New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Roubo mortising

Posts

Roubo mortising

#1

Roubo mortising

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is a drawing from Roubo (1769)



Here is what I like about the drawing:

1. Posture, most important. This fellow has a really comfortable upright posture. Many people today are quite bent over, with their head practically on top of the chisel. Roubo shows a posture that is much less tiring.

2. Left arm. Well away from body, not cramped against his side.

3. Mallet. Short handle with a heavy head. It has a much shorter handle than a hammer and is not swung like a hammer.

4. Left hand. On the handle of the chisel a little away from the head. Affords good control.

Another traditional posture involves sitting either right on or right next to the piece to be mortised, either on a mortising bench or the edge of a workbench. Helpful not to bend over with this method also.Here is Roubo's mortise chisel.


Re: Roubo mortising

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Roubo mortising

#3

Re: Excellent observations

john sayles

another observation:

The chopping is being done directly over the leg of the bench for maximum support.

Re: Roubo mortising

#4

Stephen Shepherd

Another observation

Stephen Shepherd

He is standing like he is shooting a rifle.

Stephen

Re: Roubo mortising

#5

Re: Roubo mortising

James Watriss

Dealt with that earlier this week... Pigsticker chisels had to be malleted at about nipple height. Posture was defined for me by the tools.

It was almost too high. One more reason for a slightly shorter bench...

Re: Roubo mortising

#6

Re: Roubo mortising

Patrick Gibbons

In Practical Woodworker, edited by Bernard Jones, it is noted that for mortising multiple large boards a mortising stool is used and gives specs for building one. It is only 18 inches high. This was turn of the last century. I have presumed one sits on the bench above the stock but I really don't know. Of course there are many differences in work practice between this and Roubo's time but these were professional craftsmen mortising by hand.

Re: Roubo mortising

#7

Mortising bench

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is a 1st century mortising bench. Note left arm somewhat extended, hand on handle, head not too close.


Re: Roubo mortising

#8

Stephen Shepherd

I tried. *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd

I gave this an attempt, the grip worked out fine, the stance not so much.

Stephen


Mortise like Roubo

Re: Roubo mortising

#9

Re: I tried.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The main thing that caught my attention was the upright and relaxed posture and the arms well away from the body. I have seen pictures of guys really leaning over, which isn't necessary. I was not sure about my stance, so I checked it out this evening. This is pretty much the way I stand with the left foot well ahead and the toes a little turned out. But comfort is the big factor.

One of my neighbors has a millwork shop and once had a 19 year old who was really fast with the table saw. He worked ten hour days plus some evenings and Saturdays. The thing that struck me about him was that he was so relaxed he was practically dancing as he worked. Some of these Roubo characters have that same feeling especially the veneer saw pair. Roubo himself did a lot of the engravings, but not this one and perhaps none of the action drawings.

Re: Roubo mortising

#10

Re: Roubo mortising

CStanford

Yep, they're making millwork. Looks like door stiles. Big chisels for big work.

Re: Roubo mortising

#11

Re: Roubo mortising

CStanford

... I find it interesting that the workpiece is running way off the bench behind the woodworker. I wouldn't put a whole lot of stock in this, but it's clear that what is being mortised is large. If it's an article of furniture it's massive.

Re: Roubo mortising

#12

Re: Roubo mortising

CStanford

... and that is a chisel for making mortises for millwork - doors, etc.

They are not appropriate for mortising the slender legs of a federal piece for example.

Re: Roubo mortising

#13

Re: Roubo mortising

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The mortise chisels in the Seaton chest (1796) are more appropriate for a cabinetmaker, Charles. The 1/4 inch chisel is .20 inches thick, the 9/32 chisel is .25 thick, and the 11/32 chisel is .305 thick. The heavy "joiner's mortise chisels" are a late 19th century introduction and have become "traditional" in the 21st century.

Re: Roubo mortising

#14

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Roubo mortising

Stephen Shepherd

Warren,

You said: 'The heavy "joiner's mortise chisels" are a late 19th century introduction and have become "traditional" in the 21st century.'

Do you mean what people refer to as the 'pig sticker'? Because in Smith's key are illustrated, both several tang versions and one socket version.

Stephen

Re: Roubo mortising

#15

Re: Roubo mortising

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My apologies, Stephen. I haven't looked at Smith's key for many years. I had thought Smith's mortise chisels were lighter than the late 19th century ones.