gunked up one on ebay is what I'd like to do, but it might be tough, because it's hard to tell with a loaded stone sometimes even what it is. Some of the india stones are gunked so bad, and worn smooth, that they look like a black ark.

A lot of them are messed up by knife sharpeners, gravers and fish hook sharpening, too.

I have had two trans stones, one norton and one dans. the dan's stone was twice as fine as the nortons, it just seemed like a nicer stone with smaller particles (it was probably a little more dense). I can imagine the same thing would be true for black stones - some deposits will be finer than others.

I ordered the black translucent stone for now, 8x2x1, it was the same price as the norton black ark was. The seller claims their black translucents are their finest stones. We'll see. I saw a picture of one on a razor forum, it was one of the more attractive stones I've ever seen, it just looked like a translucent with a blue/black tint.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#12

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

david weaver

If i do eventually find a vintage black one, I'm also hoping for cruddy and cheap.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#13

Ellis Walentine

Used to have one

Ellis Walentine

I had an 8x2 hard black Arkansas stone that I bought in the late 70s, when Woodcraft was still in Woburn, Massachusetts. I stopped using it because I got into Japanese waterstones around '77 and they cut much faster, with equally impressive results, plus I didn't have to clean oil off my plane irons. All my stones except one were lost in my shop fire in '99, so, unfortunately, I can't sell you mine.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#14

Re: Tricky

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

Ok ...how about a linky so others can take advantage of the supplier.

JR

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#15

Re: Tricky

david weaver

naturalwhetstone.com (it's on the third page of the bench stone section)

http://www.naturalwhetstone.com/productssharpening3.htm

It's not easy to find what they have on their page. I have used them before and the last time I ordered a stone from them, I talked to the owner and got him to cut me exactly what I wanted. They are a small operation, and their prices are all over the board, depending on what they have the best access to, I guess.

The stones they label black translucent are expensive.

I'll report how good the stone is when I get it and use it for a little while, to make sure it's at least as good as the dans HTA that I used to have.

The most important thing, aside from fineness, about the dans and the stones I got from naturalwhetstone before is that they were flat when i got them.

I had huge black arkanasas stone from halls that was an OK stone, but it as 12x3 inches, and it was so far from flat I never did get it fully flattened. It's almost as if it was cut with a loose wandering band and had a very big crown on the surface, with the edges and corners falling way off. It must've been a 16th or more out of flat.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#16

With patience, chances excellent

Ron in Kokomo

First contact Mr. Leach, then his sometime cohort Mr. Donnelly, then hang out on eBay. If you aren't insisting on having one this week, your chances are great.

Re: What are my chances - Vintage Black Arkansas

#17

Re:  With patience, chances excellent

david weaver

I've been combing through things. I figure I have a lifetime to find one.

My black translucent (new, not vintage) arrives today. It'll likely just be a dark translucent, but we'll see. I'm chasing curiosity at this point more than a functional need to sharpen something with an arkansas stone.

But then again, all of us are here chasing curiosity of some type, because very few of us actually "need" to woodwork or do any of this stuff. We could sit on the deck drinking beer in the sun instead. Something drives us all, even if we rarely agree on anything collectively.