New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

Posts

Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#1

Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

david weaver

This is something that's bothered me for a while, but I've never seen anything definitive about it - just speculation.

Does anyone have any documentation about whether or not the type of abrasive has a beneficial or negative effect on edge life when a similar degree of sharpness is attained?

It's no secret that I've bought just about every type of stone, and some of them I've seen stuff bordering on hocum where the seller claims that a type of stone makes for longer lasting edges (it's usually attributed to natural stones that don't make grooves as deep).

I have counted strokes off of a shapton 15k before to compare irons, and I don't believe it, but I'd like to see an opinion on it.

Somewhere around 1 micron edges or so is where I don't see any beneficial effect of going finer on a plane iron (because the wear will blast off the fine edge in a hurry, and 1 micron will leave wear more than unform enough).

I have never been able to tell anything other than that an edge that is less sharp will be dull faster. Has there been any scientific documentation related to how that edge is prepared and how resultant wear occurs? (i.e., if the edge has relatively narrow deep grooves like shaptons or diamonds leave, vs. gradual grooves like coticules, arkansas stones or natural japanese stones might leave).

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#2

Data

Bill Tindall

I took some notes from the Tribology book I was reading recently. Somewhere below 10 micron the mode of abrasion can change from milling out shavings of metal to another kind of abrasion. It all had to do with the surface energy to separate tiny "chips" from the bulk metal. Apparently this activity gets very unfavorable at a small scale. The hardness and shape of the abrasive grit affects the cross over point. Unfortunately there were no further details provided. These must be found in some source that goes deeper into the topic.

The bottom line is that the surface worked by this or that abrasive could be different depending on the abrasive hardness and shape.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#3

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

Schtoo

Only hear-say information, but from folks who take sharpening seriously enough that they make most folks you've ever heard of look like they barely just learned to stop peeing in their shorts when it comes to sharpening tools.

It can and does make a difference, but only if the human driving the plane actually knows what they're doing when it comes to both making the blade sharp and also making the blade blunt.

Or in other words, it's largely academic. Kind of. Sort of.

Stu.

I spent my Sunday waving the Western plane flag in the heart of kanna country.

Photo courtesy of Tsunesaburo.

(That's a picture of an Anniversary Clifton #6 with it's guts laid bare. Beautiful plane.)

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#4

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

david weaver

Yeah, when someone can get an edge on a razor that is both super keen and smooth (comfortable in a shave, not a blindingly sharp but rough-feeling weeper-maker) at the same time, that's about the point where I start listening. It probably wasn't until about 3 months ago that I got to the point where I feel like I could pick up any razor and get that kind of edge out of it without question.

I can definitely feel the difference in stones - EASILY - when I shave. The aggressive stone are very hard on your face if you only strop them on bare leather (the chosera and shapton 15k are both harsh, I haven't tried the SP 13k yet without cleaning up the edge with chromium oxide).

But in medium hardwoods, the wear overtakes a fine edge so fast that there are precious few strokes where the different starting edge (though I can see the difference in the finish on the shavings on my natural stones vs. artificial stones when both are freshly sharpened).

All of that said, I haven't really noticed any difference in edge longevity between stones over here, though shaving has taught me several things about the "sharp vs. shiny" debate. All of the japanese razor stones once taken to clear water will polish a bright finish if they are fine stones, even though they are gentle on an edge and leaving a shallow-grooved finished edge. And so far, every one that I have tried is still improved by chromium oxide powder on balsa (both the polish and the level of sharpness). I hate to say that with as much money as I have spent, but it is true.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#5

More

Bill Tindall

There is no chance of the milling- a- shaving- out mode of sharpening unless the abrasive particle is 25% harder (rule of thumb according to the book) than the steel. When the abrasive can't mill a chip out other mechanisms of abrasion become important. The surface of the metal can become work hardened and the texture of the surface can become different. The "natural" stones are no harder than some of the crystal structures that could be in your steel. These stones could therefore result in a surface different from that produced by say diamonds.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#6

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

Schtoo

I don't have any evidence to back up anything, but...

That chunk of wood in the vise is hinoki, a moderately hard softwood. It's full quatersawn, and the grain is wavy. I'm using it for folks to plane for fun, but it's a very, very expensive piece of wood if, IF, I actually paid for it.

Also, it's completely unforgiving of a non-sharp blade. Doesn't matter what the heck you do with pitch, chip breaker or anything else, if the blade is sharp and the cut if fine, it'll plane cleanly in any direction. If the blade isn't properly sharp, you'll get tearing and a gappy shaving out of it.

I've planed plenty of wood, as have some folks who had a play with the planes (guy in the green shirt, if you ever meet him and he says something, pay attention. Very, very close attention) and we were all surprised at how that piece of wood behaved, simply because it's not easy to find wood that 'nice' nor so good at being a diagnostic tool.

But fresh off the stones, there is no real difference. Even 'meh' stones will get a blade sharp enough to do the job on that plank.

It's after taking off an inch or so, 0.001" at a time that you start seeing what difference the sharpening method actually makes, with no other variable involved. Same planes, same blades, same shaving thickness and end result on the wood, just different stones.

Oh, thinnest shaving I can get off that plank without the shaving being just dust is approximately 10 microns. The shaving looks like lace/tissue and the surface is absolutely polished. Completely pointless, but it's cool to look at and cool to play with. It also earns brownie points here, so it's not that useless...

Stu.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#7

Re: More

Schtoo

Bill,

I'm surprised to see someone actually write this down, other than myself.

Completely speculative, but something tells me that sharpening isn't always just cutting away what's not the edge, but also doing something to the edge that doesn't remove metal. Polishing, burnishing, localised work hardening. I don't know, but these kinds of things are why I don't disregard any of the 'lore' willy nilly.

This kind of speculation is also why I'm not completely oblivious to the charms of a good oilstone. Granted, they don't 'cut' so well, but maybe it's not 'cutting' they're actually meant to be doing.

(But also why they don't get on all that well with complex alloy steels.)

Will be interesting to see what transpires. :)

Stu.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#8

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#9

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

david weaver

That is in the ballpark of 4 ten thousandths. It all depends on the wood, I guess, there are things easier than hinoki (strange that's the wood, I have one literally outside my front door - grows quite well over here, but I can see why it would be expensive) to get a thinner shaving with, though.

I have had two people tell me that they were looking for a better edge when they were able to get 3 or 4 ten thousandth inch thick shavings from a board -I have *no clue* what they were searching for. .0002? They'll be disappointed when they find out that you can't really go much thinner than that without a lot of fidgeting and wood selection.

I'd consider .0003-.0004 to be the results you'd get from good stones (1 micron, etc) in a medium hardwood. You can't get much thinner than that with a common plane and a common wood, at least not with a quick routine sharpening.

But I definitely haven't tried hinoki, it's probably harder to get a uniform shaving with that than it is with soft maple or cherry.

I wonder what those guys thought of the clifton. Did they think it was kind of awkward?

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#10

Re: Stropped edges...

david weaver

I can tell you from experience, that with bare horse leather, the edge that is left after stropping is definitely sharper than it is without stropping.

But in wood, I haven't found any extra edge life over a shapton 15k edge that is either palm stropped or just lightly pulled along its length in a piece of pine to remove any remaining burr.

When shaving, if the leather is good, there is an easily noticed step up in sharpness on a piece of worn horse butt that is clean (I mean dead clean, no dust, no compound, etc) even coming off of chromium oxide that was appled to a forgiving surface. Fresh horse butt will decrease sharpness, and any strop with any dirt in it at all will, too, the strop must be worn smooth and be clean, which isn't really practical in a shop.

My shaving strop hangs vertically in closet so that it stays clean. It is unfinished vegetable tanned horse butt that I bought off of ebay, and it was fairly abrasive when it was new. the surface of it is reflective now, and it does wonderful things to a razor edge.

A shapton makes a smoother edge than diamonds, though (presume you're using diamonds?) which may be why i don't notice an improvement in wood like I do shaving. The wear that happens in shaving is definitely there, but it is miniscule compared to the beating an edge takes going through wood.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#11

Re: More

david weaver

What's being described here (the polishing and work hardening) is definitely what occurs on my natural stones that won't release particles (the antique japanese barber hones, etc). It is definitely different than the plowed furrows that come from diamonds. I'm not debating that.

It's whether or not the resultant edge sticks around long enough to actually make a difference.

I have seen references before to natural stone created edges that folks have claimed to be work hardened. So has such a comment on his page, but I can't remember where.

The very cutting that we see when we first sharpen something doesn't hang around long in medium hardwoods that we often plane, though. Even if it's a bit harder, it is in short order that it disappears based on what I've viewed under a microscope.

But as far as the burnishing and work hardening, definitely. The metal isn't being "cut into" and abraded off fast enough to just disappear before its properties are at least changed a little.

I have put my time in stroke testing A2 before, though, who is going to volunteer to undertake this round of practical testing? :) Not me.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#12

Some notions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David and all,

Edge life for me is how long before the plane stops pulling itself into the wood--at that point, it's ready for sharpening. Others will have a different thought, of course.

Notion 1: Compactness. One notion in my head is that there is a war of sorts between the steel at the blade edge and the wood. That is, the steel is trying to hold its shape as it is forced through the wood, it's trying to minimize the rate of metal loss. But the wood fibres are trying to 'get into' the edge, look for niches or unsupported protrusions, the better to wear or tear at the metal.

In the above view, the steel will be more vulnerable to the wood, the more deeply toothed it is in plan view, and the more deeply incised it is (due to sharpening) in cross-section.

So the most 'compact' edge would be the one with the finest-grained toothing in plan, and the shallowest incising in section.

Which abrasive or combination of abrasives gives the edge steel the most compact form? That seems a primary question. Right off the bat, it would appear that the finer the abrasive, the finer the toothing and incising. But a second consideration is that certain abrasives are sharper, bite deeper, than others.

One other notion that comes to mind:

Notion 2: Does the finest edge hold form longer than a coarser edge? To illustrate, will an edge finished with 1/4micron diamond hold form longer than an edge finished with 1 micron diamond? Or will an edge finished with 15,000g Shapton hold form longer than an edge finished with 8000g Shapton. The test here is not whether the 1/4micron edge or 15000g edge will degrade quickly from ultimate sharpness--of course it will--the test is whether the finer edge remains a little sharper than the less-fine edge, after they have each made the same number of planing passes. [Steve Elliott may have some actual data or at least an informed opinion on this from his experiments.]

Hypothesis 1: The most durable edge is the most compact edge. This is for a given steel.

Hypothesis 2: The most compact edge is the edge with the finest-grained finish.

Then again, maybe none of the above is so. As others have said, the answers will depend as much on anecdotes from experienced practitioners, as on data from controlled experiments. Because there is so much we don't know, such as the exact mechanism of dulling or whether there is work hardening imparted by certain abrasives or techniques.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#13

Question

Al Goldstein

What about side-to-side sharpening?

That would put the groves, narrow or wide, parallel to the cutting edge rather than perpendicular. How would this affect the rate of edge dulling? TIA

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#14

Re: Some notions

david weaver

I agree with all of that. i think to have a real answer about it, though, someone has to put in the sweat work with boards all from the same tree and count strokes.

I'm just too lazy to do it.

Everything I have ever seen describing the increase in longevity is a statement of quantity of work done, but it's never compared to something else.

When I tested a couple of A2 irons in maple, I did two things:

1) Every hundred strokes (or some number like that) I examined what the iron was doing, and made comments about the surface. I made notes then of when I would've actually sharpened if I were using the iron to smooth (this was somewhere in the ballpark of 400-500 feet of planed wood)

2) I made note of the point where the iron actually stopped cutting and wouldn't take a .002" shaving. This point was, depending on the iron, between about 1100 and 1800 feet of maple.

I planed on the edge for two reasons:

1) consistency

2) laziness

I did it twice for each iron. It was an incredible amount of time and boredom.

I think if we could get someone to do this five times with a natural stone edge and 5 times with a similar sharpness synthetic edge, we could figure out whether or not the burnishing of the edge improves durability a lot (in terms of number, both items above, too - when would you sharpen, and also when does the plane actually stop cutting), or if it in fact does at all.

It would be a torture test. I've never seen anything measured in actual output on relative terms provided, though.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#15

Re: Question

david weaver

That's a good question, it could certainly be an option.

brent beach had a comment about this on his site, where he mentioned that he had small long (along the length of the edge) shallow fractures on the edge of the iron he was using as opposed to narrow deep ones in the direction of the abrasions on a "normally" sharpened iron.

I know Derek has mentioned that he hasn't seen that, but I saw something similar on my irons about the same time I was doing a durability test of a couple of A2 irons (someone loaned me the side sharpening video at the same time).

I never did push it to the limit, though, to see if it actually made a difference in the number of strokes.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#16

Re: More

James Watriss

That's consistent with my experience with water stones. Other abrasives leave a shiny, mirror like surface the bevels of my Japanese chisels. With higher grit water stones, the softer metal (wrought iron, mild steel, whatever else) develops a haze, as if the smaller abrasions were bring scrubbed away instead of burnished over.

Re: Edge Longevity by Abrasive - Any Difference?

#17

Re: More

david weaver

I'll sharpen one of mine on my barber hone sometime this weekend if I can remember (which is a vintage ozaki mine stone out of a barber shop, it is the finest natural stone I have ever seen of any type).

It, too, (IIRC) will create a bright shiny bevel.

My favorite suita stone will leave a medium polish on the hard steel and a matte finish on the backing iron. But the barber stone doesn't release anything, and it brings everything up to a polish.

It doesn't make an edge any more keen than the sigma power 13k, though I can feel that the edge itself is less harsh on my face (fewer weepers and less irritation).

The suita stone will make a nice edge (looking at it, it's probably a narutaki suita, but I'm not sure of the mine because the stamp is long gone), but if I am being honest with people, it only approaches the keen edge that a very good synthetic stone has on steels that are well matched to it (it is a very good white steel stone). It is a relatively expensive stone, though, I wouldn't bother people with comparisons to subpar natural stones.